Nuri Sahin - Borussia Dortmund #18

Sushi Master wrote:Sahin can defend decently, but not Mou-class. He had Schweinsteiger level tackling rates in his last BL season.

I do agree that Mou won't play him without a DM.

Thats sort of proving my point....Schweinsteiger is the passer not the defender, thats why he plays with Gustavo

bhends wrote:

Sushi Master wrote:Sahin can defend decently, but not Mou-class. He had Schweinsteiger level tackling rates in his last BL season.

I do agree that Mou won't play him without a DM.

Thats sort of proving my point....Schweinsteiger is the passer not the defender, thats why he plays with Gustavo

Schweinsteiger defends a shit lot. I was praising Sahin with that comparison, in that he's a complete sort of player.

But yes, the extra DM also helps.

Bender did most of the defensive work at BVB tbf which alot of people have missed or ignored.

The question is, Sahin and Ozil at CM or just Alonso at CM?

Agreed, Mole.

My point is that Sahin > Xabi "tackles don't exist" Alonso when it comes to defending.

If you're playing both Alonso and Sahin, you need a DM and out goes Özil.

Sahin is poor mans Arteta sort of player.

They are good defensively but you cannot afford to start a game without a proper DM.

Often, Wenger leaves just Arteta in midfield but thats in second half depending on situation.

Nuri Sahin is a gem but unfortunately Real Madrid dont know how to use them.

Instead, they are stuck with Khedira and Lass who are not going to dominate a WC midfield anytime soon.

you guys are out of your minds. first. ozil and sahin can play together either in a 4-2-3-1 with sahin as a CM/DLP and ozil as a CAM

or in a 4-3-3 with ozil part of the attacking 3 and sahin as a midfield 3. and no ozil is not being played out of position if he is played on the wing have you not watched him play at werder bremen?

the reason he is not playing is not because he is a flop or going to be sold etc. its because he was hurt the majority of the time he has played here and needs time to adjust to the league and his teammates

hes had 5 total appearances, mostly against scrub teams

highburied wrote:Sahin is poor mans Arteta sort of player.

They are good defensively but you cannot afford to start a game without a proper DM.

Often, Wenger leaves just Arteta in midfield but thats in second half depending on situation.

Nuri Sahin is a gem but unfortunately Real Madrid dont know how to use them.

Instead, they are stuck with Khedira and Lass who are not going to dominate a WC midfield anytime soon.

seriously, do you ever shut up?

and who says alonso cant defend? or sahin for that matter.

alonso consistently rates the highest in tackles won.

deezydeez wrote:and who says alonso cant defend? or sahin for that matter.

alonso consistently rates the highest in tackles won.

source please.

Yuri's thoughts mirror my own, I'm not worried a bit. If he comes through, great. If he doesn't then it's usual business at Real Madrid.

Some RM fans dont know their own players

bhends wrote:

deezydeez wrote:and who says alonso cant defend? or sahin for that matter.

alonso consistently rates the highest in tackles won.

source please.

http://www.realmadridstats.com/steals.html

tackles won:

ramos 182
pepe 154
alonso 153
arbeloa 94 and so on....

deezydeez wrote:

bhends wrote:

deezydeez wrote:and who says alonso cant defend? or sahin for that matter.

alonso consistently rates the highest in tackles won.

source please.

http://www.realmadridstats.com/steals.html

tackles won:

ramos 182
pepe 154
alonso 153
arbeloa 94 and so on....

Real Madrid "steals" 2010/11

A) what is a "steal" ? is that a tackle or an interception?

B) "2010/11"....is that the calendar year or last season? or is that supposed to mean this season? (in which case the guy running the site cant count?) Cause that claims Xabi Alonso has 7 cards in 2010/11....But in the 2010/11 season he had 17...in the 2011/12 season he has 9

When Alonso said tackling is not a skill I think he was referring to slide tackles.

We're running out of time. This player has to be integrated sooner than later, yesterday if that's still possible into the team.

Tackles won (La Liga only), according to WhoScored:

1) Lass 50 total/ 4.5 per match
2) Sergio Ramos 42 /2.6
3) Alonso 49 / 3.1
4) Marcelo 38 / 2.8
5) Coentrão 37 / 3.7

Khedira only 19 / 1.5

Sahin and Alonso..both only play with better defensive players in the midfild than themselves..and you want to play them together at the same time...and with Ozil..

Alright then.

The Franchise wrote:Sahin and Alonso..both only play with better defensive players in the midfild than themselves..and you want to play them together at the same time...and with Ozil..

Alright then.

I tried to explain to them that it's a terrible, terrible idea, but i just failed. Some things are better learnt the hard way, through experience.

The Franchise wrote:Sahin and Alonso..both only play with better defensive players in the midfild than themselves..and you want to play them together at the same time...and with Ozil..

Alright then.

There is literally a reason why we (they) are posting while Real Madrid hired a professional (World Class) manager to handle such decisions.

Sahin flop transfer of the season so far?

Lionel Messi wrote:Sahin flop transfer of the season so far?

Could be or he can be one of the best signings.

Why are people ignoring that we already play 2 CMs?

Khedira is no DM. Every madridista has been saying it for ages that Xabi is our DM. He handles the job but he doesn't do it good. We need a proper DM hence why Lass has been playing so much lately

Mamad wrote:He was injured for 3-4 month.

and yes he needs time. new league and new style of play. remember Benzema's first season.....

This. He will be brilliant for Real. He's young.

People here are always way too impatient.

halamadrid2 wrote:

Idrisozet wrote:

halamadrid2 wrote:yh eh got 90 mins against Ponferradina

if he doesnt fit Mous plans... why did Mou buy him

Same reason why he bought Quaresma

Quaresma wasnt voted the best player in his league

i would compare Quaresma to Pedro Leon

He once had more potential than C.Gagogino, I am sure you know who that is.

The xcx wrote:

highburied wrote:Sahin is poor mans Arteta sort of player.

They are good defensively but you cannot afford to start a game without a proper DM.

Often, Wenger leaves just Arteta in midfield but thats in second half depending on situation.

Nuri Sahin is a gem but unfortunately Real Madrid dont know how to use them.

Instead, they are stuck with Khedira and Lass who are not going to dominate a WC midfield anytime soon.

seriously, do you ever shut up?

Legendary post