Which reminds me, FC Basel also only got 20 goals against in the league so far, but then, they only had 22 matches by now. Yann Sommer FTW!

VivaStPauli wrote:And why would they?

Iker wasn't better than Buffon a couple years ago and he isn't better than Neuer now.

Not that he's bad. But world's best? That's just delusional.

I certainly dont see why Neuer is better than Casillas now. Surely he had a better season with Schalke but i dont see how he is playing above Casillas level now.

Neuer lately has been making more errors than a virgin attempting his first home run ffs

Casillas is the best in the world get over it

I rate buffon and iker at the same level. Buffon was/is the most consistent one, while Iker made the most spectacular defences.

The rest dont come close.

VivaStPauli wrote:And why would they?

Iker wasn't better than Buffon a couple years ago and he isn't better than Neuer now.

Not that he's bad. But world's best? That's just delusional.

i am sorry but iker was definitely better than buffon two years ago

and he is better than neuer this season ,neuer has made one error too many in big games

Actually this thread wasn't a "which GK is better than the other" (we had that numerous times before...), but just raw numbers for the season so far. Defense != GK alone after all. ^^

No modern GK has has a better career than Iker and Iker's career isn't even over.....

Anyway RWO is right, there are usually 4 guys in front of the Keeper that deserve recognition ^^

I bet no one can call(other than RWO ,Viva and Babun) the 4 a the back for gladbach without doing research

Le Samourai wrote:I bet no one can call(other than RWO ,Viva and Babun) the 4 a the back for gladbach without doing research

Jants Dante Deams and Stranzy?

Le Samourai wrote:I bet no one can call(other than RWO ,Viva and Babun) the 4 a the back for gladbach without doing research

ohh excuse you i made the bmg thread in the club section then it was merged

Ok other than the German fans.

Le Samourai wrote:Ok other than the German fans.

Was I right lmao?

You got 2 out of 4 lol.

Le Samourai wrote:You got 2 out of 4 lol.

Really O.o? I really thought that was it

any other than madrid fans backing up casillas here?

I´m not taking any sides just want to see the general opinion

Giggslegend wrote:any other than madrid fans backing up casillas here?

I´m not taking any sides just want to see the general opinion

Casillas > all

end of

Only Ter Stegen has had a better season than Casillas so far IMO (and that's debateable)

Casillas has already pulled alot of wonder saves and still haven't made any error

I see this Neuer> Casillas argument.....then I see the same people come back to posit this Buffon> Casillas argument and it's like.............pick one.

Casillas was once essentially the Neuuer to Buffon's Casillas.....playing behind a crap,WOAT defence and carrying Real Madrid on his shoulders.

Now Casillas is there where Buffon was before and people want completely reverse their argument.It's funny.

He had 1 bad season in there....I'll admit as much....bad by his standards.

@Crim ....you were actually right....

Wikipedia :vagi:

Crimson wrote:Jants Dante Deams and Stranzy?

Really good! You were only deceived by the spelling

Jantschke - Stranzl - Dante - Daems

Neuer is just becoming another Casillas.Getting overrated to no end.

I think Ter Stegen is better than him imo.

Surag wrote:Neuer is just becoming another Buffon .Getting overrated to no end.

I think Ter Stegen is better than him imo.

there, now it looks all right to me

Neur did not do anything to deserve to be called bigger than Iker.

That being said, the lad does indeed have a bright future ahead of him.

Giggslegend wrote:any other than madrid fans backing up casillas here?

I´m not taking any sides just want to see the general opinion

Yep. Me.


OT: Sadly we will not see Casillas being praised for his brilliance this season as obviously one group will be conveniently ignoring all the times he saved Madrid's somewhat inconsistent backline along with the fact that he has produced countless clean-sheets, along with the fact that he is playing for a club where the pressure is certainly higher than Monchengladbach and even Bayern.

Yet we will continue to hear on how brlliant Neuer was last season while ignoring all his blunders with Schalke and his countless blunders with Bayern this season.

Then why isn't Handanovic being mentioned? Why isn't Abbiati of last year being mentioned? What about Buffon this season?

Skewed and overlooked.

Or am I delusional?

Neuer is the most overrated player in the world atm.inb4 stats,youtube videos and someone mentioning his 2010 season