Is Pep correct to oust Hart?

he was given the job before the season was over, he must have watched hart to know whether or not he wants him. i agree with many people on here that the whole "goalie should be able to use his feet" thing is overstated and isn't of huge significance in getting points let alone winning the title. however, if that's what a coach wants, then so be it. a coach should go for what he feels is right, not what the fans, director, president or whoever feel.

if bravo is messing up and hart's still not getting shine cos of personal reasons or because the manager doesn't want to admit his decision was foolish, then that's a different case. then it becomes about ego and trying to save face, no longer about business

Hapless_Hans wrote:

sportsczy wrote:ffs, Pep is not the most "successful" coach in Bayern history...  just based on facts alone:

Lattek - 9 seasons
6 Bundi titles
3 Cups
1 CL
1.11 trophies per season

Hitzfeld - 7 seasons
5 Bundi titles
4 Cups
1 CL
1.43 trophies per season

Heynckes -  6 seasons
3 Bundi
1 Cup
1 CL
0.83 trophies per season

Pep - 3 seasons
3 Bundi
2 Cup
1.66 trophies per season

IMO, CL trumps Bundi...  especially in today's Bundi that is non-competitive.  Hitzfeld is the most "successful" if you're just looking at major trophy stats anyhow.

And please don't bring up the garbage supercups, cwc and other nonsense.

Pep won 2 cups.

Exactly. Corrected for you Sportczy. Also, as mentioned, he has tons of other credentials that prove he is the best. He didn't win a CL... in 3 years. Big deal. It's not like Alex Fergusson not winning one in 15.

Pep is a monster league coach... and CL coach. let's not forget that he already has 2 in just 7 seasons of coaching. Best win % either at 28%. A pitty it will go down at City where I very much doubt he has any chance to win another one.

ahem...a real Serie A corner with real Serie A pressure?