Rank our Squad: Season 2011/12

Ive been inspired by LWL91's thread of ranking players lol so here i put together where each of our players ranks and then il put an overall rank of a particular area eg. Defence. please take part guys and i hope it starts much discussion! as always lets keep it clean


Buffon A
Manninger C+
Storari A


Bonucci C+
Chiellini A
Lichsteiner B+
De Ceglie B
Grosso C
Motta E
Barzagli C+
Sorensen C+


Vidal B
Pirlo A
Marchisio B
Pazienza C+
Marrone D+
--------------
Estigarribia D+
Krasic B+
Elia B
Pepe C+
Giaccherini C+

Attack:

Del Piero A
Matri A
Quagliarella B
Amauri F (yeh thats right!!!)
Iaquinta B
Vucinic A
Toni C+

Iaquinta B?

sciacca wrote:Iaquinta B?

HE'S GOOD LOL

Of course he's good, but he's useless and injury prone now lol..

sciacca wrote:Of course he's good, but he's useless and injury prone now lol..

cmon man, he can still play a part. whenever he played last year he did really well. he definately deserves another go unlike amauri

Haha.. Yeah I am a great inspiration i know

Agree with Sciacca, Iaquinta is not a B.. Not if you rate Marchisio a B.. HOW DARE YOU! Marchisio is, lol, WORLD CLASS!!!!!

Meet Iaquinta..



Note the title "going in circles"

Who on earth gave this a neg rep? He did great work regardless if you agree or not with the ratings... I gave it a +1

Del Piero A
Matri A
Vucinic A

Ganso wrote:Del Piero A
Matri A
Vucinic A

Matri = 20(Top 5 in Serie A)
Del Piero did great when he was called upon regardless, his leadership, experience, skill helped out win many games.
Vucinic has been our best striker this pre-season and has been great with Roma

LOL @ Motta (E for Effort)
I agree with most
but
Attackers:
Quagliarella: A
The man is a great finisher & I believe he & Matri are gonna be fighting for that staring spot all season long.
Midfielders:
Pepe: B
Give the man some credit...he saved our ass against Fiorentina this season with that stunning freekick

+1 pasquale, nice job, i would give chiellini A- or B+ cz he was mistaken in alotta goals on us last season

If Amauri deserves an F,Iaquinta deserves pretty much the same too..

Both are pretty useless in their own ways..Amauri goes goalless for almost a year,whilst Iaquinta on an average plays a game per year..

I disagree with your ranking of quite a few players in that list..Its a bit too tedious to discuss it so i'll leave it here..

Amauri is great but not for juve especially now since hes unmotivated so F is fair. Toni deserves better since hes a great sub and motivated, same with Quagliarella. You cant even rate new players cuz u dont even know how they will do for juve and if they would be a sub or starter.

sciacca wrote:Who on earth gave this a neg rep? He did great work regardless if you agree or not with the ratings... I gave it a +1

Damn right!

Keepers:


Buffon A-
Manninger C+
Storari B+

Defence:

Bonucci B
Chiellini A
Lichsteiner B+
De Ceglie B
Grosso C+
Motta E
Barzagli C
Sorensen B+

Midfield:

Vidal B+
Pirlo A-
Marchisio B
Pazienza C+
Marrone D+
--------------
Estigarribia D+
Krasic A
Elia B+
Pepe B-
Giaccherini C+

Attack:

Del Piero A
Matri B
Quagliarella A
Amauri F (yeh thats right!!!)
Iaquinta F
Vucinic A-
Toni C+

In the end, everyone has his own opinion