best method in rating certain player in 1 match

what is the best method in rating certain player in 1 match?

1) full video in 1 match
pros:
had everything you can find for in measuring how good the player is
con:
its hard to focus certain player unless you edit this full video & just focus the certain player that you want to rate

2) video on  certain player in 1 match
pros:
easier to measuring how good the player is
con:
this video can be considered flaw when you only edited & show only the good part of the certain player. It should be everything that player did on the pitch whether it was good or bad

3) stat
pros:
goal, assist, tackle, keeper save etc stat can be use in measuring how good the player is
con:
usually the stat tell only a part of the stories. Its hard to find the stat that tell everything that happen on the pitch. There is no stat on the strength or weakness of the opponent player they faced in the match (example)

anything that you want to add?

The best method?

Actually having good knowledge of football.

Phritz wrote:The best method?

Actually having good knowledge of football.

that is very subjective

some feel they have enough knowledge of it but in reality, it is not

some did have the knowledge of it, but when it comes to conclusion, they give the wrong one

in the end, i still feel the amount of knowledge is very subjective

let me add some more

4) commentator on that match
pros:
it helps if the commentator is good in judging player
con:
if the commentator is not good in judging player, it will give a wrong impression on that player

Use the eye test.

Dice.

All of the above, but I think star signs should be a parameter, too.
For example, Scorpios in general should not be trusted, while with a Leo in defense you always have to be prepared for errors made out of vanity.

In doubt ask a competent, knowledgable, proven and good-looking (this doesn't actually matter but it also doesn't hurt) football expert of your choice. For example: me.

Casciavit wrote:Use the eye test.

sometime the person that have a healthy eye can give the wrong conclusion on certain player

Art Morte wrote:Dice.

dice no.6 shows that the player is world class?

Hapless_Hans wrote:All of the above, but I think star signs should be a parameter, too.
For example, Scorpios in general should not be trusted, while with a Leo in defense you always have to be prepared for errors made out of vanity.

i quite agree if the combination of above methods can help us in measuring the quality of certain player

sometimes, games rating like in pes & fifa can help for the beginner that want to start following the football

but i'm not sure about the star sign

Fußball wrote:In doubt ask a competent, knowledgable, proven and good-looking (this doesn't actually matter but it also doesn't hurt) football expert of your choice. For example: me.

your perspective still help us in thinking out of the box about certain player, majority of it made sense