How good is Joe Hart?

Best in the world
Top 5-10 in the world
Best in the Pl
Top 5 in the Pl
Average
Overrated

Where do you think Hart lies from these options i think top 5-10 in the world is just about right.

Best in the PL and top 5-10 in the World.

Overrated by the media, seen him referred to as the best GK in the world numerous times by SKY pundits.

I'd say he's top 5 in the PL.

overrated, but extremely good. probably 10-20 range?

Best in PL, top5-10 world (Casillas, Neuer, Buffon, Lloris, Cech, Hart)

He's overrated by the British media. One of the best in PL, but not the best. Lloris, Cech, Hart, and to some extent Reina (if he gets himself together) are all pretty much equal imo. Arguably Top 10 in the world.

Messiah "Aggerswagger" wrote:He's overrated by the British media. One of the best in PL, but not the best. Lloris, Cech, Hart, and to some extent Reina (if he gets himself together) are all pretty much equal imo. Arguably Top 10 in the world.

Lloris needs to beat Friedel first to be considered in that list

Friedel in top 5?

there is no overrating by the media. hart is the best in the PL, and top 5-10 in the world

Overrated.

Legend wrote:

Messiah "Aggerswagger" wrote:He's overrated by the British media. One of the best in PL, but not the best. Lloris, Cech, Hart, and to some extent Reina (if he gets himself together) are all pretty much equal imo. Arguably Top 10 in the world.

Lloris needs to beat Friedel first to be considered in that list

Well Lloris needs to be given at least one game to be able to beat Friedel. He hasn't even debuted yet for Spurs, it's kind of hard to displace someone from the team if you aren't even given a chance..amirite?

2nd in the PL behind Cech, and top 5-10 worldwide

Best goalkeeper in the Premier League last season, with Krul and Vorm just behind. No way was Cech close to those three. It's even debatable which order anyone would have them placed in. Also, the people that say he's overrated and mention Lloris and Reina - it seems slightly ironic. Lloris can't even deal with crosses yet and is very poor at dictating his own area, whilst Reina hasn't been at his best since 10/11 (arguably 09/10. And, no, inserting a condition like "if he gets back to his best" doesn't place him above Hart...

I think he's a very good keeper but English Media assess him too highly. I would say he's probably the best in the PL but he's low in my top 10 GKs of the world .for me.

I dont know why you guys think he is overrated, he is the best GK in EPL and top 5 in the world.

Best GK in the EPL they said

Top 5-10 in the world they said

Firenze wrote:Best GK in the EPL they said

Top 5-10 in the world they said

did a good job mate

his defense let him down

he wish he had steve bould

the last goal was

city were lucky to have him tonight, had 1 slip up but made some wc saves all night, particularly that first one he had - ronaldos shot and higgys header from a yard out.

Yeah, he was actually top class tonight, well, barring that huge feck up.

best in the PL they said...he is top 5 in the world he said.

that save against bezema
nothing he could've done aside from the ronaldo goal....but then it dipped D: and bounced.

Anyone who blames him for last goal is fked up , Kompany should have kicked that ball out .

pUsHa wrote:Anyone who blames him for last goal is fked up , Kompany should have kicked that ball out .

ya talk about overrated epl players, kompany looked like ronaldos doormat all match

This is what happens when you play an Argentine as a defender why sub Maicon with Zabaleta. because of yellow i think