What do you guys think about this category?

https://i.imgur.com/najvmP4.jpg

Agree/disagree?

Iniesta should be one up imo

Sepp Maier needs to be up with the Titan. The Cat of Anzing was legendary

Yeh, if Xavi's in 'god tier' then Iniesta should be too.

That's actually a pretty good list.

Iniesta should be there indeed.

Theres alot that i disagree with that list. Scirea and Del Piero should be in the god list. Baggio should be in the GOAT list, as well as arguably Platini abd Garrincha. I think all 3 of them definitely deserve it over Zizou and R9.Xavi should be one lower. Kahn and Buffon should together, whether in the god or demi god list is arguable. Totti, Cannavaro, Thuram, and Casillas could all arguably be one higher. Other than those things though its a pretty good list.

juventus101 wrote:Theres alot that i disagree with that list. Scirea and Del Piero should be in the god list. Baggio should be in the GOAT list, as well as arguably Platini abd Garrincha. I think all 3 of them definitely deserve it over Zizou and R9.Xavi should be one lower. Kahn and Buffon should together, whether in the god or demi god list is arguable. Totti, Cannavaro, Thuram, and Casillas could all arguably be one higher. Other than those things though its a pretty good list.

.
the list can't be perfect. Overall, it's quite well done.
Iniesta and xavi together definitely
Sheva shouldn't be higher than eto'o ( same category )

I agree its pretty good and will never be perfect by everyones opinion. Also agree about Sheva and Etoo. They should be on the same level.

No Busquets

Litmanen so far up hurts my eyes big time.
Rivaldo should definitely be a tier upwards and Zidane, Ronaldo and Eusebio a tier down.

Maldini deserves Goat tier status.

Initesta and ADP are suffering down there in Demi-God tier.

And poor Gianni Rivera is suffering big-time down there in Great tier.

For some players in the same tier, you can clearly say that one was better than the other. E.g. Kaka v Rui Costa

And I think a few players who are completely absent from this list should be included. Even just going through some past Milan greats: None of the Gre-No-Li trio? Maldini and Baresi included, but Tassoti and Costacurta missing completely? Altafini?

Of course, nobody's going to make a perfect list, this is just my opinion.

This is a pretty damn good list. Some over/underrated there but again as most said its impossible to please everyone.

Im sad that no italians are in the GOAT tier. IMO, not having any defenders in there is not well rounded, but w/e... No heskey either

also, Sepp Maier was ugly as f*ck.

and seriously where the hell is Thuram?

Looks pretty good to me

lol at zidane and ronaldo in goat tier, they should be in god tier

dani alves should be in very good tier also, why is he not in the list?

REWB wrote:lol at zidane and ronaldo in goat tier, they should be in god tier

Ronaldo is arguably the greatest striker of all time

Ronaldo, Zidane should go down. Garrincha, Iniesta should go up. Possibly CR7 down though apart from that its pretty accurate.

Its an admirable attempt, but no I dont agree.

I also assume this is more based on peak performance and not so much titles and longeviety..which is something I actually like.

But still, no.

Either you dont put Kubala or you put him higher.

I dont think Zidane should be that high, I dont think he is better than Zico or Platini, but if he is, then he is closer to them than he is Cruyff and Pele for example.

Take Cristiano down, hes not better than at the very least half of the players a tier below.

Gerson and Villa too low..is it just me who cant see Romario or Socrates?

Litmannan and Redondo that high is pretty crazy to me, especially the former.

Oh and Beckham has no right being anywhere near this list...as good as Veira

It's nice to attempt this, and I'm sure it took some work.
But it's utterly flawed.

Underrating the likes of Platini, Puskas etc., completely forgetting about Gerd Müller, overrating R9 etc etc - there's just tons wrong with it.

Muller is in the 2nd tier, whats wrong with that?

But I protest the lowly rank of Sepp Maier!

I think its unfair for goalies to even be put in this, its impossible for them. Though I agree Maier is too low anyway.

Yeah, it an all-time injustice - goalies are never properly treated with the respect they are due!

Zidane is too high. Iniesta is too low. There is not a difference of 2 tiers between both and Platini was actually better than Zidane as well as is Xavi.

Henry doesn't belong in the God tier. 3 tiers above Spain's all-time top goalscorer? Don't think so.

Raul 2 tiers above David Villa as well? LOL

BatiGOL only a demi-god below Henry? Bergkamp same tier as Iniesta, Rivaldo, Rijkaard? Which Arsenal fan made this?

Scirea is too low.

Scholes is not in the same tier as Pirlo or Iniesta.

VDS 2 tiers below Kahn?

Eto'o 2 tiers below Henry?

Meh. Shit list.

Why even list Very Good players when there's no way you could even name 10% of them in that graphic?

Also Maldini deserves to be on Zidane's level. Either bump him up or bring Zidane down. A lot more I disagree with (Nilton Santos so low, no Bochini , why is rooney there but not ibra? ) but whatever, everyone would make a different list.