Re: Best Player in the Premier League?

by IAmManUnited Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:22 am

Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

by Arquitecto Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:26 am

IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

OK bro, go to sleep.

by Ali Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:27 am

IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

woah there, you might'v forgotten our friends Suarez and Nasri

also if he had kept his form this season it would've easily been Cesc, I mean EASILY.

by IAmManUnited Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:32 am

Arquitecto wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

OK bro, go to sleep.

Hahah its def no one on liverpool i can tell u that much

by IAmManUnited Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:34 am

ali8775 wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

woah there, you might'v forgotten our friends Suarez and Nasri

also if he had kept his form this season it would've easily been Cesc, I mean EASILY.

Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

by Ali Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:37 am

IAmManUnited wrote:
ali8775 wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

woah there, you might'v forgotten our friends Suarez and Nasri

also if he had kept his form this season it would've easily been Cesc, I mean EASILY.

Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

what the frak are you talking bout, I mean Cesc would easily be the best, but his dribbling is not average , his close control is incredible and he has a turn that most players would dream of.

by Raptorgunner Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:40 am

IAmManUnited wrote:
ali8775 wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Rooney is the best player in the EPL, no question, his playmaking skills are very underrated despite the fact hes a WC finisher and has the vision of scholes.

Also to be fair, Nani is maybe the most skillfull player in the EPL

woah there, you might'v forgotten our friends Suarez and Nasri

also if he had kept his form this season it would've easily been Cesc, I mean EASILY.

Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

Dont forget Rooney is getting more money then Cesc and RVP put together Very Happy

I hope this does not turn in to another war thread. Rooney is my fav united player.

I think we all should get back to voting Very Happy

by Swanhends Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:41 am

IAmManUnited wrote:Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

Just wondering, how is that different from Rooney?

Substitute passing for shooting and yeah....

by Raptorgunner Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:43 am

bhends wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

Just wondering, how is that different from Rooney?

Substitute passing for shooting and yeah....

Lets not do this please.

by Gil Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:44 am

Rooney's long passing is outstanding to be fair.

by IAmManUnited Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:44 am

bhends wrote:
IAmManUnited wrote:Cesc is a good passer, nothing skilful outside that, his dribbling is average, his shooting is average, his passing is WC, so where does the easily part fit in?

Just wondering, how is that different from Rooney?

Substitute passing for shooting and yeah....

Have u not seen rooney pass? Are we seriously judging his long range and short range passing? Not being offensive but the dude is scholes-eque quality in passing...

by CBarca Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:49 am

BarrileteCosmico wrote:I voted for Modric, for the lulz

~~But I actually think it's Vidic~~

Welcome to the club.

Partly cause he's underrated (is he anymore?), but I do have a Modric shirt so...kinda had to.

I will correctly assume the second part as kidding and strike that for you mate.

Modric is now GODRIC.

by Swanhends Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:50 am

Gil wrote:Rooney's long passing is outstanding to be fair.

Aye, well aware that he can knock a brilliant mile-long pass every now and again...but lets not act like he's Paul Scholes doing it every other game...Rooney is more like once every two lunar cycles...

by El Chelsea Fuerte Wed Aug 03, 2011 4:33 am

vidic hands down

persie needs to be fit more often

by BeautifulGame Wed Aug 03, 2011 4:46 am

Surprised Van Der sar is not on the list.He was outstanding for United last year.

by El Chelsea Fuerte Wed Aug 03, 2011 5:03 am

BeautifulGame wrote:Surprised Van Der sar is not on the list.He was outstanding for United last year.

But he doesn't play in the PL.

by kiranr Wed Aug 03, 2011 6:08 am

Raptorgunner wrote:
van Persie became the first player to score in seven successive Premier League away games when he scored against Bolton, beating Didier Drogba's record who was on six successive away games, between August and November 2009.

van Persie managed to score in his ninth consecutive away match, bringing his goal tally for the season to a personal record of 18 league goals. He also equalled the record held by Cristiano Ronaldo and Thierry Henry by scoring 18 league goals from the turn of the year to the end of the season. He ended the season just two goals behind joint league top scorers, Carlos Tevez and Dimitar Berbatov in the race for the golden boot.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_van_Persie

This means he has been the best for half a season! In my opinion, until he plays an entire season, he will never be in the contention of being the best player. Fitness plays a huge role in ranking and Van Persie's poor fitness will always cost him!

by Babun Wed Aug 03, 2011 6:11 am

Fernando Torres because he used to own Nemanja Vidic Very Happy

by Vyey Wed Aug 03, 2011 7:38 am

I am bias

by Magricos Wed Aug 03, 2011 8:04 am

When was John Terry the best player in the PL ? confused

by El Chelsea Fuerte Wed Aug 03, 2011 8:06 am

Magricos wrote: When was John Terry the best player in the PL ?

When you weren't born.

by Iceman Wed Aug 03, 2011 8:25 am

bhends wrote:Yes, yes if we were holding a competition of who could score the most goals in half a season Van Persie would win...but the EPL plays full seasons, and Van Persie is physically incapable of playing a full season, so while you can marvel all you want about "Look how much Van Persie scored in only half a season!" please don't dare try to imply that should Van Persie play a full season, he could score twice as many goals (or anything like that) because we all know that he cannot, in fact, play a full season

If we're talking about potential and capability, then this post is pretty meaningless. Just sounds like someone is butthurt :coffee:

by LeSwagg James Wed Aug 03, 2011 9:28 am

Ameobi.........

by boss Wed Aug 03, 2011 9:51 am

Robin van Persie & Gareth Baleeeee...tHe bEst n most FAIR players..ever seen ...imo

by Red Alert Wed Aug 03, 2011 10:00 am

RVP is definitely up there. Not sure why people are choosing Rooney because of the second part of the EPL, and is leaving RVP in his shadows. RVP was about the same with Rooney, maybe even better. Neutral

Also, if Rooney wasn't playing for United, he'd definitely be loved by everone in the EPL. But, he does, so he's last on the list. :geek:

Anyway, Tevez for me. He's awesome. Very Happy

Well, after Suarez. =P

Probably would have said Fabregas a few months ago but Wenger has ruined him.

Wenger also made him.

The likes of Fernando Torres, Theirry Henry, Dennis Bergkamp, Zola, Cantona, Cristiano Ronaldo, Shearer, Lampard, Didier Drogba, John Terry etc could all claim to be the best in the past and most would agree but it's not like that these days is it?

No Gerrard? Really? He's never been the best in the past? Come on now...

by Freeza Wed Aug 03, 2011 10:08 am

Daniel Agger!! or at least he is good 2 weeks per year (the time when he isn't injured)

Probably Vidic or Suarez for me, both amazing in their own aspect

by Sponsored content

Best player in the EPL?