If your club were relegated, which of your players would stay?

Donuts wrote:

mtfootball wrote:With Real Madrid there's no point leaving. The team would be promoted the following season and the club would start buying if stars left. Even in the second division Real Madrid would still be the biggest club in the World. And also the team could win the CL the previous season, meaning the club competes in it while in the second division.

2 years without UEFA is a big deal for a player, take CR7 for example, he wants the player of year and trophies, those wont happen being relegated and will leave, especially because he is 27 in his peak years why would he waste it in second division.

It would be 1 year and if we win the CL the season we get relegated, the following season we'd be competing in it.

mtfootball wrote:It would be 1 year and if we win the CL the season we get relegated, the following season we'd be competing in it.

Lol you are talking as though Real Madrid winning the CL is a mere formality..

This is just a hypothetical question barring circumstances and events..CL or EL has nothing to do with it since the possibility of Real Madrid winning CL and relegated at the same time wont transpire in real life nor in FIFA or PES.Better answer to the question instead.

Iker, Xabi, Granero, Higuain.

Totti, Perrotta, Lobont, Taddei and the primavera boys.

mtfootball wrote:

Donuts wrote:

mtfootball wrote:With Real Madrid there's no point leaving. The team would be promoted the following season and the club would start buying if stars left. Even in the second division Real Madrid would still be the biggest club in the World. And also the team could win the CL the previous season, meaning the club competes in it while in the second division.

2 years without UEFA is a big deal for a player, take CR7 for example, he wants the player of year and trophies, those wont happen being relegated and will leave, especially because he is 27 in his peak years why would he waste it in second division.

It would be 1 year and if we win the CL the season we get relegated, the following season we'd be competing in it.

That response is so.. lol honestly be realistic if you got relegated against teams like Granada Zaragoza etc etc how do you expect your team to win the CL.

Donuts wrote:

mtfootball wrote:

Donuts wrote:

mtfootball wrote:With Real Madrid there's no point leaving. The team would be promoted the following season and the club would start buying if stars left. Even in the second division Real Madrid would still be the biggest club in the World. And also the team could win the CL the previous season, meaning the club competes in it while in the second division.

2 years without UEFA is a big deal for a player, take CR7 for example, he wants the player of year and trophies, those wont happen being relegated and will leave, especially because he is 27 in his peak years why would he waste it in second division.

It would be 1 year and if we win the CL the season we get relegated, the following season we'd be competing in it.

That response is so.. lol honestly be realistic if you got relegated against teams like Granada Zaragoza etc etc how do you expect your team to win the CL.

The relegation might be a punishment like the Serie A one, not because we finished 18th, 19th or 20th.

ErPupone wrote:Totti, Perrotta, Lobont, Taddei and the primavera boys.

You think De Rossi would leave?

mtfootball wrote:The relegation might be a punishment like the Serie A one, not because we finished 18th, 19th or 20th.

And you'd be barred from European competitions if anything like that happened..

You really are making little sense here..

I think all Bayern Munich players would stay, but I fear my 2nd team (Madrid) players will all leave, except for maybe Casillas and Ramos.

The Messiah wrote:I think all Bayern Munich players would stay, but I fear my 2nd team (Madrid) players will all leave, except for maybe Casillas and Ramos.

Robben would leave in a heart beat.

JT, Cech, Lamps, Lukaku, Ivanovic, Mikel, McEachran and the rest of the youth squad.

David Luiz may be a fun guy but I don't think he'll stay, at least not for long. Maybe half a season. One season at most.

If Kalou was still a Chelsea player, he'd probably stay too.


Wow! 7 players!

Ambrosini, Abbiati, Abate, Acerbi, Antonini, Bonera, Nocerino.

I wouldn't hold it against Robinho, Pato and Boateng if they left in this situation, I imagine Mexes and Flamini would jump ship - I'm honestly not poking fun at the French, I think they'd have legitimate reasons to leave - and I can't really judge whether Montolivo would stay given we haven't yet seen him play in our shirt and unlike Acerbi, another new arrival, he has just a few years left of his prime.

I'd like to think that El Shaarawy would stay however it's a difficult thing to predict. Muntari and Urby might stay, I imagine there'd be limited interest in our team anyway as Ganso said.

Lukkaku?really?lol

mtfootball wrote:With Real Madrid there's no point leaving. The team would be promoted the following season and the club would start buying if stars left. Even in the second division Real Madrid would still be the biggest club in the World. And also the team could win the CL the previous season, meaning the club competes in it while in the second division.

Yeah I could fly to the moon tomorrow. I only have to get a ticket.

Ganso wrote:Lukkaku?really?lol

Yes, Lukaku.

most of the la masia grads would stay for sure and it also depends on the state of the club at the time, alot of factors come into play, i.e. morale, how the club is being run and such like...

As a Barca fan; if we were releated this season, then Xavi,Puyol,Valdes,Messi,Iniesta,Pedro,Busquets,Thiago...basically the la masia grads would all want to stay,but wage cuts and suchlike would determine what the club would do in such a situation.
In Barca's case,most of the guys have enjoyed enormous success in the last few years,so the factor of wanting to leave because a chance of winning is gone for 1 season(best case scenario) would be very low,lMO.

If I had to pinpoint players most likely to leave:
Dani Alves

David Villa

Sanchez

Mascherano(might still because he seems to love the club)

Abidal(if not fully fit,he would be released)

Adriano

Jordi Alba(might leave since he hasn't been a part of past success)

Cesc Fabregas(la masia graduate but I am not yet sure how much he loves the club,tbh)

Most people here are over-estimating players' willingness to stay if the club gets relegated, imo.

Messiah "Aggerswagger" wrote:For Liverpool, these guys I'm pretty sure would stay

Gerrard
Carra
Kelly
Agger
Lucas
Spearing
Shelvey
and the Academy players

I don't think Agger or Lucas would stay.

I have faith in their loyalty and their love for the club, but you're most likely right

larisano wrote:If I had to pinpoint players most likely to leave:
Dani Alves

David Villa

Sanchez

Mascherano(might still because he seems to love the club)

Abidal(if not fully fit,he would be released)

Adriano

Jordi Alba(might leave since he hasn't been a part of past success)

Cesc Fabregas(la masia graduate but I am not yet sure how much he loves the club,tbh)

Fabregas would leave and join Madrid.

Lukaku is a huuuge Chelsea fan and has been for a long time.

everyone except rami, banega, soldado and alves, they're all shit except guaita whose existence everyone seems to ignore

Barrettinator wrote:JT, Cech, Lamps, Lukaku, Ivanovic, Mikel, McEachran and the rest of the youth squad.

Seriously i dont see Ivanovic and Mikel staying..

7amood11 wrote:Not many footballers are looking to waste a year of their careers in the 2nd division.

For Juve currently, Buffon, Chiellini, Marchisio, and PDC.

This..

You can add Pepe,Barzagli and Giovinco to the list too.

i would say everyone except Lass, Ronaldo, Ozil and Benzema.

It would be an odd scene for Barca. Barca B would be relegated the third div. as a result, so I imagine seeing Barca B playing just as they would anyways, with the B players being "promoted" to play in la Segunda due to a technicality. And at least half of our current team would be competing in La Segunda, so there would just be drubbings. As far as who would stay, I guess it depends on the scenario.