Based on body of work obviously Benzema edges Sturridge. But who would you rather have?

Depends on the coach mainly, and then the other players somewhat.

benzy

I like more Sturridge tbh

Benzema is better, but not by much. Still, they are different type of strikers

Benzema easily.

Benzema a couple classes above.

Not even a comparison.

Easily Benzema, the guy is a talent you can build a team around. Haven't seen this from Sturridge yet tbh, even though he is a great striker in his own right.

Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

Definitely Benzema, much more proven.

Valkyrja wrote:Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

Benzema is not tier 1 striker but definitely good enough to carry the attacking area .

Highburied wrote:

Valkyrja wrote:Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

Benzema is not tier 1 striker but definitely good enough to carry the attacking area .

It's not about him being good enough or not. He obviously is. Based on ability he could start for any team in the world. But mentally he is weak. Too sensitive, losses confidence to easily.

Dislike both, but if I have to say who's better then I'd say probably Benz.
Sturridge still needs to make me a bo-liever.

Valkyrja wrote:Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

benzema mentality ain't weaker than cr tho or does one need a strong mentality to stat pad?  

benz>easily

chad4401 wrote:

Valkyrja wrote:Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

benzema mentality ain't weaker than cr tho or does one need a strong mentality to stat pad?  

benz>easily

Did you just try to say Benzema has a stronger mentality than CR?

izzy wrote:

chad4401 wrote:

Valkyrja wrote:Benzema is too weak mentally to build a team around.

benzema mentality ain't weaker than cr tho or does one need a strong mentality to stat pad?  

benz>easily

Did you just try to say Benzema has a stronger mentality than CR?

yep, that sounds nuts

Benz fangirl.

what can you expect.

yes tell me about all the cl finals big game player cr got us too, cr was notorious as a big game choker couple years ago, didn't he miss his pen against bayern and one against chelsea, he didn't even take one when Portugal got eliminated , cr has come up short in a lot of big games

benz>easily is @ the op clowns lay off the tears girls

chad4401 wrote:yes tell me about all the cl finals big game player cr got us too, cr was notorious as a big game choker couple years ago, didn't he miss his pen against bayern and one against chelsea, he didn't even take one when Portugal got eliminated , cr has come up short in a lot big games  

How sad that you equate mentality with 'big game hurr durr'.

What about consistency?
What about level of play?
What about being relied upon?
What about hard work?
What about effort?

Benzema has a stronger mentality than CR?

I think there needs to be an era of unity and peace for Madrid fans. At least until Bayern knock us out

ah yes i keep forgetting that stat padding is skill that win trophies , big games doesn't count , that why we are winning the league

and i said his mentality isn't weaker clowns

chad4401 wrote:ah yes i keep forgetting that stat padding is skill that win trophies , big games doesn't count , that why we are winning the league

See? You couldn't even answer so you went to your usual rhetoric of 'stat pad hurr durr'.

Don't worry, I'll answer for you;

Is Benzema consistant? No
His level of play? It fluctuates, it's never held to a high level.
Is he relied upon? lol, just France and Madrid REALLY rely on him.
Hard work?
Effort? Zidane and Perez sent him to Italy to get him into shape because he was fat.... Nuff said.

This dude has a strong mentality?

...

izzy wrote:

chad4401 wrote:ah yes i keep forgetting that stat padding is skill that win trophies , big games doesn't count , that why we are winning the league

See? You couldn't even answer so you went to your usual rhetoric of 'stat pad hurr durr'.

Don't worry, I'll answer for you;

Is Benzema consistant? No
His level of play? It fluctuates, it's never held to a high level.
Is he relied upon? lol, just France and Madrid REALLY rely on him.
Hard work?
Effort? Zidane and Perez sent him to Italy to get him into shape because he was fat.... Nuff said.

This dude has a strong mentality?

izzy debating with you is tiresome this is the first season he is a starter and once he finally got going he has held his play up since so argument done.

before madrid he was every good, why cause he played consistently, he has scored in the last 3 games for france since guess what izzy? playing every week at club level

he still show up in a lot of big games but as usual your eyes are closed.

and for all of cr consistency and 40+ goals a season madrid has won a grand total of bleep all, so keep pretending that cr scores hattricks in semi finals bro .

chad4401 wrote:izzy debating with you is tiresome this is the first season he is a starter and once he finally got going he has held his play up since so argument done.

before madrid he was every good, why cause he played consistently, he has scored in the last 3 games for france since guess what izzy? playing every week at club level

he still show up in a lot of big games but as usual your eyes are closed.

and for all of cr consistency and 40+ goals a season madrid has won a grand total of bleep all, so keep pretending that cr scores hattricks in semi finals bro .

You still can't answer simple questions can you?

1st season? Didn't even make the France WC squad.
No, he was a starter in his 2nd season and lost his spot.
He was a starter in his 3rd season and retained it.
4th season? Lost his spot AGAIN.
5th season? Poor first half, better second half.
This equals, inconsistency.

Before Madrid? Lyon? LYON? Please, who cares what he did for Lyon, that team is small compared to Real Madrid and you can play well for Lyon but it means shit when you join a bigger club and your every game is critiqued and Benzema has proven that in his time here, he can not sustain playing at a high level consistantly.

He scored in his last 3 games for France? Why don't you remind me how long he went NOT scoring for France?

He still show up in a lot of big games? He's been here for 5 years and you can name about 5 big games he's shown up for. 5 years, 5 big games. Give this guy a medal.

I love how you keep bringing up Ronaldo and try to denegrate him to propel Benzema. So funny. Ain't gonna work brah, so please keep trying.