Would you rather have....

New game

Poster gives you options of two players. You pick one and then give two players for the next poster to choose from.

-Try to make it interesting and don't go for top 10 players.

-Also don't repeat the players already done.

-Past, present, future (thiago messi etc) all allowed (future is a joke pls). All past players in their prime. Current ones as they are now.

- Neither or both isn't an answer = post deleted.

- Game is essentially "who would you take for the team you support" and NOT "who is better"

------------------------------------------

We begin

Would you rather have..



Ryad Mahrez OR Nolito?

To clear it up. Is this a "who is better" or "who would you take for the team you support" kind of game? If it's the latter, I'd take Maldini over Maradona because Barca already has a GOAT attack so Maldini would improve us more. If it's the former, Maradona is obviously the more decisive and better footballer.

"who would you take for the team you support"


think it will be better to have both players being in the same position (relatively similar anyways) to make it more interesting imo. but you can do defender or mid if u want

Got it. Then let's start.

Nolito.

Özil or James Rodriguez?

James Rodriguez

Gonzalo Higuain or Raheem Sterling

Higuain

Gundogan or Verratti?

Verratti.


Griezmann or Lacazette?

Griezmann for sure


Bale or Reus ?

Reus .

Mexes or Zapata ?

Mexes

Lewandoski or Aguero ?

Lewa

Ramsey or Henderson?

Ramsey without a doubt.

Aubameyang or Reus?

For Madrid Auba but Reus is a better footballer
Bazoer vs Neves at DM

@RG it would be nice to have another thread for explanations. For example probably someone wants to know why X would prefer player Y over player Z etc

No idea who is either but I like the name Neves so...Neves

Ramos or Pepe?

Pepe.

Cristiano Ronaldo or Rivaldo?

Rivaldo. God bless that man.

Um, more interesting, Bebeto or Romario?

Romario.

Aguero or Zlatan?

Zlatan .

y'all need to learn how to play this kind of game . Hint : don't go by the book , try to make the next one choose something awkward , else it's a waste of time .

Fellaini or Felipe Melo ?

- Neither or both isn't an answer (both lol)

- Game is essentially "who would you take for the team you support" and NOT "who is better"

there you go guys , take your pick . And don't forget to imagine what it would be like ! Unless of course you sadly don't have to imagine it , then you have my sympathy . You can still choose the other one if you're a fan of either, grass is always greener on the other side

Fellaini

Jesus Navas or Nani?

Navas

Batistuta or Shevchenko?

Batistuta because of his hair.

Gravesen or Gareth Barry?

Gravesen

Pato or Sturridge

Sturridge , his only problems are injuries.

Deco or Modric ?

Deco. That man was lovely.

Danilo or David May?