Fifa12, PES12, and FM12 ratings for Roma

FIFA12
starting XI: Stekelenburg 85, Cassetti 78 Burdisso 78 Juan 80 Angel 74; Perrotta 76, DDR 83, Pjanic 79; Lamela 74, Totti 80, Bojan 78

subs: Curci 73, Heinze 77, Gago 78, Simplicio 75, Greco 74, Caprari 70, Ozzy 79

reserves: Kjaer 76, Cicinho 73, Pizarro 77, Taddei 76, Borriello 80, Rosi 72, Okaka 70, Lobont 73, Plagiacelli 61, Viviani 69, Verre 56, Borini 72, Nego 59, Antunes 67, Barusso 68


PES12
starting XI: Stekelenburg 81; Cassetti 82 Juan 84 Heinze 83 Angel 78; Taddei 83 Pizarro 89 DDR 89; Pjanic 81; Totti 88 Borriello 78

subs:Curci 82; Cicinho 78 Burdisso 82 Kjaer 82 Antunes 75, Simplicio 77 Gago 81 Perrotta 77; Rosi 78 Ozzy 74 Bojan 76; Lobont 80

reserves: Barusso 71, Greco 72, Okaka 73, Borini 64
missing players: Lamela, Nego, Verre, Viviani, Plagiacelli, Caprari

i'll list the FM ratings once i have them

FM12
CurrentAbility PotentialAbility Name
(values are out of 200)
156 167 stek
154 157 ddr
153 185 totti
152 160 osvaldo
151 165 juan
148 160 pizarro
146 156 gago
146 160 borriello
142 160 heinze
141 160 pjanic
141 155 burdisso
139 148 perrotta
138 167 angel
138 163 kjaer
138 146 cassetti
137 147 brighi
135 150 jsb
133 140 guberti
132 140 taddei
131 142 simplicio
130 -9- lamela
130 145 lobont
127 140 rosi
127 140 cicinho
125 166 bertolacci
125 -8- borini
124 135 greco
120 130 curci
113 119 barusso
110 142 okaka
108 155 d'alessandro
106 -8- nego
105 -8- crescenzi
104 -8- pettinari
090 -8- florenzi
088 -8- caprari
074 -9- ciciretti
069 -8- verre
064 -8- ferri
055 -8- boldor


-9 = random value between 150 and 180, generated at start of game save
-8 = random value between 130 and 160, generated at start of game save

i only included the notable primavera players. viviani and montini are crap apparently =[

Well we can all agree how underrated our players are in Fifa, its craaaazy. So what yall think about the games?

Ok well you know the ratings are BS when Borriello=Totti.

PES >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fifa

The Fonz wrote:PES >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fifa

FM >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> PES>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> FIFA

fifa is garbage

but credit to them, fifa12 has improved a lot this year. PES12 vanilla is trash as usual with the F'ed up transfers, but after some mods come out, it'll be a lot better

FIFA is made for the Premier League guys. Even Torres is GOD in that game compared to his actual worth.

Im glad the Pes demo really surprised me this season, and I can finally enjoy the game when it comes out october 14th here

Eivindo wrote:FIFA is made for the Premier League guys. Even Torres is GOD in that game compared to his actual worth.

Im glad the Pes demo really surprised me this season, and I can finally enjoy the game when it comes out october 14th here

i agree with you. it's the main reason why i boycott fifa every year since 09. for crying out loud john o'shea has a higher rating than juan/burdisso/mexes/kjaer

de rossi is also rated equally to huddlestone

PES and FM is the way to go

What's PES! FM!

Yes Fifa is England biased. It has four levels of English League but only two from Spain, Italy, Germany & France.

Also, some European Leagues they skipped are way better than A or K League. BTW, why do they say ECC or EFA instead of Champions League or Europa League!

iftikhar wrote:What's PES! FM!

Yes Fifa is England biased. It has four levels of English League but only two from Spain, Italy, Germany & France.

Also, some European Leagues they skipped are way better than A or K League. BTW, why do they say ECC or EFA instead of Champions League or Europa League!

Because they don't have the license

FM editor's not out for the FM12 demo, so i don't really know the player ratings

i can only use "assistant reports", which judges players by stars

4 stars (key players): juan, stek, ddr, totti
3.5 stars (1st team): burdisso, kjaer, heinze, bojan, osvaldo, borriello, pizarro, gago
3 stars (rotation/1st team): pjanic, perrotta, angel
2.5 stars (rotation/backup): taddei, cassetti, lobont
2 stars (backup): cicinho, rosi, lamela, simplicio, curci, greco, barusso
1.5 stars (not needed): borini

strikers (best to worse): totti, bojan, osvaldo, borriello, borini
midfielders (best to worse): ddr, pizarro, gago, pjanic, perrotta, taddei, simplicio, greco, barusso
fullbacks (best to worse): angel, cassetti, cicinho, rosi
centerbacks (best to worse): juan, burdisso, kjaer, heinze
keepers (best to worse): stek, lobont, curci

best XI:
Stekelenburg
Burdisso Juan Kjaer Heinze
Pizarro DeRossi Gago
Bojan Totti Osvaldo

gutted that they underrated borini, simplicio, and rosi. but they were still lenient with totti

Are River Plate in PES 12 ?

Just beat some poor sap 5-0 with Roma.

He was Barcelona too..

Poor guy never stood a chance.

McLewis wrote:Just beat some poor sap 5-0 with Roma.

He was Barcelona too..

Poor guy never stood a chance.

The Fonz wrote:Are River Plate in PES 12 ?

yes, but lamela isn't anywhere in PES12, not for national team, not for river plate, not for roma

schnix wrote:

The Fonz wrote:Are River Plate in PES 12 ?

yes, but lamela isn't anywhere in PES12, not for national team, not for river plate, not for roma

Ah *bleep*

The Fonz wrote:

schnix wrote:

The Fonz wrote:Are River Plate in PES 12 ?

yes, but lamela isn't anywhere in PES12, not for national team, not for river plate, not for roma

Ah *bleep*

get the PC version. give it some time. fans will eventually mod the shit out of it so you can download a shitstorm of patches. i'm sure lamela will make his way into PES somehow

schnix did FM 12 come out yet?

Lamela's definitely on FIFA 12 lol

Even at 74, guy's one of my favorite players....He can be extremely skillful going forward.

Camurrìa.Sto.Stronzo wrote:schnix did FM 12 come out yet?

Demo came out the other day.......

Immaculate_Mole wrote:

Camurrìa.Sto.Stronzo wrote:schnix did FM 12 come out yet?

Demo came out the other day.......

Whens the full game coming out?

Camurrìa.Sto.Stronzo wrote:

Immaculate_Mole wrote:

Camurrìa.Sto.Stronzo wrote:schnix did FM 12 come out yet?

Demo came out the other day.......

Whens the full game coming out?

21st October

McLewis wrote:Lamela's definitely on FIFA 12 lol

Even at 74, guy's one of my favorite players....He can be extremely skillful going forward.

the player ratings in FIFA suck balls. if lamela were playing for say, arsenal, he'd be rated in the high 70's already

Fifa and their bullshit ratings,nothing new.Just gives me more reason to hate on them.....

PES12,just 6 more days ..Hurry up ...

Camurrìa.Sto.Stronzo wrote:schnix did FM 12 come out yet?

demo's out, but not the full game. beat mancity 2-1 with roma in preseason (totti+borini scored )

just wanted to try it out. i'd go back to FM12demo once in a while, but i'm still trying to win the scudetto with siena in FM11 first before FM12 comes out. i just beat roma 0-5 at the olimpico. sorry


full shot: https://2img.net/h/i1203.photobucket.com/albums/bb386/cuorediroma/romasiena-1.jpg

i always seem to do well against roma in video games....

Rosicky playing for Siena, daaaaaaaaaaaaaamn! FM :p