Do you see him as a flop or not

No

If he din't get us top four....i would consider him a flop but he has done alright just a lack of consistency.

No one should use the position thing as an excuse...a player of Arshavin's talent should be able to play there

Arshivan we love the guy, once a while he produces magic. :shisha:

Can the admins can change the title:its 'flop' and I guess it wasn't noticed.....quite misleading.....I thought 'twas some exclusive slang used in Arsenal sub-forum

Arshavin cannot be definitely regarded as flop,he has helped Arsenal immensely and I still consider him to be one of the most stylish players around...

The problem with Arsha and Chamakh is that they both are confidence players.When they are in form,they're really good but when they are bad,they're really bad.If Arsha can get back his confidence,which he must have after his virtuoso display vs. Bolton,he can contribute well....and give his best,like he did last year vs. Aston Villa.

Arshivan has been a good buy and did help us many games last season and the season he was bought. He is still a great player with great vision, if we go back in time I would still buy him.

don't think Wenger motivates him proprely...certain players need a good bollocking to perform well, Arshavin seems like one of those guys.

Wenger just shows him way too much respect

Nope definitely not a flop

gunnerlistick wrote:don't think Wenger motivates him proprely...certain players need a good bollocking to perform well, Arshavin seems like one of those guys.

Wenger just shows him way too much respect

Arshivan is a grown man and is the captain of Russia I dont think he needs anyone to tell him anything. Arshavin knows what he is doing and so far he has been great.

Raptorgunner wrote:

gunnerlistick wrote:don't think Wenger motivates him proprely...certain players need a good bollocking to perform well, Arshavin seems like one of those guys.

Wenger just shows him way too much respect

Arshivan is a grown man and is the captain of Russia I dont think he needs anyone to tell him anything. Arshavin knows what he is doing and so far he has been great.

yeah but a player of his talent can't be this inconsistent heck even Dirk kuyt has been more consistent than Arshavin plus his fitness is just embarrassing for a football player let alone a captain

nope, not a flop

quite the character, though... and at this stage in his Arsenal career, I think he is best suited coming off the bench. He really doesn't have the work rate to last all game... But, bring him on in the last 20-25 mins when we need a spark... perfect!

not a flop


he was worth all the money we spent on him.... he got us CL which paid for his fee

Just for his goal against Barca, he is not. lol

on topic, as someone said, if i had to go back, i would still purchase him.

Now the catch is if Anzhi/Some random Rich club comes up with a fat offer for Arshavin,will you let him go or not?

Andrei Arshavin's stats since joining Arsenal:

08/09 - P15 G6 A9
09/10 - P39 G12 A7
10/11 - P52 G10 A17

Total: P114 G29 A33

Now consider that he's been playing out of position since he's got here, would you say those are particular bad statistics? I wouldn't. They're certainly not stats of a flop.

In terms of consistency, he's been disappointing and because of that, he's not cemented himself as one of the league's best players as he should be. But, in terms of producivity and scoring important goals, he's been very good.

As for whether we should sell him if an offer comes: I say yes, only because I think we need to freshen up the left wing a bit with a more consistent player.

Statistically speaking, even when he is having an off season, this guy racks up some good numbers on assists and goals! You can't expect magic everday from this guy..

Anyway, the only annoying thing about him is his fitness lol. for someone who dreams of playing for barca (those guys are insanely fit, probably on drugs) his fitness is appaling to say the least

@gunnerslick;
positioning is an excuse for him dude. Is it any coincidence that his best performance for a log time now, came when he played behind the striker? No it's not a coincidence.

Shava has a hard time running up and down the flanks, he is not a very fit player, yet we are asking him to do quite a bit of running. So he isnt gonna do very well on the flanks. + hes not very consistent.

underperformer but not a flop

The Verminator wrote:@gunnerslick;
positioning is an excuse for him dude. Is it any coincidence that his best performance for a log time now, came when he played behind the striker? No it's not a coincidence.

Shava has a hard time running up and down the flanks, he is not a very fit player, yet we are asking him to do quite a bit of running. So he isnt gonna do very well on the flanks. + hes not very consistent.

so he gets paid all that money not to be fit ??....all footballers should be fit they are athlete after all, Figo,Ronaldinho all these players were attacking midfielder in the number ten mould yet they played on the wing and performed well because they were extremely talented.

So i don't see why Arshavin should use the position as an excuse

The Verminator wrote:@gunnerslick;
positioning is an excuse for him dude. Is it any coincidence that his best performance for a log time now, came when he played behind the striker? No it's not a coincidence.

Shava has a hard time running up and down the flanks, he is not a very fit player, yet we are asking him to do quite a bit of running. So he isnt gonna do very well on the flanks. + hes not very consistent.

LOL WUT?! Not sure if serious!

I'm not buying that for one moment. The guy trains exactly the same way as his peers. So the whole fitness nonsense, I'm not buying it!

However, Arshavin sits somewhere between a good buy and a flop. It's that simple. A lot of the time, he doesn't turn up for big games, it's as simple as that. Ok, so he plays slightly out of position; but he's hardly playing defensive midfield as opposed to Central attacking. He isn't getting any younger, so I say cash in on him when the opportunity arises.

Arshavin is just lazy. Full stop. When he was playing in his preferred role for Zenit and Russia, that wasn't much of an issue but playing out wide requires some amount of work rate.

Unfortunately, Wenger doesn't seem to like the idea of playing two offensive wingers, a no.10 and a striker and so Arshavin wound on the flanks. You'd have thought by now he had grown accustomed to the role and its demmands, but since he's so inconsistent that doesn't seem like the case.

Arshavin's Arsenal career: Played119 Scored 30 Assisted 34.

Like Jay said earlier these stats for a guy playing out of position are very very decent.

Do I consider Arshavin a flop? No. His stats are too impressive and he hasn't always started games so his appearances also include 5-20 minute cameos so his goals/assists to game ratio would be even more impressive if based on starts.

The stand-out memories; Scoring 4 at Anfield, Scoring an over-head kick at Wigan, Scoring v Barcelona, Scoring great strike at Old Trafford. And ones that people forget...such as his brilliant display v Aston Villa in 4-2 last season when he linked up with Rosicky, Nasri + Chamakh brilliantly.

Of course, times when he plays like he just can't do it anymore (like against Marseille) I get angry but I think the goods out-way the bads, meaning he is not a flop.

Arsène Wenger says that Andrey Arshavin is a vital part of his squad.

The Russian forward showed his quality with a fine display in the 2-1 Carling Cup victory over Bolton on Tuesday night, scoring one and setting up the second for Ju Young Park to turn the Fourth-Round tie on its head.

Arshavin starred in a roving central role behind the South Korean striker and Wenger admits he is more comfortable in that position.

“I believe that he is more at ease now in a more central role because if he is on the flanks it is very physical and you have to defend a lot,” the manager told Arsenal Player. “That's not always his strongest part in the game.

“You can see that in the future he can be a very influential player behind the striker.”

Arshavin has sometimes struggled to hit the heights of his dazzling debut season in an Arsenal shirt but Wenger has never doubted the 30-year-old’s qualities.

“This guy is an absolutely top class player but something somewhere gets people a little bit reluctant sometimes.

“You look at his assists and goals scored and he is always among the best. He can come on and have an impact, he can start and have an impact - Andrey is an impact player.”

The problem with Arsha and Chamakh is that they both are confidence players.When they are in form,they're really good but when they are bad,they're really bad.If Arsha can get back his confidence,which he must have after his virtuoso display vs. Bolton,he can contribute well....and give his best,like he did last year vs. Aston Villa.

The stand-out memories; Scoring 4 at Anfield, Scoring an over-head kick at Wigan, Scoring v Barcelona, Scoring great strike at Old Trafford. And ones that people forget...such as his brilliant display v Aston Villa in 4-2 last season when he linked up with Rosicky, Nasri + Chamakh brilliantly.

Arshavin's good performances were so few last season,I guess everyone will remember all his good performances