rank these players

VibeTribe wrote:

Omniscient wrote:Henry
CR7
Shevchenko
ADP
Villa

DeviAngel wrote:Del Piero
Sheva
Henry
C.Ronaldo
Villa

C.Ronaldo has done nothing more than ADP ffs adp stayed in 2nd league for love og his club and he is lowest earner in juve ... and CR above him ? lmaoo

Skill is being compared here, not dedication or class. ADP is nowhere near CR7 in skill.

LMAO

With Ronaldo's physical capability Del Piero would be the better by a mile.

But he doesn't have ronaldo's physical capability, no ifs and buts.

Henry
ADP
CR7
sheva
villa

Choosing between ADP and Henry :S

Ah well

Henry
ADP
CR7
Sheva
Villa ( why is he here lol ? )

cr7 at 26 has already surpassed them all imo its still close so I understand that people rank Henry and Del Piero above him since its person preference.

But lets compare Henry and CR7 (mainly club performances)

Henry 33
top scorer PL 2003-04 - 30 goals
top scorer PL 2004-05 25 goals
top scorer 2005-06 27 goals

0 ballon d'or s-
2nd 2002-03
3rd in 2005-06

Arsenal 174 league goals from 254 matches (playing striker)
Barcelona 35 goals in 80 matches (playing LW)



Arsenal FA Premier League: 2
FA Cup: 3
FA Community Shield: 2

Barcelona La Liga: 2

Copa del Rey: 1
Supercopa de España: 1
UEFA Champions League: 1
UEFA Super Cup: 1
FIFA Club World Cup: 1


C. Ronaldo 26
top scorer 2007-08 PL 31 goals(playing as RM)
top scorer 2010-11 BBVA 40 goals(playing as LW)

1 ballon'dor 2007/08
second place 2006-07,2008-09

Manchester United 196 games (84 goals)
Real Madrid 76 games (82 goals)


Manchester United
Premier League: 2006/2007, 2007/2008, 2008/2009
UEFA Champions League: 2007/2008
FA-Cupen: 2003/2004
Engelska ligacupen: 2005/2006, 2008/2009
FA Community Shield: 2006,2007
Fifa club worldcup: 2008
´
Real Madrid: broken Copa del Rey

Sticking to club form because Henry has a World Cup and Euro to his name as well as the other mentioned accolades, eh?

Slick

Lex wrote:Sticking to club form because Henry has a World Cup and Euro to his name as well as the other mentioned accolades, eh?

Slick

France was an empire of talant during Henry's time so its unfair to judge from NT point of view. With players like Makelele, Zidane, Viera, Trezeguet etc are you seriously gonna compare that to Ronaldo's portugal with players like postiga nani and meireles

The clubs they both played has similar talanted players so its far more fair to compare from that view.

Ronaldo does'nt have Va Va Voom



/thread

Portugal weren't exactly wallflowers not too long ago, with a prime Carvalho, Figo, Deco, Ricardo featuring in several tournaments together

Lex wrote:Portugal weren't exactly wallflowers not too long ago, with a prime Carvalho, Figo, Deco, Ricardo featuring in several tournaments together

No way you can even compare portugal to france, france shits all over portugal

1- Henry/Del Piero
2- Shevchenko
3- Ronaldo
4- Villa

xabi wrote:cr7 at 26 has already surpassed them all imo its still close so I understand that people rank Henry and Del Piero above him since its person preference.

you have never watched ADP or Henry at their prime. So yea, stick with the stats. Its not really a "personal Preference" when 90% of the sane football fans would pick ADP over Ronaldo.

When Villa gets ranked higher than Ronaldo you know shrinks exist for a reason.

1. Henry
2. ADP
3. CR7
4. Sheva
99. Villa


Just wait until CR7 has ended his career. Henry and ADP have nearly ended theirs.

Eh again..you can not compare old m.u team and this madrid galactico with Arsenal..Prime henry would win ballon dor several times if he played for those team
Goals or stats means nothing by time. maradona zidane platini kryuff etc they remembered for their performances and titles. Great scorers like Jardel, V.Nisterloy, Kempes nobody puts them on their level. even romario scored more than 1000 goals, but still its not enough for him to be in that level. Klose almost World Cup top scorer of all time

Proves that Performance>Stats

Henry was better player than CR7. henry could do what cr does plus he has vision and passing he could participate in build ups. reason that henry didnt win ballon dor because he never win CL with Arsenal

RealGunner wrote:Villa ( why is he here lol ? )

Cause he barley makes the S Tier.

billionmillion wrote:Proves that Performance>Stats

I completely agree.

billionmillion wrote:Henry was better player than CR7.

I don't agree.

Omniscient wrote:

Skill is being compared here, not dedication or class. ADP is nowhere near CR7 in skill.

ADP is pure class and I would say has more skill on the ball than Ronaldo. Also, Del Piero's skill leads to more success; whereas Ronaldo is more of a physical beast.

Henry
Del Piero
CR7
Villa
Shevchenko