Arsenal and Valencia

I really love both Arsenal and Valencia, and during a argument with a friend couldn't fully decide which team has more quality. What do the neutrals think?

Solgado/Adriuz

Piatti/Vicente Mata/Pablo Hernandez

Parejo/Maduro Banega/Tino

Albelda/Topal

Mathieu Costa/new CB Rami Miguel

Alves




RVP/Chamakh

Nasri/Rosicky Gervinho/Walcott


Wilshere/Diaby Fabregas

Song

Gibbs/new LB Koscielny Vermaleen Sagna

Szczenscy


Make a different line up if you guys think its appropriate. But who do you think has the better team? I feel Fabregas gives Arsenal just a slight edge, otherwise they are quite even. But some of my friends argued that piatti + hernandez + mata are better than Nasri + Gervinho + Walcott. Don't mean to offend any Valencia or Arsenal fans, but to me it seemed quite interesting.

arsenal.... no doubt!!!

always in the CL, always a tittle contender!!!

well arsenal were in last years cl and valencia were not, despite arsenal being in the harder league

english_jewel wrote:well arsenal were in last years cl and valencia were not, despite arsenal being in the harder league

Fail, Valencia were in the CL last year lol they were ko'ed by Schalke in 2nd round.

Your thinking of Villarreal.

Well i didn't want to to judge based on how they have previously performed in Cl, even though Mr. Mole pointed out the fallacies in ur argument, but just looking at their first team/depth of squad/quality of the team etc.

Immaculate_Mole wrote:

english_jewel wrote:well arsenal were in last years cl and valencia were not, despite arsenal being in the harder league

Fail, Valencia were in the CL last year lol they were ko'ed by Schalke in 2nd round.

Your thinking of Villarreal.

lmao i fail

That's a tough one

No Silva, no Villa, no party

Lex wrote:No Silva, no Villa, no party

oh, you mean ''No Totti, no Party''?

Arsenal has the better squad but I'm sure they wouldn't mind having a few of Valencia's players. Especially Alves, who's an epic GK.

Arsenal can at least try to beat Barca...

Learn from it, Valencia

Sushi Master wrote:Arsenal can at least try to beat Barca...

Learn from it, Valencia

We didn't get slaughtered now did we?

Arsenal takes this one. At least they have compitent CB's and 1 WB/FB.

Sushi Master wrote:Arsenal can at least try to beat Barca...

Learn from it, Valencia

good to know that valencia weren't even trying when we were one of two teams in la liga who took a lead at camp nou this season...

on topic, it would be close, hoping for a cl draw next season... we have a better keeper, slightly worse defence, the midfield would be pretty much equal if banega felt like playing up to his talent and van persie is out for 3 months a year so soldado >>> chamakh...