Goallegacy's best Left Back of 2011

omarish wrote:

Surag.Blueguy wrote:Seriously this poll voting needs to be scrapped if at all Marcelo manages to win this one.

loooooool... are you saying marcelo doesnt deserve it but Lahm, the one who played RB last season deserves it more? :lol!:

We even are looking at the current season arent we ?

Based on only last season ,i'd still give my vote to Cole or even Evra over Marcelo.He's(cole) been quite poor this season i have to say.

marcelo. Just because all left backs in the world are meh atm

As neutral fan i would pick Marcelo coz he has improved his game ALOT

Sushi Master wrote:

EarlyPrototype wrote:Didn't Lahm play RB last season?

He did. But he's playing LB this season.

Anyways, it has to be Lahm, no one even comes close. Cashley's past it, Coentrao doesn't even play, Marcelo can't defend, Evra forgets to track back etc.

Lahm who was not even at his best last season playing at RB with Marcelo being the most effective left back last season voted champions league best left back of 2010/11 and been one of the best this season minimum top 3 still does not deserve to be voted best?

Lahm is better on paper, but all bias aside Marcelo actually deserves this lol.

Welcome mate.You sure have a lot of Marcelo support here

Surag.Blueguy wrote:

omarish wrote:

Surag.Blueguy wrote:Seriously this poll voting needs to be scrapped if at all Marcelo manages to win this one.

loooooool... are you saying marcelo doesnt deserve it but Lahm, the one who played RB last season deserves it more? :lol!:

We even are looking at the current season arent we ?

Based on only last season ,i'd still give my vote to Cole or even Evra over Marcelo.He's(cole) been quite poor this season i have to say.

well thats delusion... in 2011 was marcelos improvement year and he has been really good that season. if we look back, maybe not as good. but in this voting being consistent and good throughout 2011 is all that is needed and thats exactly what marcelo has been.

cole has been meh this season, and evra is not even top 5 (current form).

abidal...

Arent we making an assessment based on last season as well this season ?!?!?!

Cole indeed has been poor this season and Evra has not been all that bad imo.

Well you dont need to categorize Lahm as a RB or LB coz he's the best FULLBACK in the world along with Alves(I dont think there's much of a gap b/w the two).

And talking about consistency ,guess what ,Lahm is mr.consistency and is far more well-rounded than Marcelo.

And isnt this guy assembling a team of all these polls ?It would be really ridiculous if Lahm isnt in the lineup.

All that matters now that,Lahm is a left-back and my vote goes for him

that smile

gets my vote

ABIDAL by farrr!!

halamadrid2 wrote:abiidal cant even control a ball under pressure lol

Marcelo all day all night

WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What did i just read?

Grande_Milano wrote:Saeta, wont calm down?

Not too sure what you mean, but I am making a whole lineup from these polls so I need to make quite a few.

halamadrid2 wrote:
shat himself big time when DiMaria pressured him, resorting to Albilol like hoofing/clearing...guy is overrated end off

Yeah, Marcelo was so awesome under pressure right. Anyway, not disagreeing Marcelo maybe better, but the reason you gave is not it.

To Saetablanca, the votes are so close for Lahm and Marcelo, it is only fair that there is another poll with only those two as options.. What do you think?

halamadrid2 wrote:marcelo is one of the best in the world in getting out of pressuring situation, when didnt he get out of pressure vs barca??

Go watch the match again...

kiranr wrote:
To Saetablanca, the votes are so close for Lahm and Marcelo, it is only fair that there is another poll with only those two as options.. What do you think?

But what reason is there for that? Apart from the idea that the 'Marcelo haters' will all pool into Lahm just to deny him the spot, there is nothing it would change. In fact, this is better because it shows who we think is the 3rd and 4th etc LB.

Anyway, I dont want to spam the GS with uneccessary polls.

Saetablanca wrote:

kiranr wrote:
To Saetablanca, the votes are so close for Lahm and Marcelo, it is only fair that there is another poll with only those two as options.. What do you think?

But what reason is there for that? Apart from the idea that the 'Marcelo haters' will all pool into Lahm just to deny him the spot, there is nothing it would change. In fact, this is better because it shows who we think is the 3rd and 4th etc LB.

Anyway, I dont want to spam the GS with uneccessary polls.

If you want an accurate GL winner, then what i suggested is a good idea. Because all the polls will generate biased results anyway. But it is upto you.

lulz you wouldn't have said that if Abidal was winning.

EarlyPrototype wrote:lulz you wouldn't have said that if Abidal was winning.

I would have

bump

Isn't this the best LB of last season?....

I think its the whole year of 2011.

Nutmeg Maestero Ideally.

but i voted for Coentrao, ive been more impressed by him

Madrid fans are naturally all voting for Marcelo. And we have a shit load of Madrid fans.

The rest either vote for Abidal or Cole depending on who they support, and Lahm just out of Marcelo hate, although I have to admit Lahm's been meh by his standards.

This poll is kinda flawed...