Insane footballer who is going down as one of the best ever in his position

Best ever.

Are dreptate.

Equal to R. Carlos in trophies.

Did he surpass him? You decide.

2 goal line clearances
9/10 dribbles succeeded,
11/16 duels won
8 chances created
4 interceptions
1/1 tackles won
1 assist (and what an assist )

guest7 wrote:Equal to R. Carlos in trophies.

Did he surpass him? You decide.

Not sure if he already has a better career, but he is the better player for sure.

Consistently outstanding.

Wasn't Paolo Maldini a left back.

Socur Toxanarosa wrote:

guest7 wrote:Equal to R. Carlos in trophies.

Did he surpass him? You decide.

Not sure if he already has a better career, but he is the better player for sure.

you guys are insane.

sportsczy wrote:

Socur Toxanarosa wrote:

guest7 wrote:Equal to R. Carlos in trophies.

Did he surpass him? You decide.

Not sure if he already has a better career, but he is the better player for sure.

you guys are insane.

no they're not.

You actually think Marcelo is better than Roberto Carlos (comparing both at the height of their respective playing careers)?!

It's not a bad comparison, the only thing that's stopping Marcelo is his performances with the national team,

Doc wrote:You actually think Marcelo is better than Roberto Carlos (comparing both at the height of their respective playing careers)?!

Yeah. On form he is the best attacking full back of all times

"Best attacking fullback"

Since are doing that, imo CR is the best attacking fullback of all time.

lol i love when we make up new categories to give the players we like extra props because we know their deficiencies. e.g. a fan knows a goalie isn't the best in the world, but to make him better than he is we say "best passing goal keeper", or a dm/cb whose defending is bonkers becomes "most acrobatic dm, or best passing dm"...

one thing i'd give marcelo, the kid's got a lot of heart, but he ike ramos still gives me panic attacks on defense, sometimes he's not even in his position at all, like that last semi final against juve. he's fantastic for our team, but its high time someone taught him to defend a little. and he's also a bit of an injury prone player. i'm not going to talk about comparing him to carlos maldini zanetti et al, its disrespectful to them. let the man enjoy his time

Carlos was better in attacking as well, just fyi Valk but I like that you're consistent with this one so I'll just agree to disagree with your view on Marcelo. That being said, would not trade him with any left back out currently, well, not anymore.

I like Marcelo but he is too incomplete to be compared to Carlos and specially Maldini.

Even Alex Sandro is a more complete left-back. Needs one more year at the same level before everyone realizes it.

Warrior wrote:Even Alex Sandro is a more complete left-back. Needs one more year at the same level before everyone realizes it.

lol no

Valkyrja wrote:

Doc wrote:You actually think Marcelo is better than Roberto Carlos (comparing both at the height of their respective playing careers)?!

Yeah. On form he is the best attacking full back of all times

That has to be one of the most ridiculous things I've read in my years one here

Hapless_Hans wrote:

Valkyrja wrote:

Doc wrote:You actually think Marcelo is better than Roberto Carlos (comparing both at the height of their respective playing careers)?!

Yeah. On form he is the best attacking full back of all times

That has to be one of the most ridiculous things I've read in my years one here

I don't know why that surprises you. All current top players are the greatest of all time. Millions of people born during the 90s and 00s can confirm it

Valkyrja wrote:

Doc wrote:You actually think Marcelo is better than Roberto Carlos (comparing both at the height of their respective playing careers)?!

Yeah. On form he is the best attacking full back of all times

only if football started 10 years ago.

Kind of like how every player from the 80s and 90s are the best ever to people 10-20 years older. There'll always be a generation bias.