Re: Paolo Maldini says Marcelo is the best LB

by Valkyrja Tue 18 Sep 2012, 22:48

Saying Marcelo isn't the best LB in the world by far is like saying Messi and Cristiano aren't the best players in the world.

Top 15 player in the world.

by Albiceleste Tue 18 Sep 2012, 22:51

a deflected goal doesn't change the fact he is an inconsistent and bad defender. inb4 youtube clip or gif of a random tackle to 'prove' me wrong

by Mamad Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:07

best LB bar none.

by guest7 Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:19

Albiceleste wrote: a deflected goal doesn't change the fact he is an inconsistent and bad defender. inb4 youtube clip or gif of a random tackle to 'prove' me wrong

by Ganso Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:34

Albiceleste wrote: a deflected goal doesn't change the fact he is an inconsistent and bad defender. inb4 youtube clip or gif of a random tackle to 'prove' me wrong

yes,lets ignore the rest of the game

no fullback in the world is solid defensively nowadays and no fullback is half as good as marcelo going forward

by Arquitecto Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:46

Kizu wrote:Saying Marcelo isn't the best LB in the world by far is like saying Messi and Cristiano aren't the best players in the world.

Top 15 player in the world.

So Marcelo is the greatest LB in the world? Are you out of your mind or your just trolling?

Ganso wrote:
Albiceleste wrote: a deflected goal doesn't change the fact he is an inconsistent and bad defender. inb4 youtube clip or gif of a random tackle to 'prove' me wrong
yes,lets ignore the rest of the game

no fullback in the world is solid defensively nowadays and no fullback is half as good as marcelo going forward

Maybe cause Marcelo cannot be classified as a LB considering he has the defensive ability of Antonini. He is a LW or LWB at best.

by urbaNRoots Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:50

If Marcelo is the best LB then Andre Santos should be second as he's as bad as Marcelo at defending and half decent attacker.

by Ganso Tue 18 Sep 2012, 23:52

Santos is worse at defending,average passer and definitely not as good at the final third.

Also he is so prone at making defensive mistakes,like losing the ball,while marcelo rarely does it

by Valkyrja Wed 19 Sep 2012, 00:08

Marcelo improved dramatically defensively in the last 2 years. He is caught out of position sometimes, but his tackling is very good. He is only 24 and he is already the best by far.

by guest7 Wed 19 Sep 2012, 00:17

Let's just ignore the expert opinions of Paolo Maldini, Ashley Cole and Maradona :coffee:

Obviously he is shit. His performances vs Barca, City and Bayern were crap aswell :coffee:

by Ganso Wed 19 Sep 2012, 00:50

rofl,epic avatar is epic

by Arquitecto Wed 19 Sep 2012, 00:58

Kizu wrote:Marcelo improved dramatically defensively in the last 2 years. He is caught out of position sometimes, but his tackling is very good. He is only 24 and he is already the best by far.

Improved dramatically? So how far in the spectrum of defensive incompetence was he 2 years before? And he still is an incompetent defender.

Being adept in attack does not equate to being the "BEST LB IN THE WORLD". There are several LBs overall better than him.

Se7en wrote:Let's just ignore the expert opinions of Paolo Maldini, Ashley Cole and Maradona

Obviously he is shit. His performances vs Barca, City and Bayern were crap aswell

Must I bring up the amount of legends who have made piss poor judgements when selecting defensive personnel? Laughing

And the fact that Maradona is being used as an indicator is just lol.

by the xcx Wed 19 Sep 2012, 01:20

Haters..Madrid can never have any Wc players..Its always some scrub club that ends up with a WC rb or a midfielder Mad

by The Sanchez Wed 19 Sep 2012, 03:56

Se7en wrote:Let's just ignore the expert opinions of Paolo Maldini, Ashley Cole and Maradona

Obviously he is shit. His performances vs Barca, City and Bayern were crap aswell

Thanks. Your exactly right :coffee:

by McAgger Wed 19 Sep 2012, 05:33

I'm wondering who you guys are considering to be better than Marcelo if he's not the best??

by BarrileteCosmico Wed 19 Sep 2012, 06:30

But... but... but... Ramos is his heir!

by Zealous Wed 19 Sep 2012, 11:06

Ramos is his heir as a CB :coffee:

Anyway Marcelo is the best in his position and as a a pure footballer better than most midfielders as well.

by Arquitecto Wed 19 Sep 2012, 11:53

Zealous wrote:Ramos is his heir as a CB

Anyway Marcelo is the best in his position and as a a pure footballer better than most midfielders as well.

As a pure footballer better than most wingers, not midfielders.

And you haven't explained how can he be remotely the best in his position if he cannot defend to save his life.

by Mamad Wed 19 Sep 2012, 11:56

And you haven't explained how can he be remotely the best in his position if he cannot defend to save his life.

He can defend to save his life.

by Arquitecto Wed 19 Sep 2012, 11:59

Mamad wrote:
And you haven't explained how can he be remotely the best in his position if he cannot defend to save his life.

He can defend to save his life.

Damn... You really really have me convinced here. But I'll just ignore all the times any half decent winger/forward turns him inside out.

But continue thinking Marcelo is a LB

by Ganso Wed 19 Sep 2012, 12:08

But who is better?I have seen cole and lahm get roasted a lot recently,Marcelo was great defensively and offensively vs bayern,barca and now city.evra?not even close.coentrao can't even bench him. I just struggle to start thinking of other options

by guest7 Wed 19 Sep 2012, 12:17

Marcelo can defend, he is just abit inconsistent with it imo. Can't defend unless it's a big team lol

by Arquitecto Wed 19 Sep 2012, 12:40

Ganso wrote:But who is better?I have seen cole and lahm get roasted a lot recently,Marcelo was great defensively and offensively vs bayern,barca and now city.evra?not even close.coentrao can't even bench him. I just struggle to start thinking of other options

Lahm is a RB.

Who is better as an overall package?

Criscito
Cole (far far more consistent defensively)
Emilio Izaguirre
Naxto Monreal
Jon Aurtunexte
Felipe
Zanetti
Santon (better defensively of course)

Bayern? He was roasted as the Allianz Arena by Robben (who failed with his end product) and came on from the bench in the Bernebeu. In the latter his biggest contribution was a disgraceful challenge.

City? He wasn't even tested considering City were playing a completely narrow counter with the wide forwards going central.

How does Barca count considering 70% against Barca he has been utterly humiliated while the rest of the time its against Sanchez (who can't even beat Mesbah).

Point is he is not a LB from anywhere as he is a WC Left winger.

Mourinho has created a superb system which allows to maximize from Marcelo's strengths and minimize from his weaknesses as this doesn't only involves Khedira doing most of the defensive work for him

by Mamad Wed 19 Sep 2012, 13:06

Arquitecto wrote:
Mamad wrote:
And you haven't explained how can he be remotely the best in his position if he cannot defend to save his life.

He can defend to save his life.

Damn... You really really have me convinced here. But I'll just ignore all the times any half decent winger/forward turns him inside out.

But continue thinking Marcelo is a LB

When he wants to defend and he sticks to his position and not going forward he is really good at defending. he showed it against Barca, Bayern and other big teams. against quality wingers.

The problem with him is he is out of position a lot and that's because he goes forward too much. but when he sticks to his position he can defend much better than what you think.

People are unfair toward Marcelo. someone dribbles him and he is shat but for other LB's its just OK to be dribbled a few times.

by Ganso Wed 19 Sep 2012, 13:26

What are you talking about arq?Coentrao was the one who got roasted at the alianz,Marcelo didn't even play until he came on the second half to play as a winger.He started at the bernabeu and completely bossed robben and lahm.And he was fantastic like everyone else at the supercup,Sanchez was useless.

by Abramovich Wed 19 Sep 2012, 15:18

Alaba>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

by Sponsored content