worst thread ever

you can tell the op is a barca fan, pele dares say hes better than messi and the bitter hater thread pops up

first, if youre arguing about quaility of leagues, you havent a leg to stand on with la liga

2nd.

how many ballon dors and team of tournaments have xavi been in? yet barca fans claim hes one of the best ever.

3rd.
its all poor logic, modern fanboy reasoning applied to an age where it doesnt apply

every brazilian of that era claims hes the best, every player...but noooooo

team of the year ftw

was team of the year even a big deal back then? its not even a big deal now

jelly op?

ronaldinho is a fly by night, his time was too short to be compared with giggs etc

every reason the op has said pele is overrated applies to giggs and ronaldinho lol

personal awards, quality of leagues, teams etc

smh

Who said that Pele is the best ever? (except fifa). 1200 goals and 3 WC's when teams were winning 15-0 and brazil were dominating the world. 1 golden ball in the wc and a flop in another wc's

today defence and tactics are much stronger

A flop?! The man was injured for 2 World Cups (1962. 1966). Unless you consider injured men flops...

billionmillion wrote:Who said that Pele is the best ever? (except fifa). 1200 goals and 3 WC's when teams were winning 15-0 and brazil were dominating the world. 1 golden ball in the wc and a flop in another wc's

today defence and tactics are much stronger

he would simply adapt to today's game.

btw,you have no idea what youre talking about on the world cup part do you?

Time Magazine: "Pele is therefore a different phenomenon from the baseball or football star. Soccer stars are dependent on their teams even while transcending them. To achieve mythic status as a soccer player is especially difficult because the peak performance is generally quite short--only the fewest players perform at the top of their game for more than five years. Incredibly, Pele performed at the highest level for 18 years, scoring 52 goals in 1973, his 17th year. Contemporary soccer superstars never reach even 50 goals a season. For Pele, who had thrice scored more than 100 goals a year, it signaled retirement."

billionmillion wrote:Who said that Pele is the best ever? (except fifa). 1200 goals and 3 WC's when teams were winning 15-0 and brazil were dominating the world. 1 golden ball in the wc and a flop in another wc's

today defence and tactics are much stronger

can u tell me what defence sir? the defence of puyol and pique? (lmaofffomalallaalal)

@billionmillion, please read the arguments at the first pages correctly.
I assure you that reading them will at least point to the right direction when speaking about past greats.

@OP, I guess you can have your own opinion, and I regret that my arguments could not alter your POV at all. (I really hope you read them at least).
Also, I did not set out to say that Pele is the BEST EVER, just that he is deserving of his Tier 1 spot. Messi did not finish yet, and hence cannot be in contention, yet. (See Owen's case to understand why).

As for the Garrincha Pele debate, based on the footage I have, and the professional assessment. Pele edges Garrincha simply because he was more devoted to the game. I think Gar is more talented, but he woul always be party animal first, and footballer second. Look at it this way, what if Ronaldinho was as devoted as Messi (who strikes high points for that).

I hope my posts provided some insight into the debate.

good point on the comparison of garrincha and ronaldinho,never thought about it

Yeah, its a shame some footballers are just so immature, Cassano really destroyed his potential, and Balo is doing the same thing.

One of the main reasons we are talking so much about Messi and CR today (aside from the obvious talent) is the amount of devotion they put into their game. There are many rough gems out there, but it requires sweat and blood to polish those gems. We shouldn't let all the work go unnoticed.

Pele is definitely the best player ever.

The facts? You don't need facts to know he is.

Lord

I am really enjoying reading your post's your becoming a very valuable member of this community in my eyes.

May i ask was you on the old forum or lurked there or did you just find this forum?

I have been lurking longer than the loch Ness Monster. RAAAWR

And thank you for your kind words.

1st - The golden ball is not given to the best players, sometimes the best ones do not get it.
2nd - South America was the boss until the 90's. Thats when Europe started to import our starts.
3rd - If you mention Argentina and Brazil (Many people did), mention Uruguay, because Uruguay untill the beggining of the 90's was the boss in South America.
4th - Offtopic, but just so you know, Uruguay will win its 15th Copa America this year.

Uruguay wrote:1st - The golden ball is not given to the best players, sometimes the best ones do not get it.
2nd - South America was the boss until the 90's. Thats when Europe started to import our starts.
3rd - If you mention Argentina and Brazil (Many people did), mention Uruguay, because Uruguay untill the beggining of the 90's was the boss in South America.
4th - Offtopic, but just so you know, Uruguay will win its 15th Copa America this year.

lmao that was completely off topic

Uruguay was of course top then (hopefully they regain that statues), In fact, all the Uruguay national team players played in their own league. Which was boss as well. In fact, the Brazilian and Uruguay league were the stronger leagues in SA in the 1960's.

*Cough* Mexico wins Copa America *cough*.

On Topic: Well I do agree Pele is not the best for the following reason: Time.

50 years from now there will be people who will say that Messi is not the best of all time and so forth and so forth. As long as the game keeps advancing time will slowly erase past figueres and create new ones in their place.

Hispano you gotta deal with the Americans first

honestly though,im not sure mexico will make it with both uruguay and chile in the same group

Ganso wrote:honestly though,im not sure mexico will make it with both uruguay and chile in the same group

Aren't Mexico fielding like a B-team as well?

yup..................

Barcelona - Pele's Santos
3-1 in games for Barca...
yeaaah yeaahhh Brazilian league was the best on the world in Pele's time LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
do I have to say that Real Madrid was better than Barca in that time?

how about you mention the time santos trashed barca 5-1?

yup,clearly superior

jog it on

So according to your logic, one game can summarize the whole team, the league, and the international standing.

All the while, you provide zero context for the match, and no real analysis aside from the scoreline.

Ganso wrote:how about you mention the time santos trashed barca 5-1?

yup,clearly superior

jog it on

One game
other 3 Barca won

ChollaVille wrote:

Ganso wrote:how about you mention the time santos trashed barca 5-1?

yup,clearly superior

jog it on

One game
other 3 Barca won

the other 3 which were not in pele's era