Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
+64
Rebaño Sagrado
RealGunner
danyjr
Eman
CBarca
braylann
harhar11
Bellabong
DuringTheWar
vizkosity
Ganso
altobelli
Cookie Monster
elm_baraja_shaman
Cotes
vivabarca38
BAYERN_MUNICH
Rabea
boss
Cruijf
TheRedStag
billy_gr
jibers
juventus101
:{Mr.Mustachio!
BarrileteCosmico
Patrick Bateman
messixaviesta
stefanobada
Tifoso Romanista
viepr149
free_cat
7amood11
aleumdance
Adit
Gil
The Franchise
guest7
Grande_Milano
Great Leader Sprucenuce
S
kiranr
Gemini
la bestia negra
Forza
ELO
sbaggio
Juveman17
leemhuis
Luca
Le Samourai
Die Borussen
C.Marchisio #8
Swanhends
Zealous
VivaStPauli
Arquitecto
Eivindo
Babun
The Messiah
Potential
rwo power
REWB
Onyx
68 posters
Page 4 of 14
Page 4 of 14 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9 ... 14
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:The other thing that should be mentioned, is Cassano drops deep when Italy are defending which will give them an ever greater number advantage.
You are all talking about Italy from a defensive stand point in midfield but how about going forward? With Cassano picking up Schweignsteiger and De Rossi and Marchisio picking up Khedira and Ozil.
The thing you are talking about mus'nt happen from a Germany standpoint happens again..... Pirlo is free with a cigar in his mouth.
That isn't being talked about because Khedira, Schweinsteiger and Ozil will just out run them. Italy don't want to get into a stamina match with Germany they will just flat out lose that. When you are the physically weaker side you don't man mark.
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:As mentioned before if Germany try to pass through Italy they will come unstuck in my eyes as also mentioned before Germany need to use the wingers and fullbacks as much as possible to drag out covering midfielders to expose Pirlo.
And they will do exactly that. Germany have shown they are very dynamic in attack, they can score a goal from almost any angle, left right or center of the pitch. The question will be can Italy keep up with that if they play a diamond. They did against England because England only attacked through one flank and they still couldn't restrict them to no clear chances.
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:What Italy need to do is the exact scenario i mentioned above... if Cassano drops deep and picks up Schweignsteiger ( like i think he will as he usually does) then Germany have a massive problem because the end result will be Pirlo will have massive loads of space.
All well and good in theory but are they actually physically up for it mole? This is still a sport after all.
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:Although this tactical view is only really relevant for the first 70 mins because Cassano and Ozil wont last much longer than that..... then the Coaches become important.
Ozil will maintain a high level for 90 minutes and he's done it before a bunch of times. For anyone who has watched him closly this stopped being an issue for a while now.
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:That's if the scoreline is close at this point anyway, if Balotelli has his shooting boots on it would probably be over by half time :lucas :
Actually how efficient Italy's front line is will be important, I don't think they can win if they score zero goals in thirty five attempts like last night lol
EDIT: I would like to add that Germany have looked weak on set pieces, something Italy have been quite decent at so this could be a factor.
Zealous- World Class Contributor
- Posts : 16098
Join date : 2011-08-01
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
I think the stamina would be an issue with Pirlo and Cassano only. Balo of course does not do much. But everyone else will be pretty much up for it and they are not physically weaker than the Germans.
kiranr- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 3496
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Lets get one thing straight, for all who mention Pirlo disappearing in Bernebeau during the first leg of the GS, Allegri was playing what is literally Milan's worst possible formation/line-up. It consisted of a 4-3-3 with Pirlo-Gattuso-Seedorf which was proven the worst possible midfield combination and formation.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
Arquitecto- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 12672
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
I already answered it in page two but again. Where did Italy dominate Germany in that friendly? Stats say otherwise. We had more possession+ more goal scoring chances. The one with the most key passes on the pitch was Özil.Arquitecto wrote:Lets get one thing straight, for all who mention Pirlo disappearing in Bernebeau during the first leg of the GS, Allegri was playing what is literally Milan's worst possible formation/line-up. It consisted of a 4-3-3 with Pirlo-Gattuso-Seedorf which was proven the worst possible midfield combination and formation.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
http://blogs.bettor.com/International-Friendly-Germany-vs-Italy-A-Tactical-analysis-a55453
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Balotelli is going to destroy Hummels and Badstuber.
But Germany will score 2/3 at the other end.
But Germany will score 2/3 at the other end.
Gil- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 9447
Join date : 2011-06-06
Age : 33
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Italy could throw all the numbers in midfield they still won't dominate possession. The reason is Germany uses free space wherever it's present. If Italy decide to pack the middle expect lots of Lahm overlapping and overloading of flanks. Italy will be forced to commit players for defending the flanks which will open up the middle. Their 3 men defence would have to stay deeper because Klose/ Gomez and Müller will make runs in behind 100%- The gap between Pirlo, their defence and attackers will get very big. Cassano dropping back isn't a problem because Hummels and Badstuber are excellent game openers.Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:The other thing that should be mentioned, is Cassano drops deep when Italy are defending which will give them an ever greater number advantage.
You are all talking about Italy from a defensive stand point in midfield but how about going forward? With Cassano picking up Schweignsteiger and De Rossi and Marchisio picking up Khedira and Ozil.
The thing you are talking about mus'nt happen from a Germany standpoint happens again..... Pirlo is free with a cigar in his mouth.
As mentioned before if Germany try to pass through Italy they will come unstuck in my eyes as also mentioned before Germany need to use the wingers and fullbacks as much as possible to drag out covering midfielders to expose Pirlo.
What Italy need to do is the exact scenario i mentioned above... if Cassano drops deep and picks up Schweignsteiger ( like i think he will as he usually does) then Germany have a massive problem because the end result will be Pirlo will have massive loads of space.
Although this tactical view is only really relevant for the first 70 mins because Cassano and Ozil wont last much longer than that..... then the Coaches become important.
That's if the scoreline is close at this point anyway, if Balotelli has his shooting boots on it would probably be over by half time :lucas :
They won't be able to dominate anything. It's like saying Manu would dominate Farca with 4-5-1 formation vs. 4-3-3 just because they have higher numbers in midfield
It's still 10 vs. 10. Germany's 10 uses the space a lot better than narrow Italian one. Marchisio, De Rossi etc. will be very busy with Özil and Khedira. They make fast runs to take markers away. Have fun tracking them with Marchisio and De Rossi alone
Also, Marchisio is overrated.
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Italy was playing away from home in Germany. The link you provided had no "stats" in it.
leemhuis- Banned (Permanent)
- Club Supported :
Posts : 923
Join date : 2011-09-07
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Immortal Babun wrote:Italy could throw all the numbers in midfield they still won't dominate possession. The reason is Germany uses free space wherever it's present. If Italy decide to pack the middle expect lots of Lahm overlapping and overloading of flanks. Italy will be forced to commit players for defending the flanks which will open up the middle. Their 3 men defence would have to stay deeper because Klose/ Gomez and Müller will make runs in behind 100%- The gap between Pirlo, their defence and attackers will get very big. Cassano dropping back isn't a problem because Hummels and Badstuber are excellent game openers.Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:The other thing that should be mentioned, is Cassano drops deep when Italy are defending which will give them an ever greater number advantage.
You are all talking about Italy from a defensive stand point in midfield but how about going forward? With Cassano picking up Schweignsteiger and De Rossi and Marchisio picking up Khedira and Ozil.
The thing you are talking about mus'nt happen from a Germany standpoint happens again..... Pirlo is free with a cigar in his mouth.
As mentioned before if Germany try to pass through Italy they will come unstuck in my eyes as also mentioned before Germany need to use the wingers and fullbacks as much as possible to drag out covering midfielders to expose Pirlo.
What Italy need to do is the exact scenario i mentioned above... if Cassano drops deep and picks up Schweignsteiger ( like i think he will as he usually does) then Germany have a massive problem because the end result will be Pirlo will have massive loads of space.
Although this tactical view is only really relevant for the first 70 mins because Cassano and Ozil wont last much longer than that..... then the Coaches become important.
That's if the scoreline is close at this point anyway, if Balotelli has his shooting boots on it would probably be over by half time :lucas :
They won't be able to dominate anything. It's like saying Manu would dominate Farca with 4-5-1 formation vs. 4-3-3 just because they have higher numbers in midfield
It's still 10 vs. 10. Germany's 10 uses the space a lot better than narrow Italian one. Marchisio, De Rossi etc. will be very busy with Özil and Khedira. They make fast runs to take markers away. Have fun tracking them with Marchisio and De Rossi alone
Also, Marchisio is overrated.
Of course, Italy does not have a chance against the great invincible Germans. All Italians are overrated, the Germans are underrated. And, all your LOLing at the Italians makes it even more clear to us that you have the knowledge and the expertise to explain how it will be impossible for Germany to lose.
leemhuis- Banned (Permanent)
- Club Supported :
Posts : 923
Join date : 2011-09-07
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Babun, if there is one thing Italy is good at, it is closing down space.
kiranr- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 3496
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Don't mention the friendly of February 2011. Germany was playing with Mertesacker and Aogo in defense - nothing good could come out of that
Here are the full line-ups: http://www.kicker.de/news/fussball/nationalelf/startseite/fussball-nationalteams-freundschaftsspiele/2011/1/1002269/spielanalyse_deutschland_italien-924.html
Here are the full line-ups: http://www.kicker.de/news/fussball/nationalelf/startseite/fussball-nationalteams-freundschaftsspiele/2011/1/1002269/spielanalyse_deutschland_italien-924.html
rwo power- Super Moderator
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20978
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
So much BS at once. Provide some insights. Empty banters don't interest me the leastleemhuis wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:Italy could throw all the numbers in midfield they still won't dominate possession. The reason is Germany uses free space wherever it's present. If Italy decide to pack the middle expect lots of Lahm overlapping and overloading of flanks. Italy will be forced to commit players for defending the flanks which will open up the middle. Their 3 men defence would have to stay deeper because Klose/ Gomez and Müller will make runs in behind 100%- The gap between Pirlo, their defence and attackers will get very big. Cassano dropping back isn't a problem because Hummels and Badstuber are excellent game openers.Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:The other thing that should be mentioned, is Cassano drops deep when Italy are defending which will give them an ever greater number advantage.
You are all talking about Italy from a defensive stand point in midfield but how about going forward? With Cassano picking up Schweignsteiger and De Rossi and Marchisio picking up Khedira and Ozil.
The thing you are talking about mus'nt happen from a Germany standpoint happens again..... Pirlo is free with a cigar in his mouth.
As mentioned before if Germany try to pass through Italy they will come unstuck in my eyes as also mentioned before Germany need to use the wingers and fullbacks as much as possible to drag out covering midfielders to expose Pirlo.
What Italy need to do is the exact scenario i mentioned above... if Cassano drops deep and picks up Schweignsteiger ( like i think he will as he usually does) then Germany have a massive problem because the end result will be Pirlo will have massive loads of space.
Although this tactical view is only really relevant for the first 70 mins because Cassano and Ozil wont last much longer than that..... then the Coaches become important.
That's if the scoreline is close at this point anyway, if Balotelli has his shooting boots on it would probably be over by half time :lucas :
They won't be able to dominate anything. It's like saying Manu would dominate Farca with 4-5-1 formation vs. 4-3-3 just because they have higher numbers in midfield
It's still 10 vs. 10. Germany's 10 uses the space a lot better than narrow Italian one. Marchisio, De Rossi etc. will be very busy with Özil and Khedira. They make fast runs to take markers away. Have fun tracking them with Marchisio and De Rossi alone
Also, Marchisio is overrated.
Of course, Italy does not have a chance against the great invincible Germans. All Italians are overrated, the Germans are underrated. And, all your LOLing at the Italians makes it even more clear to us that you have the knowledge and the expertise to explain how it will be impossible for Germany to lose.
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Immortal Babun wrote:I already answered it in page two but again. Where did Italy dominate Germany in that friendly? Stats say otherwise. We had more possession+ more goal scoring chances. The one with the most key passes on the pitch was Özil.Arquitecto wrote:Lets get one thing straight, for all who mention Pirlo disappearing in Bernebeau during the first leg of the GS, Allegri was playing what is literally Milan's worst possible formation/line-up. It consisted of a 4-3-3 with Pirlo-Gattuso-Seedorf which was proven the worst possible midfield combination and formation.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
http://blogs.bettor.com/International-Friendly-Germany-vs-Italy-A-Tactical-analysis-a55453
Babun you have provided me a word for word analysis which would be just as futile if I provided another word for word analysis favoring Italia.
Germany may have had more possession yet Italia simply looked better with the ball in my opinion. You could say Germany had the first half, but Italia was better in the 2nd.
Also there were 2 calls which Badstuber and Aogo fouled Italian players which wasn't given for some odd reason despite the blatancy of the tackles.
You may have your opinion yet Germany certainly did not dominate.
Great game though.
Arquitecto- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 12672
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Yeah, they're expert at it. The problem is they need the numbers to defend and stay close to their box. How do you expect them to dominate the game if they're busy defending? They could only counter and that's their best bet imo.kiranr wrote:
Babun, if there is one thing Italy is good at, it is closing down space.
If you say they'll set a very good counter formation and may win I agree but saying they'll dominate the proceedings= no chance.
We took the foot off the pedal in second half ( Özil, Schweini and Khedira had a CL next). Also, Aogo and MertesackerArquitecto wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:I already answered it in page two but again. Where did Italy dominate Germany in that friendly? Stats say otherwise. We had more possession+ more goal scoring chances. The one with the most key passes on the pitch was Özil.Arquitecto wrote:Lets get one thing straight, for all who mention Pirlo disappearing in Bernebeau during the first leg of the GS, Allegri was playing what is literally Milan's worst possible formation/line-up. It consisted of a 4-3-3 with Pirlo-Gattuso-Seedorf which was proven the worst possible midfield combination and formation.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
http://blogs.bettor.com/International-Friendly-Germany-vs-Italy-A-Tactical-analysis-a55453
Babun you have provided me a word for word analysis which would be just as futile if I provided another word for word analysis favoring Italia.
Germany may have had more possession yet Italia simply looked better with the ball in my opinion. You could say Germany had the first half, but Italia was better in the 2nd.
Also there were 2 calls which Badstuber and Aogo fouled Italian players which wasn't given for some odd reason despite the blatancy of the tackles.
You may have your opinion yet Germany certainly did not dominate.
Great game though.
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
rwo power wrote:Don't mention the friendly of February 2011. Germany was playing with Mertesacker and Aogo in defense - nothing good could come out of that
Here are the full line-ups: http://www.kicker.de/news/fussball/nationalelf/startseite/fussball-nationalteams-freundschaftsspiele/2011/1/1002269/spielanalyse_deutschland_italien-924.html
Both teams were playing near foreign line-ups as compared to now (although Germany's is closer) so a judgement of how the similarities will be to thursday will almost be unnecessary.
Arquitecto- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 12672
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
I agree, Italian midfield will not dominate possession over German midfield. Germany midfield is a class above Italian midfield which will be proved come 28th.Italia Out numbering in midfield is definitely a serious issue but you have to take into account that Germany's fullbacks will be unmarked as well which will help them dominate possession .
It is not a surprise that Italia has only scored one goal from open play in the whole tournament now. Their narrowness and trying over the top balls over and over again again again has made them predictable.I think Italia is strong defensively due to the numbers they put at the back but lacks offensive cutting edge due to the same reason ie not enough men in final third.
Ozil will be key this game. Pirlo is not defensively good enough to stop Ozil and if they let Pirlo alone deep i can see Ozil having a great game.
I think Germany should play Lahm at RB for this game. Him bombing throw right wing ,Rues dribbling and Ozil drifting to right wing will be too much for Italias left back who imo is average at best.
Italy cant play a deep line this time because Germany will have enough time on the ball and they have Gomez who can be used as a target.
It is not a surprise that Italia has only scored one goal from open play in the whole tournament now. Their narrowness and trying over the top balls over and over again again again has made them predictable.I think Italia is strong defensively due to the numbers they put at the back but lacks offensive cutting edge due to the same reason ie not enough men in final third.
Ozil will be key this game. Pirlo is not defensively good enough to stop Ozil and if they let Pirlo alone deep i can see Ozil having a great game.
I think Germany should play Lahm at RB for this game. Him bombing throw right wing ,Rues dribbling and Ozil drifting to right wing will be too much for Italias left back who imo is average at best.
Italy cant play a deep line this time because Germany will have enough time on the ball and they have Gomez who can be used as a target.
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
I don't care who wins
Just win spain
Just win spain
aleumdance- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 2943
Join date : 2011-12-11
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Immortal Babun wrote:Yeah, they're expert at it. The problem is they need the numbers to defend and stay close to their box. How do you expect them to dominate the game if they're busy defending? They could only counter and that's their best bet imo.kiranr wrote:
Babun, if there is one thing Italy is good at, it is closing down space.
If you say they'll set a very good counter formation and may win I agree but saying they'll dominate the proceedings= no chance.
But who said they will dominate? I think all of us expect that if Pirlo is not marked and gets the ball, then Germany is in trouble through counters and set-pieces. Germany will attack Italy from all sides and with lots of crosses as well.
It will be a fascinating match. If Italy get their tactics rights and the way Germany usually sets up, then there will be lots of action on the pitch with each team getting opportunities for the goal ( I expect Germany to get more chances).
kiranr- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 3496
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Immortal Babun wrote:Yeah, they're expert at it. The problem is they need the numbers to defend and stay close to their box. How do you expect them to dominate the game if they're busy defending? They could only counter and that's their best bet imo.kiranr wrote:
Babun, if there is one thing Italy is good at, it is closing down space.
If you say they'll set a very good counter formation and may win I agree but saying they'll dominate the proceedings= no chance.We took the foot off the pedal in second half ( Özil, Schweini and Khedira had a CL next). Also, Aogo and MertesackerArquitecto wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:I already answered it in page two but again. Where did Italy dominate Germany in that friendly? Stats say otherwise. We had more possession+ more goal scoring chances. The one with the most key passes on the pitch was Özil.Arquitecto wrote:Lets get one thing straight, for all who mention Pirlo disappearing in Bernebeau during the first leg of the GS, Allegri was playing what is literally Milan's worst possible formation/line-up. It consisted of a 4-3-3 with Pirlo-Gattuso-Seedorf which was proven the worst possible midfield combination and formation.
If closely followed during that time, this midfield couldn't even dictate against Bologna.
And Pirlo was marked out better by Alonso and not Ozil.
2nd leg was different where Pirlo was dictating the and wasn't really troubled by Ozil's intelligent marking off the ball.
And why is everyone talking about Germany's midfield vs Pirlo as if Pirlo is the only man in midfield?
Has anyone heard of Claudio Marchisio? A technically skilled beast who was vital to Juve's season? Danielle freaking De Rossi? A world class midfielder who is just as good as Schweinstieger?
Anyone see the Germany-Italia friendly where Germany wasn't exactly dominating? (Almost the opposite).
Point being in the end fatigue will be the main point in which is the downfall for Italia. The camp has already complained of fatigue through the tournament and given Italia had to run and gun till the end of extra time against England, Germany will have a substantial advantage there.
Also for this game, Cesare NEEDS to change the formation as the 4-3-1-2 will not be dynamic enough to face Germany.
A 3-5-2 (or 3-4-1-2 MUST be deployed as notable changes would be DDR back to Sweeper role and Motta taking over in midfield while Cassano and Di Natale start.
http://blogs.bettor.com/International-Friendly-Germany-vs-Italy-A-Tactical-analysis-a55453
Babun you have provided me a word for word analysis which would be just as futile if I provided another word for word analysis favoring Italia.
Germany may have had more possession yet Italia simply looked better with the ball in my opinion. You could say Germany had the first half, but Italia was better in the 2nd.
Also there were 2 calls which Badstuber and Aogo fouled Italian players which wasn't given for some odd reason despite the blatancy of the tackles.
You may have your opinion yet Germany certainly did not dominate.
Great game though.
Taking a pedal off the half is a feeble excuse . Italia played with as much effort in the first half as a bloated mats magnusson.
Oh yes... and Italia had Rannochia and Bonnuci with Cassani and Cheillini as LB
Arquitecto- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 12672
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
That was my point, actually. 1st, never take any friendlies of Germany too serious (AFAIK Italy are rarely putting everything into friendlies either), and of course, 2nd. Löw was experimenting then. I mean, he started out with Lahm - Badstuber - Mertesacker - Aogo in defense and then subbed Lahm and Stubsi out to make it Boateng - Hummels - Mertesacker - Aogo... That such shuffling of a defensive line is prone to leak goals should be obvious.Arquitecto wrote:Both teams were playing near foreign line-ups as compared to now (although Germany's is closer) so a judgement of how the similarities will be to thursday will almost be unnecessary.
Last edited by rwo power on Mon Jun 25, 2012 3:08 pm; edited 1 time in total
rwo power- Super Moderator
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20978
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
I'm totally looking forward to seeing both Manu Neuer and Gigi Buffon in action much!kiranr wrote:It will be a fascinating match. If Italy get their tactics rights and the way Germany usually sets up, then there will be lots of action on the pitch with each team getting opportunities for the goal ( I expect Germany to get more chances).
rwo power- Super Moderator
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20978
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
It seems to be the case according to people posting in this thread. I was specially answering Mole. He thinks Italy would dominate the proceedings with higher numbers in midfieldkiranr wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:Yeah, they're expert at it. The problem is they need the numbers to defend and stay close to their box. How do you expect them to dominate the game if they're busy defending? They could only counter and that's their best bet imo.kiranr wrote:
Babun, if there is one thing Italy is good at, it is closing down space.
If you say they'll set a very good counter formation and may win I agree but saying they'll dominate the proceedings= no chance.
But who said they will dominate? I think all of us expect that if Pirlo is not marked and gets the ball, then Germany is in trouble through counters and set-pieces. Germany will attack Italy from all sides and with lots of crosses as well.
It will be a fascinating match. If Italy get their tactics rights and the way Germany usually sets up, then there will be lots of action on the pitch with each team getting opportunities for the goal ( I expect Germany to get more chances).
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
leemhuis wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:Italy could throw all the numbers in midfield they still won't dominate possession. The reason is Germany uses free space wherever it's present. If Italy decide to pack the middle expect lots of Lahm overlapping and overloading of flanks. Italy will be forced to commit players for defending the flanks which will open up the middle. Their 3 men defence would have to stay deeper because Klose/ Gomez and Müller will make runs in behind 100%- The gap between Pirlo, their defence and attackers will get very big. Cassano dropping back isn't a problem because Hummels and Badstuber are excellent game openers.Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:The other thing that should be mentioned, is Cassano drops deep when Italy are defending which will give them an ever greater number advantage.
You are all talking about Italy from a defensive stand point in midfield but how about going forward? With Cassano picking up Schweignsteiger and De Rossi and Marchisio picking up Khedira and Ozil.
The thing you are talking about mus'nt happen from a Germany standpoint happens again..... Pirlo is free with a cigar in his mouth.
As mentioned before if Germany try to pass through Italy they will come unstuck in my eyes as also mentioned before Germany need to use the wingers and fullbacks as much as possible to drag out covering midfielders to expose Pirlo.
What Italy need to do is the exact scenario i mentioned above... if Cassano drops deep and picks up Schweignsteiger ( like i think he will as he usually does) then Germany have a massive problem because the end result will be Pirlo will have massive loads of space.
Although this tactical view is only really relevant for the first 70 mins because Cassano and Ozil wont last much longer than that..... then the Coaches become important.
That's if the scoreline is close at this point anyway, if Balotelli has his shooting boots on it would probably be over by half time :lucas :
They won't be able to dominate anything. It's like saying Manu would dominate Farca with 4-5-1 formation vs. 4-3-3 just because they have higher numbers in midfield
It's still 10 vs. 10. Germany's 10 uses the space a lot better than narrow Italian one. Marchisio, De Rossi etc. will be very busy with Özil and Khedira. They make fast runs to take markers away. Have fun tracking them with Marchisio and De Rossi alone
Also, Marchisio is overrated.
Of course, Italy does not have a chance against the great invincible Germans. All Italians are overrated, the Germans are underrated. And, all your LOLing at the Italians makes it even more clear to us that you have the knowledge and the expertise to explain how it will be impossible for Germany to lose.
Hey, what's your problem man? Why are you playing cheerleader for other nations? Btw cheerleading is a teenage girl job. Why don't you just vent your anger at Bert? By supporting Italy you're setting yourself up for double the pain when we ko them too.
Gemini- Hot Prospect
- Club Supported :
Posts : 211
Join date : 2011-12-17
Age : 37
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Immortal Babun wrote:
It seems to be the case according to people posting in this thread. I was specially answering Mole. He thinks Italy would dominate the proceedings with higher numbers in midfield
I think he was just trying to say that Germany will not be able to dominate the midfield like everyone early on were claiming
kiranr- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 3496
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
aleumdance wrote:I don't care who wins
Just win spain
#SaveusCR
Zealous- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 16098
Join date : 2011-08-01
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Marchisio is not overrated, far from it. He's been performing incredibly well all season and during the Euros.
7amood11- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 3113
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Semi final: Germany vs Italy discussion
Arq & co.
Apart from useless banter etc. I expect a very exciting game. Germany vs. Italy was never a boring sleep inducing encounter
May the best team on the day win. I'm very excited
Apart from useless banter etc. I expect a very exciting game. Germany vs. Italy was never a boring sleep inducing encounter
May the best team on the day win. I'm very excited
I'm saying we'll dominate the middlekiranr wrote:Immortal Babun wrote:
It seems to be the case according to people posting in this thread. I was specially answering Mole. He thinks Italy would dominate the proceedings with higher numbers in midfield
I think he was just trying to say that Germany will not be able to dominate the midfield like everyone early on were claiming
Last edited by Immortal Babun on Mon Jun 25, 2012 3:22 pm; edited 1 time in total
Babun- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 7221
Join date : 2011-06-05
Page 4 of 14 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9 ... 14
Similar topics
» Semi-Final: Brazil v Germany
» World Cup FINAL: Germany vs Argentina discussion
» Champions League: Semi Final Discussion
» Semi final: Portugal vs Spain discussion
» Final: Spain vs Italy
» World Cup FINAL: Germany vs Argentina discussion
» Champions League: Semi Final Discussion
» Semi final: Portugal vs Spain discussion
» Final: Spain vs Italy
Page 4 of 14
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Today at 11:33 pm by Pedram
» Mbappe to Real Madrid - Official
Today at 11:25 pm by Myesyats
» Champions League '24/25
Today at 11:21 pm by futbol_bill
» Witcher 4
Today at 11:20 pm by Pedram
» Mbappe signs for Real Madrid.
Today at 11:17 pm by Turok_TTZ
» The Official Real Madrid Matchday Thread 24 - 25
Today at 10:19 pm by halamadrid2
» GL NBA fantasy 24-25
Today at 6:44 pm by Warrior
» The TV Series Thread - Part 5
Today at 1:56 pm by BarrileteCosmico
» Ruben Amorim Sack Watch
Yesterday at 10:52 pm by the xcx
» The US Politics Thread
Yesterday at 9:56 pm by Pedram
» Vinicius Jr signs for Madrid
Yesterday at 6:34 pm by halamadrid2
» Premier League 2024/25
Mon Nov 25, 2024 2:46 pm by farfan
» La Liga 2024/25
Sun Nov 24, 2024 9:07 pm by Thimmy