Di Maria vs. Robben vs. Silva vs. Iniesta

3 Categories, For each Rank them 1 to 3 (1 being the best)

Dribbling:

Passing:

Overall play (speed + workrate + stamina) :

Dribbling: Iniesta, Di Maria, Robben, Silva

Passing: Iniesta, Silva, Di Maria, Robben

Overall play (speed + workrate + stamina) : Di Maria, Robben, Silva, Iniesta

Dribbling: Iniesta, Robben, Di Maria, Silva

Passing: Iniesta, Silva, Di Maria, Robben

Overall: Iniesta, Silva, Di Maria, Robben

Dribbling:Iniesta,Di Maria,Robben,Silva

Passing:Iniesta,Silva,Di Maria,Robben

Overall play :Di Maria,Iniesta,Silva,Robben

Wow. Its incredible how overrated Di Maria is and how underrated Robben is. It should be like this:

Dribbling: Robben - Iniesta - Silva - Di Maria

Passing: Silva - Iniesta - Di Maria - Robben

Finishing: Robben - Silva - Di Maria - Iniesta

Clutchness: Iniesta - Robben - Silva - Di Maria

Overall: Robben - Silva/Iniesta - Di Maria

Wow. It's incredible that you added two more categories just to suit your opinion. lol

Robben....clutch.........

The Franchise wrote:Robben....clutch.........

Indeed.

Oh how can we forget about the late season a few months ago. Pure clutch!

Real Kandahar wrote:3 Categories, For each Rank them 1 to 3 (1 being the best)

Dribbling:

Passing:

Overall play (speed + workrate + stamina) :

Di Maria > Robben. Thats the purpose of this thread. Robben was shipped out swiftly, from both chelsea and Madrid.

Crime to mention Iniesta in the same breath as other 3.

Iniesta is an all time great....the other 3 aren't.

Schweini wrote:Crime to mention Iniesta in the same breath as other 3.

Iniesta is an all time great....the other 3 aren't.

Dont u supporst liverpool? Or are you now a barca fan?

Dribbling: Iniesta, Silva, Robben, Di Maria.

Passing: Iniesta, Silva, Di Maria, Robben.

Workrate and stamina: Di Maria, Silva, Iniesta, Robben.

Speed: Robben, Di Maria, Silva, Iniesta.

Overall play: Iniesta, Silva, Robben, Di Maria.

^ saying Iniesta is an all time great, doesn't make me a Barca fan.

what am I supposed to say? Downing is an all time great ?

Schweini wrote:^ saying Iniesta is an all time great, doesn't make me a Barca fan.

what am I supposed to say? Downing is an all time great ?

u had xavi on your avatar a few weeks ago... not a massive jump in logic...

jibers wrote:

Schweini wrote:^ saying Iniesta is an all time great, doesn't make me a Barca fan.

what am I supposed to say? Downing is an all time great ?

u had xavi on your avatar a few weeks ago... not a massive jump in logic...

So does Bhends tbf, we are all in awe of Xavi's deceptive face

di maria a good passer? robben is much better at passing,but dribbling,crossing,workrate etc it all goes to di maria

Di Maria made 16 assists last season.

mtfootball wrote:Di Maria made 16 assists last season.

And? assists dont determine how good someone is at passing,Xavi must be meh at it then.Di Maria gives some amazing through balls and is a great crosser,but he loses so much possession with simple passes.his passing ratio is awful.

hahahaha

In terms of being an actually winger... Di Maria, Robben, Iniesta, Silva though as overall players... Iniesta, Robben, Silva, Di Maria.

Dribbling: dimaria, robben, iniesta, silva

Passing: silva, iniesta, dimaria, robben

(speed + workrate + stamina) : robben win on speed, dimaria on workrate

winger: dimaria, silva, robben, iniesta
robben too predictable.

att. mid: iniesta, silva, dimaria, robben

overall:
2010-11: iniesta, silva, robben, dimaria
2011-12: iniesta, silva, dimaria, robben
2012-13: dimaria-silva-iniesta, robben.

halamadrid2 wrote:
just curious why do people rate Robben??? the only thing the guy can do is cut in and shoot and he is nearly 29 years old, seriously the guy is so limiyted its unreal, i wouldnt bat an eye lid for him if he played for Everton for example. he would stay there because nobody would want him thats how limited he is

Well he is a fine player to me . Well what is wrong with what he does? Many players do that as well . They are called inverted wingers , there is nothing limited about them although they can be a little one dimensional and cause the middle to get congested but the movement in between the lines is exceptional .

So are you saying Nani, Young , Schurlle , Villa and Adam Johnson limited? If you've noticed inverted wingers have actually gotten popular in the last couple of seasons and there are more players drifting to the center or cutting inside for teams . They along with him are quite useful .

But since I want to stay on topic :

Dribbling : Iniesta, Robben,Silva , Di Maria

Passing : Iniesta, Silva, Di Maria , Robben

Overall Play : Iniesta , Silva, Di Maria , Robben

halamadrid2 wrote:passing??? like short passes sideways and backwards??? if so then:

Passes: Silva, Iniesta, Di Maria, Robben or if its killer balls/through balls then:

DiMaria, Silva, Iniesta, Robben

Overall play (speed + workrate + stamina): Di Maria, Iniesta, Silva, Robben

just curious why do people rate Robben??? the only thing the guy can do is cut in and shoot and he is nearly 29 years old, seriously the guy is so limiyted its unreal, i wouldnt bat an eye lid for him if he played for Everton for example. he would stay there because nobody would want him thats how limited he is

Unreal isnt it. Guy with Sneijder took Oranje to WC final,single handedly took Bayern to CHL final something which has rarely been done in the history of the game. Lit up by the Premier League with Chelsea & was by far Madrid's best man in his 1st season when he was not injured.

1 of the 5 players in history of football to have assists in 3 different Euros.

And as for Di Maria he is garbage. Bayern's 4th Division Reserve Wingers like Jennings & Fischer are better than him. Hell my 12 year old nephew is way better than Di Maria.

Kingofeverythingclassy wrote:

halamadrid2 wrote:passing??? like short passes sideways and backwards??? if so then:

Passes: Silva, Iniesta, Di Maria, Robben or if its killer balls/through balls then:

DiMaria, Silva, Iniesta, Robben

Overall play (speed + workrate + stamina): Di Maria, Iniesta, Silva, Robben

just curious why do people rate Robben??? the only thing the guy can do is cut in and shoot and he is nearly 29 years old, seriously the guy is so limiyted its unreal, i wouldnt bat an eye lid for him if he played for Everton for example. he would stay there because nobody would want him thats how limited he is

Unreal isnt it. Guy with Sneijder took Oranje to WC final,single handedly took Bayern to CHL final something which has rarely been done in the history of the game. Lit up by the Premier League with Chelsea & was by far Madrid's best man in his 1st season when he was not injured.

1 of the 5 players in history of football to have assists in 3 different Euros.

And as for Di Maria he is garbage. Bayern's 4th Division Reserve Wingers like Jennings & Fischer are better than him. Hell my 12 year old nephew is way better than Di Maria.

lol what? in his first season he was perenially injured.. it was his second season that he played a lot , and even then higuain outshone him considerably.