Pogba vs Thiago

cant believe we dont have one yet.

so...?

Thiago by far

Thiago because he plays in CL whereas Pogba's team doesnt as they flopped plus he plays in a weak Serie A and Thiago scored a wonder goal last week too so...yeah,Thiago..

/GL

Both scrubs.

Pogba for me

Let's be fair they are different types of players and as such we can't judge them on the same skills. The fact that thiago has about 10000000x more quality with the ball as a better passer, dribbler, keeping possession, doesn't necessarily make him a better player even though they are both midfielders. Pogba is quite big, and strong, and has a powerful shot, remember that

DuringTheWar wrote:Let's be fair they are different types of players and as such we can't judge them on the same skills. The fact that thiago has about 10000000x more quality with the ball as a better passer, dribbler, keeping possession, doesn't necessarily make him a better player even though they are both midfielders. Pogba is quite big, and strong, and has a powerful shot, remember that

You really wouldnt stop would you The same old ignorant description in each thread concerning him.Its like you genuinely have a grudge against him.

you disagree? So, is he a better passer than thiago? A better dribbler? Better at keeping possession? Is he not big? Is he not strong? Does he not have a powerful shot? Which of the statements I made is wrong?

No i dont actually disagree but you're again ,just exagerrating to make a point.

Thiago is obviously a better passer and probably better at keeping possession too but in other areas it might actually be closer than you think,seriously.Pogba's incredible at close control dribbling,and he does put it to use quite often,i am really not sure you've noticed that.Technically i cant say there's much wrong with him apart from his passing(which is still good at this level) and it could improve with time.He's only 20 afterall.

Thiago's passing ability is a bit overrated and loses possession more often than let's say a Pogba who's more safe in his passing.

Not to mention his decision making is often poor like when tries to dribble past a player (and he loses possession in process quite often) when he should take a pass or pass it when he should shoot.

In that regard I find Pogba better, he's smarter. But Thiago is better in other things which are already mentioned here.

If I could choose.. Pogba for me!

Thiago loses a lot of possession, but he just gives some orgasmic pirlo-esque balls many times.

I would go with Thiago

Pogba for me too.

The way he does things just looks effortless. That's perhaps more of a preference then, but I feel he is/will be the better of the two

Both together would make a great midfield.

Anyway, It depends on what you want but personally, I'd take Pogba.

I personally prefer Pogba

DuringTheWar wrote:Let's be fair they are different types of players and as such we can't judge them on the same skills. The fact that thiago has about 10000000x more quality with the ball as a better passer, dribbler, keeping possession, doesn't necessarily make him a better player even though they are both midfielders. Pogba is quite big, and strong, and has a powerful shot, remember that

now now, lets not exaggerate here, its more like 100000x more quality in ALL those areas, so its closer than you think.

their partnership would be great imo.

Since, we have better players than Thiago at Arsenal, with Ramsey and Wilshere, soon to be Chambo, Id go with Pogba.

Players like Pogba is harder to find.

Thiago has way more quality, but is also 2 years older so the comparison is not exactly fair. The Thiago of 2 years old was not as good as Pogba is now.

I have to agree, a two year old Thiago couldn't have possibly been as good as Pogba.

bump. LOLmasiareject vs FRAUDGBA

Alcantara, Pogba is an overrated you tube player..

Killer wrote:Alcantara, Pogba is an overrated you tube player..

So is Thiago, to be fair.

Kovacic >>>>>

Mr Nick09 wrote:Kovacic >>>>>

Thiago will be 25 this season and is playing for Bayern after playing for Barca. Pogba will be 23 and he has not played with the creme de la creme yet. when that happens he'll get better. Right now Thiago might be ( although injury prone ) but Pogba is not far behind and is a very mature player.