Malaga vs BVB

Daaaaamn, the referees in the CL are clueless this year! 2 offside goals in the Dortmund - Malaga game, Schmelzer should have been off and C.Ronaldo scored another offside goal for Real Madrid.

I wonder how its going to be tomorrow

Well deserved. Eliseu was offsides and Malaga second goal was invalid.

But wtf is Malaga defense doing lol.

Yep just saw it again 4 players offisde, although evens out the Malaga one. Dortmund deserved it anyhow, their record has been great and also beating Real in an achievement, so they've knocked out a Spainish team, lets see if they can do again next round.

I defintely DO NOT hope for Bayern vs Dormund, that would be so boring.

I hope it will be Barca vs Dormund, then Barca vs Bayern in the final

Pellegrini underrated and treated badly by Real, but not anymore. Not sure about the situation at Malaga, but if they collapse will look forward to see him arrive to another big club

Don't think it evans it out seeing as Schmelzer should have been off..

In an ideal world, I hope they find some technology to solve offside rulings

And Malaga's defense has Demichilles, never believed this guy to be safe

malaga beat madrid too btw..

harhar11 wrote:Don't think it evans it out seeing as Schmelzer should have been off..

are you serious?

Malaga player rolled around as he'd be slapped in the face. he tried to get schmelzer as straight red, whereas if he had normally gone down, there would be more chance of schmelzer getting a second yellow.

Abdullah N Al Thani ‏@ANAALThani
This is not football, but racism and clear of all

Harry Redknapp wrote:

harhar11 wrote:Don't think it evans it out seeing as Schmelzer should have been off..

are you serious?

Malaga player rolled around as he'd be slapped in the face. he tried to get schmelzer as straight red, whereas if he had normally gone down, there would be more chance of schmelzer getting a second yellow.

dude, he exagerated but that's a yellow card everyday in the week. Even the english commantator said that Schmelzer was a very lucky guy..

Harry Redknapp wrote:

harhar11 wrote:Don't think it evans it out seeing as Schmelzer should have been off..

are you serious?

Malaga player rolled around as he'd be slapped in the face. he tried to get schmelzer as straight red, whereas if he had normally gone down, there would be more chance of schmelzer getting a second yellow.

the right way for the red to successfuly take place is irrevelant with harhar's post, it was a red that was not given, end off

urbaNRoots wrote:Abdullah N Al Thani ‏@ANAALThani
This is not football, but racism and clear of all

That punch by Schmelzer was a definite red card, no doubt. And he was already on a yellow. This incident went under the radar after all the drama but it definitely affected the course of the game.

just saw malaga's 2nd goal, wasn't even offside lol

Die Borussen wrote:just saw malaga's 2nd goal, wasn't even offside lol

dude was offside / infront of the ball after the final pass, not the initial through ball.

gondov wrote:

Die Borussen wrote:just saw malaga's 2nd goal, wasn't even offside lol

dude was offside / infront of the ball after the final pass, not the initial through ball.

go watch it again, its not offside

Don't know if the "punch" is a straight red card, maybe more like a "orange" card, but it was definelty a yellow..

Die Borussen wrote:

gondov wrote:

Die Borussen wrote:just saw malaga's 2nd goal, wasn't even offside lol

dude was offside / infront of the ball after the final pass, not the initial through ball.

go watch it again, its not offside

It's clearly offside, Eliseu is higher than the ball.

Yea, it was clearly offside. Please dont even try to argue that.

Offside.

I like how you conveniently skewed the line to fit eliseu in. also wouldnt the lines be parallel? Anyway I thought it was offside.

Jesus Free, you could have done better with that man. It was offside btw, still found the ref to be not as fair as I would hope...

its onside to me, eliseu's legs are on the same line with the ball, and its very close unlike dortmund's 3rd goal where 4 players were all offside lol

it was offside. im also happy that the better team is trough.

Albiceleste wrote:I like how you conveniently skewed the line to fit eliseu in. also wouldnt the lines be parallel? Anyway I thought it was offside.

No, my image is proving that Eliseu is offside. Notice that he has part of his body offside. It was closer than I thought though.

Lines don't have to be paralel, they have to meet the vanishing point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanishing_point

Die Borussen wrote:its onside to me, eliseu's legs are on the same line with the ball, and its very close unlike dortmund's 3rd goal where 4 players were all offside lol

It doesn't matter where are the legs. All the body counts except the arms. It's offside, but it is close.

free_cat wrote:

Albiceleste wrote:I like how you conveniently skewed the line to fit eliseu in. also wouldnt the lines be parallel? Anyway I thought it was offside.

No, my image is proving that Eliseu is offside. Notice that he has part of his body offside. It was closer than I thought though.

I know, and if that image is accurate, it was closer than I thought as well.