Worst refereeing performance?

by AltoZ Thu Mar 28, 2013 6:54 pm

So whats the worst game by a ref you have seen. The biggest robbery.

A top 5 i can name on top of my head:

1. Ovrebo, Chelsea-Barcelona 2009.
2. Moreno, South Korea-Italy 2002.
3. Graham Poll, Croatia-Australia 2006.
4. Mark Clattenburg, Chelsea-United 2012.
5. Wolfgang Stark, Real-Barcelona 2011.

HM: Whoever was in charge of the South Korea-Spain game, 2002.

by danyjr Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:14 pm

AltoZ wrote:HM: Whoever was in charge of the South Korea-Spain game, 2002.

Gamal Al-Ghandour. And he was obviously bribed.

Overbo was another disgraceful refereeing performance.

Stark? He shouldn't be on this list.

by Abramovich Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:17 pm

Ovrebo will forever be remembered as the worst ever.

by harhar11 Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:17 pm

AltoZ wrote:So whats the worst game by a ref you have seen. The biggest robbery.

A top 5 i can name on top of my head:

1. Ovrebo, Chelsea-Barcelona 2009.
2. Moreno, South Korea-Italy 2002.
3. Graham Poll, Croatia-Australia 2006.
4. Mark Clattenburg, Chelsea-United 2012.
5. Wolfgang Stark, Real-Barcelona 2011.

HM: Whoever was in charge of the South Korea-Spain game, 2002.

What? O_o

Anyway, the one who was the referee in the Inter vs Chelsea game should be there. IIRC, Chelsea was robbed of 4 stonewall penalties, not 50-50 like in the Chelsea - Barca...

Abramovich wrote:Ovrebo will forever be remembered as the worst ever.

Yeah, but not just against chelsea...

Edit: no, actually I think that the spain vs south korea referee was even worse. He disallowed like 2-3 legal spanish goals..

by VivaStPauli Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:25 pm

The refs that waved Spain through against Chile and Paraguay at the 2010 WC were pretty pathetic, just like the one that robbed the US of like 3 goals against Slovenia and someone else I forgot, also in South Africa.

All in all, that WC had tremendously shit refereeing, like De Jong not being sent off for attempting to murder Xabi, or Iniesta staying on after slapping MvB right in the face in front of the linesman.

Honestly, I remember lots of shit calls, but I always forget which ref it was. Not giving the Lamps goal against Germany in Bloemfontain was horrible as well, but I can live with that one Razz

Dortmund also got the ref-shaft a lot in EL and UCL the past two seasons. TBH I tend to forget shit refs if they screw over both teams equally, which is BS, because they still screwed up, they just got lucky.

by harhar11 Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:39 pm

VivaStPauli wrote:The refs that waved Spain through against Chile and Paraguay at the 2010 WC were pretty pathetic, just like the one that robbed the US of like 3 goals against Slovenia and someone else I forgot, also in South Africa.

All in all, that WC had tremendously shit refereeing, like De Jong not being sent off for attempting to murder Xabi, or Iniesta staying on after slapping MvB right in the face in front of the linesman.

Honestly, I remember lots of shit calls, but I always forget which ref it was. Not giving the Lamps goal against Germany in Bloemfontain was horrible as well, but I can live with that one

Dortmund also got the ref-shaft a lot in EL and UCL the past two seasons. TBH I tend to forget shit refs if they screw over both teams equally, which is BS, because they still screwed up, they just got lucky.

Dude, I am a Chilean but how did the referee rob us and Paraguay? Torres acted like hell to get, don't remember who got sent off, one of our player sent off but IIRC he should have been sent off earlier.

And Paraguay got a goal disallowed, but IIRC one of their forwards was offside and he tried to head the ball meaning that he was interfering with the play, eventhough he didnt touch the ball. And also, shouldn't Fabregas have had a penalty when he tried to get the rebound of Alonso's penalty miss?

So if anything against Spain should have been the team that felt hard done by the referee against Paraguay..

by EL Patron Thu Mar 28, 2013 7:50 pm

The ref in the Celtic against Juve game, Celtic should have been awarded at least two penalty's

by CBarca Thu Mar 28, 2013 8:43 pm

Coulibaly in the US-Slovenia game.

Has an explanation of the disallowed goal ever been given yet?

by Eman Thu Mar 28, 2013 9:11 pm

Phil Dowd for his performance in Newcastle's 'epic' comeback versus Arsenal a couple of seasons back Rolling Eyes

by Lex Thu Mar 28, 2013 9:14 pm

Moreno doesn't count because he was being a prick on purpose. The list should be reserved for refs who are inept due to poor officiating skills.

by Lex Thu Mar 28, 2013 9:15 pm

6. Every La Liga linesman. 2008 -

by VivaStPauli Thu Mar 28, 2013 9:20 pm

CBarca wrote:Coulibaly in the US-Slovenia game.

Has an explanation of the disallowed goal ever been given yet?

At least not in the next few weeks after the WC, because I was waiting for an explanation. Hands down the weirdest call at the WC.

by Kick Sun Mar 31, 2013 8:32 am

Isn't this thread a bit obvious?

Gonna be ovrebo every time.

by Forza Sun Mar 31, 2013 8:37 am

This linesman:
https://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=309963813820

by The Sanchez Sun Mar 31, 2013 8:47 am

Lex wrote:6. Every La Liga linesman. 2008 -

by El Gunner Sun Mar 31, 2013 1:12 pm

Watch the EPL and you'll see at least 3 crazy, unexplained decisions per week...

by Onyx Sun Mar 31, 2013 1:19 pm

Forza Rossoneri wrote:This linesman:
https://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=309963813820

I think maybe because it was played across the goal a bit it may have not looked offside at the time.

by Harmonica Sun Mar 31, 2013 1:34 pm

El Gunner wrote:Watch the EPL and you'll see at least 3 crazy, unexplained decisions per week...

Almost the same as in every match in Spain.

by Valkyrja Sun Mar 31, 2013 2:14 pm

England-Germany in 2010 ?

by The Nature Boy Sun Mar 31, 2013 4:57 pm

Worst refereeing performance? Pierluigi-collina-net-worth

he disapproves of this thread.

by harhar11 Sun Mar 31, 2013 5:20 pm

The Nature Boy wrote:

he disapproves of this thread.

Still remember how he cost us the tie against Chelsea in the CL 04/05! Mad

by Onyx Sun Mar 31, 2013 5:23 pm

The Nature Boy wrote:

he disapproves of this thread.

PES 2003 cover. :bow:

by AltoZ Sun Mar 31, 2013 6:02 pm

@Harhar11

But it was all fine the following year with Terje Hauge/Del Horno/Messi on that horrible pitch.

by harhar11 Sun Mar 31, 2013 6:26 pm

AltoZ wrote:@Harhar11

But it was all fine the following year with Terje Hauge/Del Horno/Messi on that horrible pitch.

Of course it wasn't fine that Del Horno almost broke Messi's leg with this tackle..

And Messi got this bruises thanks to that thugish tackle..
Worst refereeing performance? 1140980555

Worst refereeing performance? 1140980555

It was a disgrace that Barca didn't even get a freekick nor did Del Horno get a yellow card. Mad

Edit: speaking of that match, shouldn't Barca have had 2 penalties in that game? one for a blatant handball by, I think, Terry. With not getting even a yellow card with a red worthy tackle + 2 penalties not given to Barca, we can add this game for that list of bad refereeing.

by stunt Sun Mar 31, 2013 6:32 pm

All of south korea's games in wc 2002.

by Sponsored content

Worst refereeing performance?

Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?

Re: Worst refereeing performance?