How would your club do in another league?

Top 2 in La Liga us or Barca

Top 2 in Germany

Winner of serie A

paperbackwriter wrote:What's this talk about more games and tougher schedule for PL players/teams?

In both 10-11 and 11-12 Ronaldo played more games for Madrid than he ever did for Man Utd in a season. 54 and 55 respectively. Messi played 60 games last season for Barca. That's 16 more than Rooney played and 12 more than Aguero and Van Persie.

Oh god please stop. How many games have been played in Li Liga this period and how many in BPL #irestmycase.

Abramovich wrote:Top 2 in La Liga us or Barca

Top 2 in Germany

Winner of serie A

You wouldnt win Serie A.

fatman123 wrote:I think Barcas lack of depth would catch up with them is they played as many games in a season as PL sides do, of course if they were to acquire the depth of the other big PL sides theyd do very well in the PL. Having said that i think RM are the more suited of the two as they have Mou and a team more suited to the physicality of England

Myth, we have tons of depth. 2 players for every position easily.

We would be contenders/champions everywhere except in the mighty bundesliga where we would struggle to end over fribourg, Mainz or Schalke.

What? So Juventus can win the EPL but Chelsea can't win Serie A !? What is Seria A the best league in the world ?

futbol wrote:

7amood11 wrote:Not a chance. PL teams apart from Barca and Madrid are stronger than La Liga teams in general.

Nope. PL is the weakest top league at the moment. From top to bottom.

Maybe you misunderstood. I was not arguing that Barca wouldn't win the PL, I was arguing against the claim CBarca made about how Barca would win the PL more easily than they win La Liga, which is ridiculous.

So you expect Barca to walk the league with over a 30 point difference between them and the likes of United and City? As I said, not a chance.


La Liga has been a two horse race for years now. Every year the number of points between 2nd and 3rd is ridiculously high. It'll definitely be much more difficult for Barca in the PL.

Will get relegated to Segunda easily.

7amood11 wrote:

futbol wrote:

7amood11 wrote:Not a chance. PL teams apart from Barca and Madrid are stronger than La Liga teams in general.

Nope. PL is the weakest top league at the moment. From top to bottom.

Maybe you misunderstood. I was not arguing that Barca wouldn't win the PL, I was arguing against the claim CBarca made about how Barca would win the PL more easily than they win La Liga, which is ridiculous.

So you expect Barca to walk the league with over a 30 point difference between them and the likes of United and City? As I said, not a chance.


La Liga has been a two horse race for years now. Every year the number of points between 2nd and 3rd is ridiculously high. It'll definitely be much more difficult for Barca in the PL.

There wouldn't be a 30 point difference between Barca and Manchester United just like there is no 30 point difference between Barca and Real Madrid (except maybe this year ). But that's not the point. The point is that Premier League teams in general are tactically and technically inferior to their La Liga counterparts. Some recent EPL scorelines:

Reading - Manu 3:4
Swansea - Norwich 3:4
Reading - Arsenal 5:7
Arsenal - Tottenham 5:2
ManU - Newcastle 4:3
Norwich - ManCity 3:4
Chelsea - ManU 5:4
Stoke - Southampton 3:3
Chelsea - Aston Villa 8:0

How would Barcelona find it harder in such an environment than in La Liga? Quality-wise it's the worst Premier League I've ever seen. Every team is leaking goals for fun. United is leading the table comfortably despite conceding 28 goals halfway through the season.

futbol wrote:
How would Barcelona find it harder in such an environment than in La Liga? Quality-wise it's the worst Premier League I've ever seen. Every team is leaking goals for fun. United is leading the table comfortably despite conceding 28 goals halfway through the season.

Barca would leak a lot more goals too

urbaNRoots wrote:

futbol wrote:
How would Barcelona find it harder in such an environment than in La Liga? Quality-wise it's the worst Premier League I've ever seen. Every team is leaking goals for fun. United is leading the table comfortably despite conceding 28 goals halfway through the season.

Barca would leak a lot more goals too

You mean Barcelona would concede 3 or 4 goals to teams like Newcastle or Norwich?

futbol wrote:

You mean Barcelona would concede 3 or 4 goals to teams like Newcastle or Norwich?

They would concede a lot more that's for sure.

pUsHa wrote:What? So Juventus can win the EPL but Chelsea can't win Serie A !? What is Seria A the best league in the world ?

juve is better than chelsea

Abramovich wrote:Top 2 in La Liga us or Barca

Top 2 in Germany

Winner of serie A

Hmmm, I'm sure Chelsea would crush Juventus, oh wait.

Bayern - would dominate any league they were in
Spurs - would be competitive in any league they played in
Roma - would be the most entertaining in any league they played in

with a bit of luck we could win the league in south korea

1st in EPL
2nd in la liga behind Barcelona
1st-2nd in Serie A maybe behind Juve

Top 2 in germany

top 3 in La Liga

1st in Serie A

Surag wrote:Win the Premier League.

2nd-3rd in La Liga.

2nd-3rd in Bundesliga.

win the premier league?

with Matri and Vucenic and Bendtner

Bottom 3 in any other league.

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

Surag wrote:Win the Premier League.

2nd-3rd in La Liga.

2nd-3rd in Bundesliga.

win the premier league?

with Matri and Vucenic and Bendtner

Juve overall a far better side than United.Besides we score loads of goals from midfield.

Bundesliga - top 5
Serie A - top 7
La Liga - top 5
Ligue 1 - top 4

In my opinion. I won't guess the exact place but this is where I would expect us to rank amongst in these leagues.

Surag wrote:

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

Surag wrote:Win the Premier League.

2nd-3rd in La Liga.

2nd-3rd in Bundesliga.

win the premier league?

with Matri and Vucenic and Bendtner

Juve overall a far better side than United.Besides we score loads of goals from midfield.

Juve would be 3rd or 4th without a top class striker, players like Giovinco would get tossed around in the PL

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

Surag wrote:

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

win the premier league?

with Matri and Vucenic and Bendtner

Juve overall a far better side than United.Besides we score loads of goals from midfield.

Juve would be 3rd or 4th without a top class striker

yeah, I'd like to see Cleverley+Carrick vs Marchisio,Vidal and Pirlo.

likeastar wrote:

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

Surag wrote:

Juve overall a far better side than United.Besides we score loads of goals from midfield.

Juve would be 3rd or 4th without a top class striker

yeah, I'd like to see Cleverley+Carrick vs Marchisio,Vidal and Pirlo.

why is this united vs juve.....guess we are the only team in the league

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

Surag wrote:

B-Mac MUFC wrote:

win the premier league?

with Matri and Vucenic and Bendtner

Juve overall a far better side than United.Besides we score loads of goals from midfield.

Juve would be 3rd or 4th without a top class striker, players like Giovinco would get tossed around in the PL

We face physical ,park the bus teams almost every week in Serie A.Like someone said in terms of technical quality and tactical organization PL's not as good as some people think.