Re: How much is Wilshere worth if Henderson is £20million?

by Jeps33178 Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:14 pm

Is henderson the new Milner?

by BeautifulGame Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:17 pm

Stupid article . Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

by Guest Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:18 pm

Jeps33178 wrote:Is henderson the new Milner?

They are both English and they are both midfielders and they both have white skin.....that's pretty much all they have in common Very Happy

Totally different players and different ages as well lol

by TheRedStag Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:20 pm

Jeps33178 wrote:Is henderson the new Milner?

No. He is Henderson

by Abramovich Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:23 pm

£20M + the English factor Razz

(£10M) = £30M

by Jeps33178 Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:27 pm

Sepi wrote:
Jeps33178 wrote:Is henderson the new Milner?

They are both English and they are both midfielders and they both have white skin.....that's pretty much all they have in common

Totally different players and different ages as well lol

Lol i meant it the sense if clubs were paying a exorbitant transfer fee compared to what the player would actually be worth

by TheRedStag Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:30 pm

Jeps33178 wrote:
Sepi wrote:
Jeps33178 wrote:Is henderson the new Milner?

They are both English and they are both midfielders and they both have white skin.....that's pretty much all they have in common

Totally different players and different ages as well lol

Lol i meant it the sense if clubs were paying a exorbitant transfer fee compared to what the player would actually be worth

How many Sunderland matches have you watched this season? Be honest

by Guest Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:31 pm

Big difference. Milner was 24 and pretty much a finished article when he moved with no potential of getting better.

This lad is turning 21 in a week....so his ceiling is higher hopefully...one thing annoys me though, apparently Henderson never drinks or stays up late, he is one of those good boys Very Happy

as Gil said, punchable !!

by Sushi Master Wed Jun 08, 2011 6:47 pm

These new Liverpool owners are loaded! Nice catch, hopefully he does good and isn't just another overrated English player (TM).

by Jamin Wed Jun 08, 2011 7:26 pm

i hope he does well honestly but 20m? jeez....liverpool fans will be crying for a new owner soon as they watch these get bankrupt.

by Great Leader Sprucenuce Wed Jun 08, 2011 7:27 pm

Sepi wrote:Big difference. Milner was 24 and pretty much a finished article when he moved with no potential of getting better.

This lad is turning 21 in a week....so his ceiling is higher hopefully...one thing annoys me though, apparently Henderson never drinks or stays up late, he is one of those good boys as Gil said, punchable !!

So your mixing at Mackem goodie 2 shoes with life of the party Geordie Rolling Eyes

Good luck with that one How much is Wilshere worth if Henderson is £20million? - Page 2 Thumbup1

P.S thumps up needs to be added Very Happy

by Giggslegend Wed Jun 08, 2011 7:32 pm

Henderson for 20 million seem overpriced but the kid really got it.

He might not be a flashy player but a great midfielder and a great prospect.

If you have followed the EPL this year you know that this is not just a random guy.

by Guest Wed Jun 08, 2011 7:35 pm

Jamin wrote:i hope he does well honestly but 20m? jeez....liverpool fans will be crying for a new owner soon as they watch these get bankrupt.

bankrupt LOOL.

We are very profitable, and just signed the biggest kit deal in history and only behind Man United in marketing revenues in England.

Not every one is an accountant like your manager...sorry, but don't comment on stuff you don't know. It's embarrassing Very Happy

I really like Arsenal, but that's very annoying with their fans. When other teams buy, it's like they have comitt a sin. No deal is apparently logical unless its Under 10M for a French player pirat

by Jamin Wed Jun 08, 2011 8:08 pm

Sepi wrote:
Jamin wrote:i hope he does well honestly but 20m? jeez....liverpool fans will be crying for a new owner soon as they watch these get bankrupt.

bankrupt LOOL.

We are very profitable, and just signed the biggest kit deal in history and only behind Man United in marketing revenues in England.

Not every one is an accountant like your manager...sorry, but don't comment on stuff you don't know. It's embarrassing

I really like Arsenal, but that's very annoying with their fans. When other teams buy, it's like they have comitt a sin. No deal is apparently logical unless its Under 10M for a French player

lol, twas a joke if you didnt get it Rolling Eyes

but the moral of the joke was that Henderson is overpriced. if you dont agree you're 100% biased Smile

by EarlyPrototype Wed Jun 08, 2011 8:26 pm

BeautifulGame wrote: Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

Nah a player is not worth only what the club is willing to pay. Are you saying that Carol is worth the 35 million pounds spent on him? I do not think so.

by poolsupporter Wed Jun 08, 2011 8:47 pm

EarlyPrototype wrote:
BeautifulGame wrote: Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

Nah a player is not worth only what the club is willing to pay. Are you saying that Carol is worth the 35 million pounds spent on him? I do not think so.

Not exactly, but it would be stupid for people to not consider the circumstances around the transfer price.

by EarlyPrototype Wed Jun 08, 2011 8:50 pm

poolsupporter wrote:
EarlyPrototype wrote:
BeautifulGame wrote: Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

Nah a player is not worth only what the club is willing to pay. Are you saying that Carol is worth the 35 million pounds spent on him? I do not think so.

Not exactly, but it would be stupid for people to not consider the circumstances around the transfer price.

The circumstances do affect transfers ,but if you take another example into account when Real payed 80 million for Ronaldo I think you will find very few people to say he was worth that much because no player at the time was actually worth 80mil.

by RED Thu Jun 09, 2011 12:02 am

Liverpool did great business imo. 13 mill Plus Ngog for 7 mill. SAFC got jacked. So he actually cost 13 mill according to a lot of reports.

Wilshire is 35 mill tops. One of the best young talents in world football.

by Ganso Thu Jun 09, 2011 12:07 am

i wouldn't pay more than 25 mil for wilshere.

by TheRedStag Thu Jun 09, 2011 12:39 am

So do we know yet if N'gog is going the other way or not?

by BeautifulGame Thu Jun 09, 2011 4:33 am

EarlyPrototype wrote:
poolsupporter wrote:
EarlyPrototype wrote:
BeautifulGame wrote: Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

Nah a player is not worth only what the club is willing to pay. Are you saying that Carol is worth the 35 million pounds spent on him? I do not think so.

Not exactly, but it would be stupid for people to not consider the circumstances around the transfer price.

The circumstances do affect transfers ,but if you take another example into account when Real payed 80 million for Ronaldo I think you will find very few people to say he was worth that much because no player at the time was actually worth 80mil.

ofcourse Ronaldo is worth 80 mil . Otherwise u wont have got former Ballon D'or yet to reach his peak and the selling club under no pressure to sell . Why would united for a lesser fee .

There is no scale to measure a player's worth . The only measurement is how much the buying club willing to pay . Whether he lives upto the price tag is altogether different matter .

by BeautifulGame Thu Jun 09, 2011 4:34 am

Irish_Catalan_Scouser wrote:So do we know yet if N'gog is going the other way or not?

According to Times NGog to SAFC is close to completion.

by Nishankly Thu Jun 09, 2011 9:43 am

Too clear this thread up . The fee is 16 million .. So Wilshere's amount reduces by 10 .. Smile

by EarlyPrototype Thu Jun 09, 2011 12:25 pm

BeautifulGame wrote:
EarlyPrototype wrote:
poolsupporter wrote:
EarlyPrototype wrote:
BeautifulGame wrote: Carrick went for 18 mil . Does that mean Alonso is 50 mil ? VDV was bought by Spurs for 8 mil . Does that mean Fabregas is only worth 15 mil ?

A player is only worth what the buying club is willing to pay .

Nah a player is not worth only what the club is willing to pay. Are you saying that Carol is worth the 35 million pounds spent on him? I do not think so.

Not exactly, but it would be stupid for people to not consider the circumstances around the transfer price.

The circumstances do affect transfers ,but if you take another example into account when Real payed 80 million for Ronaldo I think you will find very few people to say he was worth that much because no player at the time was actually worth 80mil.

ofcourse Ronaldo is worth 80 mil . Otherwise u wont have got former Ballon D'or yet to reach his peak and the selling club under no pressure to sell . Why would united for a lesser fee .

There is no scale to measure a player's worth . The only measurement is how much the buying club willing to pay . Whether he lives upto the price tag is altogether different matter .

Lets agree to disagree then.

by Magricos Thu Jun 09, 2011 7:24 pm

Actually CR7 was probably worth 80mil to Madrid at the time considering madrid got 50% of his image rights.

by Sponsored content