Sol Campbell vs John Terry

Who is the better defender?

Terry because he has been more consistent than him.

english_jewel wrote:Terry because he has been more consistent than him.

Acceptable answer but do you have more concrete reason? Anyway, just vote

Big Sol fore me, I am sure you know why.

*Bump* After all this time, no vote for Campbell? Campbell has all the right to be compared to Terry. Both lost a CL final, won a league in superconvincing manners and several other cups as well, both have partnered Ferdinand, both are rugged strong tussling no nonsense CB. Terry is more consistent helped a bit by the fact of having a dominating team with great solidity of a foundation under Mourinho. Campbell in his time was also great as well, and albeit not as much as Terry was consistent. Campbell was faster than Terry. So, it's still so super strange with many gunners voting the invincibles, noone cared for the commanding defender, except well the yours truly above me Anyway they're oh so comparable and both have own strengths and weaknesses, so let's pick up where we left off