Dybala vs Icardi vs Vietto

All of them very talented and 21 years old, who do you guys believe has the brightest future?

Squawka comparison (can't figure out how to make it into an image)

http://www.squawka.com/comparison-matrix#la_liga/2014/2015/luciano_vietto/136/136/15772/0/p|serie_a/2014/2015/paulo_dybala/137/137/2853/0/p|serie_a/2014/2015/mauro_icardi/137/137/2962/0/p#goals_scored/goals_from_penalties/assists/key_passes/chances_created/total_shots/shot_accuracy/successful_take_ons/successful_take_ons_%/aerial_duels_won/aerial_duels_won_%/tackles_won/tackles_lost#total

I've voted Dybala.

I don't really know Vietto, but Dybala is not only a good at finishing but completely destroys the opponent's defense with his movement, with his link-up play, his final ball is extremely good, can play as a lone striker or as a SS, is good at set pieces as well, has an insane work rate, tremendous player.

Icardi is a good poacher but that's it, I remember him at Samp and he was frustratingly invisible and motionless outside goals and it's something that he carried on as I've often heard Mancini asking him to partecipate more to the play, to be more involved.

On the other hand Icardi has been showing his talent for years whereas this is Dybala's first good half season in top flight football. You expect people of this age to be inconsistent.

Katy Perry wrote:I've voted Dybala.

I don't really know Vietto, but Dybala is not only a good at finishing but completely destroys the opponent's defense with his movement, with his link-up play, his final ball is extremely good, can play as a lone striker or as a SS, is good at set pieces as well, has an insane work rate, tremendous player.

Icardi is a good poacher but that's it, I remember him at Samp and he was frustratingly invisible and motionless outside goals and it's something that he carried on as I've often heard Mancini asking him to partecipate more to the play, to be more involved.

tbh when he was a Sampdoria player basically we signed him around February and after it Icardi stopped to fight for Sampdoria , basically he played the second half of season saving his energies , with indifference, perhaps he didn't want to risk injures... otherwise he would have scored even more than 10 gioals ( he had scored already 8 goals in January ).
This is the reason why he is hated from most Sampdoria fans, because they accuse him (and Sampdoria fans have good reasons , although they are normally rancorous,they were capable to throw even taps to Pagliuca, a hero of Scudetto 1991 ) to not have honored the Sampdoria kit until the end , while for example Gabbiadini did it this year even if he knew to sign for Napoli.

Anyway surely he must improve for teammwork , it his definitely his main defect so far , but his goal average is important considering the young age : 30 goals in 74  matches of Serie A, 19 in 41 under us.

Imo his quality is the fact he has the guts, essential for playing with Inter. Playing with Inter is not exactly same thing than playing with a small club .... expecially for a young player...

I like Vietto and Dybala more than Icardi that's for sure.

Think both will be better than Icardi as well as they're all around game is better than his. It's a hard one to choose between Dybala and Vietto. They're both having great seasons.

Dybala > Icardi > Vietto from what I've seen.

Dybala really looks the goods though. He's not just effective at scoring as has been mentioned but his movement, link-up and vision are also on a very high level already.

That said I'd still take Vietto on any team over Icardi just because Icardi seems like a punk.

Dybala is more completed forward,good finisher,dribbler and a with a good vision to create chances for others...he'll be a big name if keeps the good form he has atm.

Vietto scored the winner for Villarreal yesterday

That's 14 now  

It should also be noted that he's playing in a clearly better league and a better team than the other two.

Don't call me James wrote:Vietto scored the winner for Villarreal yesterday

That's 14 now  

It should also be noted that he's playing in a clearly better league and a better team than the other two.

I suppose you base that on the fact that Villareal is higher up the table than Inter? Otherwise gtfo with that bs. Saying Villareal is better than Inter is much like saying Sampdoria is better than Liverpool. Simply because they are higher up the table than L'pool.

"Manchester United scouts Inter-Palermo: Icardi & Dybala the targets

Sunday's match between Inter and Palermo was an opportunity to observe two Argentines who are shining in Serie A: Icardi (who scored a brace) and Dybala. Manchester United scouted the two talents up close from the stands. For June perhaps. United in Italy, with two Argentine strikers as targets."

http://gianlucadimarzio.com/en/calciomercato/manchester-united-scouts-inter-palermo-icardi-dybala-the-targets/

Argentina United

Yesterday Mauro destroyed him nay Dybala destroyed himself :lol



i can't still believe about it, probably the most incredible miss of year ( mods why doesn't vine link work? i know it was by tancredi palmeri but forgive me i didn't fin other )

I don't know the future but I don't think Dybala showed more than  him atm .
Surely Dybala scores amazing goals and he is a better ability to play the ball , but a point in favour of Icardi is represented from fact than being being difference maker in Inter for a young player for pressure expecially atm is   another job than Palermo , the place where Miccoli was a king and it's another reason because I don't get this hype about Vazquez diffused in Italy ( many to hope he  becomesItalian for Nazionale) , meh tbh for me he is not so different than Ricky Alvarez
while I like Dybala though.

Him and Icardi are 2 players enough different anyway,it's normal Icardi hasn't same skills , he is a finisher, but he has goal in DNA. They might play together

InterMalia wrote:

Don't call me James wrote:Vietto scored the winner for Villarreal yesterday

That's 14 now  

It should also be noted that he's playing in a clearly better league and a better team than the other two.

I suppose you base that on the fact that Villareal is higher up the table than Inter? Otherwise gtfo with that bs. Saying Villareal is better than Inter is much like saying Sampdoria is better than Liverpool. Simply because they are higher up the table than L'pool.

I agree .. Probably Vietto is better than Icardi , but I don't think to  swap Inter team with Villareal team

Vietto with 18 goals in all competitions now

I just guessed that Dybala would have more votes so I voted for Vietto, just to balance and I realised that now both have four votes each, me I like both of them

Dybala - Icardi - Vietto

Argentina's attacking trident for years to come?

Don't call me James wrote:Vietto scored the winner for Villarreal yesterday

That's 14 now  

It should also be noted that he's playing in a clearly better league and a better team than the other two.

maybe, but its easier to score goals in spain than in Italy.

Don't call me James wrote:Vietto scored the winner for Villarreal yesterday

That's 14 now  

It should also be noted that he's playing in a clearly better league and a better team than the other two.

Clearly better league? I would have thought that last year, this year I think the two leagues are pretty close. In any case, Icardi is the top goal scorer in Serie A along with Luca Toni, and he is only 22.