Topic.

Hulk is better in my eyes..

Strong,Brilliant left foot,Pacy and very lethal in front of goal..

Although both di maria possess different characteristics or different playing styles,hulk is more effective than di maria imo..

lol? Di Maria is a tooth Pick...
Hulk is a Monster...

Di Maria by a mile.

Di Maria is a headless chicken. Hulk is more intelligent.

I think Hulk wins this one by a very slight margin.

Di Maria is better.

I thought this thread was a joke... Anybody with half a brain knows Hulk is better than di maria on any day of the week.

hulk fo sho!

right now Hulk is better

Just as a side note, Hulk last season scored more goals than Di Maria has scored in his whole career...

36 goals AND 21 assists this season

I've not seen enough of Hulk to judge him, but Di Maria is just perfect for Madrid. He's pacy, can dribble and finish as well, I can see him becoming a top 10 player in the world in a couple of years time if he continues to progress the way he is doing.

lszanto wrote:Just as a side note, Hulk last season scored more goals than Di Maria has scored in his whole career...

well, Hulk is a natural forward, while di maria is more of a midifelder.

fabregas makes more assists than xavi, yet he is not any better.

El Pipita wrote:Di Maria is a headless chicken. Hulk is more intelligent.

This. Di Maria has ability to dribble and score, but he doesnt know how to play this game. I even prefer right now Callejon starting and Di Maria playing in the second half against Barca, because Di Maria is great @ counterattacking, but useless trying to create some teamwork.

Di Maria's decision making is at times questionable but he's very quick and a great dribbler and scores some fantastic goals on top of that.

Hulk anyday.

Super_Floren wrote:

El Pipita wrote:Di Maria is a headless chicken. Hulk is more intelligent.

This. Di Maria has ability to dribble and score, but he doesnt know how to play this game. I even prefer right now Callejon starting and Di Maria playing in the second half against Barca, because Di Maria is great @ counterattacking, but useless trying to create some teamwork.

sorry you may be super but i disagree with you. Yes hulk may be the better player overall due to his physical prowess but di maria is very underrated. di maria does know how to use his team mates better than you think, he does things that hulk would very unlikely to do such as this

or


or even a bicycle kick

he has great vision and really is improving in this area, yes sometimes he is a bit selfish but if he matures his game slightly he is going to great.

ppl may dislike di maria for his diving but hulk is just as bad if not worse

Don't forget Di Maria's work rate is incredible, always running and pressing as well...

I agree with theguia, Di Maria is our most underrated player (Real Madrid). It's just so sad when I see people want to replace him becouse he doesn't fit the team, yet the problem is just his decisions which CAN be improved. Compare that to mentality ie Benzema, and we still stick to him. (although we didnt have much of a choice)

Worst of all he might get replaced by Neymar.

omarish wrote:I agree with theguia, Di Maria is our most underrated player (Real Madrid). It's just so sad when I see people want to replace him becouse he doesn't fit the team, yet the problem is just his decisions which CAN be improved. Compare that to mentality ie Benzema, and we still stick to him. (although we didnt have much of a choice)

Worst of all he might get replaced by Neymar.

di maria is a very important cog of our system, removing him will make it very difficult for us to defend unless a very good defensive mod is brought in. I personally feel that di maria is a perfect fit for us, he is a perfect foil for cr7 and benzema he also give ozil alot of options, yes his decisions can be improved but he is so young, this season he will come of age, he looks really determined. bringing neymar is more us getting the world next big thing, rather thn utility to our team but i think there will be alot of rotation lets see how it works out.
and i dont see how ppl feel a person doing dirty work is running around like a headless chicken?

Nah, this aint serious?

In Portugal, Hulk was better and it wasnt much of a competition.

Only now he plays for Madrid people (other then the Benfica and Argentina fans) considers this any different.

Hulk and its not very close.

The Franchise wrote:Nah, this aint serious?

In Portugal, Hulk was better and it wasnt much of a competition.

Only now he plays for Madrid people (other then the Benfica and Argentina fans) considers this any different.

Hulk and its not very close.

read carefully, never said di maria is better, just the fact his underrated.
if di maria had the body of hulk our debate would alot different.

Sorry, didnt mean to misquote you.

my post was more directed at the rest though.

I wouldnt mind too much if you thought Di Maria was better, it would be kinda understandable.

no no, as much as i h8 porto and hulk it must said that hulk is one the most fearsome prospects in the world right now