#1 - Manuel Neuer

diptiman wrote:btw rwo, vivast and idro you should read what bleacherreport thinks about the german team if you havent read it already on the other topic, funny quotes from other forums

Idrisozet wrote:

diptiman wrote:btw rwo, vivast and idro you should read what bleacherreport thinks about the german team if you havent read it already on the other topic, funny quotes from other forums

I was among the first to read it, but didn't find it funny..... Neither can I take it seriously.

VivaStPauli wrote:BTW double-lol at the thread for calling some sinking ship bigger than Bayern Munich and trying to argue with Idrithingy.

Good luck.

Cassius_Case wrote:WC keeper like should have gone some place better where he would have recieved a much more deserved and welcoming reception, unlike some unclassy Munich fans gave him when he first joined.

Plus! he is much better than Valdes, Cech, DDG, Cesar, Krul, Abbiati, Ect so he could have gone to anyone of these bigger clubs from different league's and would of been a fan favorite from day one!

Also he would have had more chances to win some real silverware instead of a petty Bundesliga title.

Dont get me wrong, im a fan of the bundes but lets face it, its a one horse race every year with the occasional hiccup and a true WC performer like himself should be testing himself in a more competative league.

So it brings me to conclude, Do Bayern deserve such a top class keeper after the way he was taunted and forced to agree to a list of stupid and pathetic demands by the bayern faithful, such as he may never kiss the badge of the shirt ect?

Here is a list of the demands as i cannot post the link due to being new to the forum.

The rules are reportedly as follows:

1) Neuer must never simulate or initiate the team's megaphone chants.

2) Neuer must not kneel before the team and sing the 'Humba' song.

3) Neuer is prohibited from approaching the South Stand fence.

4) Neuer should not throw his shirt into the South Stand.

5) Neuer may not kiss the Bavarian crest

Would have you or your team treated such class in in such a distasteful way?

Discuss

Nirgall wrote:

Cassius_Case wrote:WC keeper like should have gone some place better where he would have recieved a much more deserved and welcoming reception, unlike some unclassy Munich fans gave him when he first joined.

Plus! he is much better than Valdes, Cech, DDG, Cesar, Krul, Abbiati, Ect so he could have gone to anyone of these bigger clubs from different league's and would of been a fan favorite from day one!

Also he would have had more chances to win some real silverware instead of a petty Bundesliga title.

Dont get me wrong, im a fan of the bundes but lets face it, its a one horse race every year with the occasional hiccup and a true WC performer like himself should be testing himself in a more competative league.

So it brings me to conclude, Do Bayern deserve such a top class keeper after the way he was taunted and forced to agree to a list of stupid and pathetic demands by the bayern faithful, such as he may never kiss the badge of the shirt ect?

Here is a list of the demands as i cannot post the link due to being new to the forum.

The rules are reportedly as follows:

1) Neuer must never simulate or initiate the team's megaphone chants.

2) Neuer must not kneel before the team and sing the 'Humba' song.

3) Neuer is prohibited from approaching the South Stand fence.

4) Neuer should not throw his shirt into the South Stand.

5) Neuer may not kiss the Bavarian crest

Would have you or your team treated such class in in such a distasteful way?

Discuss

Why was he, specifically, made to agree with this rules? What's wrong with a player kissing the "bavarian badge"?

diptiman wrote:it depends on how big the rivalry between munchen ahd shalke is.. is it as intense as madrid -barca and old firm?

Idrisozet wrote:

Cassius_Case wrote:

supra969 wrote:just ultras ignore that shit

Does that stuff normally happen?

To the guy who said this is a multi account, NO. real questions.
And to be fair, if you think newcastle is bigger than Juventus and liverpool then i bet you were one of those retarded bayern fans who gave stick to Manny.

Shocking

I am Neuer's number one fan, I openly called him a "play-maker goalkeeper" and I still stand by it. (Not a "Playmaker" but a "playmaker goalkeeper", I hope you can draw a distinction between those two.)

Yeah for sure when I look at Newcastle starting eleven I am force to say we(Newcastle) have a better team than Juventus and Liverpool. say for example I can back my claim with how epl league table currently stand(Newcastle clearly ahead of Liverpool)

Also Newcastle has done much more better in transfer than Juventus and Liverpool, say for example.

Demba-----Pappis>>>>>>>>Juventus attack

I know it hurts but that's the fact.

kiranr wrote:
Just for your info Cassius, Valdes is untouchable at Barcelona..

kiranr wrote:
There may be keepers with better ability and talent, but Valdes has been playing for Barcelona for so long that, any keeper, including Neuer, would struggle to fill Valdes' shoes.

supra969 wrote:

kiranr wrote:
There may be keepers with better ability and talent, but Valdes has been playing for Barcelona for so long that, any keeper, including Neuer, would struggle to fill Valdes' shoes.

maybe but can valdes walk in duke nukem's shoes ??

VivaStPauli wrote:But why would Barca spend money on a keeper when their possession-style means they barely need one and Valdes is half-decent?

(In fact I'd even say Valdes is a good 'keeper.)

VivaStPauli wrote:But why would Barca spend money on a keeper when their possession-style means they barely need one and Valdes is half-decent?

(In fact I'd even say Valdes is a good 'keeper.)

supra969 wrote:i rate valdes highly possibly higher than iker but i hate the lad
when ever im playing fifa he turns into a god out of 37 shots on target only one went in