The idea was interesting but too much emphasis was put on hype. Put both teams together

Top:

-----------------Neuer------------------

Selassie---Hummels--- Agger-----Evra

------------Schweini---Pirlo-------------
----------------Iniesta----------------
---Silva-----------------------Dzagoev--
--------------Gomez---------------------

Flop:

----------------Cech------------------

VDW----Chiellini---Dunne--Holebas

-----------MVB---Busquets---------------
-------------- --------------------
Robben-------------------Podolski-
-------Kershakov---CR7--------

No Torres

Aw cman...benzemas only played one game..

And he still managed some vicious drives despite the stubborn defense he was up against.

Replace him with kerzakhov and that'd be more fair.

And same goes for sheva. One game, two goals..good for him. But Gomez still deserves it more. And Dzagoev over Nani

Top


inb4evraiscrap - he was great in his first match (surprisingly).

Flop

Replace Ozil with Benz "false 10"

And Torres on the Bench for the Top team

The Lizard King wrote:Aw cman...benzemas only played one game..

And he still managed some vicious drives despite the stubborn defense he was up against.

Replace him with kerzakhov and that'd be more fair.

And same goes for sheva. One game, two goals..good for him. But Gomez still deserves it more. And Dzagoev over Nani

It's the current top/ flop eleven. Reading comprehension makes life easier

Nani ahead of Arshavin ???!!!! Really ???

I thought Willems was okay at the least...Definitely not a flop IMO

BhritanniaBhlue wrote:I thought Willems was okay at the least...Definitely not a flop IMO

He lost Gomez for the second goal and had trouble covering Müller all game long( first goal).

@I adjusted the top eleven with Dzagoev for Nani and Gomez for Sheva.

BhritanniaBhlue wrote:I thought Willems was okay at the least...Definitely not a flop IMO

To be fair, Willems was woeful against us too.

Too much to ask from a teenager, not to mention poor guy got ZERO ,and I mean ZERO help from Affellay

Immortal Babun wrote:

BhritanniaBhlue wrote:I thought Willems was okay at the least...Definitely not a flop IMO

He lost Gomez for the second goal and had trouble covering Müller all game long( first goal).

@I adjusted the top eleven with Dzagoev for Nani and Gomez for Sheva.

For the first goal Muller made a run across the center of the pitch...He's a fullback he's not supposed to follow him all the way across the field, that would've meant leaving the left flank exposed and there was someone else (dont remember who) standing right there

He did lose Gomez for the one goal, but with the way he was getting overloaded all game to lose a CF when he's not usually your marking responsibility (while clearly an error) isn't egregious

Thought Coentrao was far worse for Portugal, and the guy from Greece far worse as well (Hole-something?)

Actually, Coentrao played very well. He was overloaded like Willems because CR7 didn't track back properly
I think Holebas deserves to be in flop eleven.

Coentrao definitely didn't receive any help either, no arguments there

Don't think he played well at ALL though (just that he didnt get any help)

Immortal Babun wrote:

The Lizard King wrote:Aw cman...benzemas only played one game..

And he still managed some vicious drives despite the stubborn defense he was up against.

Replace him with kerzakhov and that'd be more fair.

And same goes for sheva. One game, two goals..good for him. But Gomez still deserves it more. And Dzagoev over Nani

It's the current top/ flop eleven. Reading comprehension makes life easier

Looks like you made the changes anyway....guess we both need reading classes eh ? Or you could just have been mistaken in choosing players that didn't even play the same amount of games Denial makes life easier too I suppose

What in the world is Robben doing there.....?


and why the hell is Boateng not in top

The Messiah wrote:What in the world is Robben doing there.....?


and why the hell is Boateng not in top

It says current UNBIASED, Robben is up there for a reason and it's a good one.

I'm contempt to put Sneijder up there instead of Dzagoev but it's close.

Top.
--------------------Neuer-----------------
Boateng-Hummels-Badstuber-Lahm
-----------Schweini--Diarra-------------
Robben-----------Muller----------Ribery
-----------------Gomez-----------------


I can't be bother with flops but I know for certain CR9 is there

The Messiah wrote:Top.
--------------------Neuer-----------------
Boateng-Hummels-Badstuber-Lahm
-----------Schweini--Diarra-------------
Robben-----------Muller----------Ribery
-----------------Gomez-----------------


I can't be bother with flops but I know for certain CR9 is there

10 Bayern players, this is so unbiased; seriously mate...

Potential wrote:

The Messiah wrote:Top.
--------------------Neuer-----------------
Boateng-Hummels-Badstuber-Lahm
-----------Schweini--Diarra-------------
Robben-----------Muller----------Ribery
-----------------Gomez-----------------


I can't be bother with flops but I know for certain CR9 is there

10 Bayern players, this is so unbiased; seriously mate...

they haven't lost any match and 1 goal conceded that's my top Back-line, ontop of that it's group of death, I'm not here to give you credit for beating weak teams like Ireland, Ukraine, Cech etc.

-------------------------------------------Pyatov------------------------------------------

----------------------Agger-------------Mellberg-----------------Hummels---------------

----------------------Diarra---------------Pirlo----------------Marchisio---------------

----Silva---------------------------------Iniesta--------------------------Dzagoev-----

-------------------------------------------Gomez----------------------------------------

7amood11 wrote:-------------------------------------------Pyatov------------------------------------------

----------------------Agger-------------Mellberg-----------------Hummels---------------

----------------------Diarra---------------Pirlo----------------Marchisio---------------

----Silva---------------------------------Iniesta--------------------------Dzagoev-----

-------------------------------------------Gomez----------------------------------------

Marchisio has been crap so far. Yeah, he's got lots of work rate but he completely failed in attack. Diarra is a defensive guru, he doesn't provide anything in attack. I don't see anything in his game which would put him above Schweini performance.


Question, how did you like Cecz' rightback?

Top:

Immortal Babun wrote:

7amood11 wrote:-------------------------------------------Pyatov------------------------------------------

----------------------Agger-------------Mellberg-----------------Hummels---------------

----------------------Diarra---------------Pirlo----------------Marchisio---------------

----Silva---------------------------------Iniesta--------------------------Dzagoev-----

-------------------------------------------Gomez----------------------------------------

Marchisio has been crap so far. Yeah, he's got lots of work rate but he completely failed in attack. Diarra is a defensive guru, he doesn't provide anything in attack. I don't see anything in his game which would put him above Schweini performance.


Question, how did you like Cecz' rightback?

Crap is a little strong no?

He has still had the most amount of shots for Italy in both games, 2 against Spain and 4 against Croatia; only one of those was off target...barely. He's still getting in great positions.

Just been unlucky in front of goal. Had they gone in the top 5 goals so far would be dominated by him

Immortal Babun wrote:

7amood11 wrote:-------------------------------------------Pyatov------------------------------------------

----------------------Agger-------------Mellberg-----------------Hummels---------------

----------------------Diarra---------------Pirlo----------------Marchisio---------------

----Silva---------------------------------Iniesta--------------------------Dzagoev-----

-------------------------------------------Gomez----------------------------------------

Marchisio has been crap so far. Yeah, he's got lots of work rate but he completely failed in attack. Diarra is a defensive guru, he doesn't provide anything in attack. I don't see anything in his game which would put him above Schweini performance.


Question, how did you like Cecz' rightback?

I disagree about Marchisio, he's been great. His hard work barely gets noticed, same as when he was playing with Juve this season.

Gebre Selassie? He's a beast, easily Czech Republic's best player and dominated the whole right flank, especially last night vs Poland. I might have to revise my line-up (which does look kind of shitty in retrospect) to include Selassie.

-------------------------------------------Pyatov--------------------------------------

--------Selassie---------------Hummels--------------Mellberg---------------Evra-----

-----------------Diarra/Schweini------------Pirlo---------------Marchisio------------

--------------------Silva------------------Gomez---------------Iniesta--------------

Marchisio and Pirlo have been the only shining lights in what has been an underwhelming campaign for Italy.

Still if you compare him with some of the midfielders of the other teams i think he's done better and he deserves a place in my opinion.