Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
+12
McAgger
Zealous
Highburied
Great Leader Sprucenuce
Onyx
chinomaster182
nichabr
la bestia negra
BarrileteCosmico
Luca
VivaStPauli
Kaladin
16 posters
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL after a transfer be removed?
Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
The January transfer market has never been the best market and that has proved itself over the years. You get very few big transfers - all the big transfers are done in the summer. Do you think it would be beneficial or detrimental if this rule about Cup-tied player would be removed? Keep in mind the potential of teams being able to bounce back hard with big tranfers if this rule is removed, it would make the R16 unpredictable.
Last edited by El Shaarawy on Thu Mar 07, 2013 10:44 pm; edited 2 times in total
Kaladin- Stormblessed
- Club Supported :
Posts : 24585
Join date : 2012-06-28
Age : 30
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Yes, I don't really see what's the point of the rule TBH, if they move domestically, they can play against their former clubs in the league, I don't see how the cup games are much different.
VivaStPauli- Fan Favorite
- Club Supported :
Posts : 9002
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 39
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Added a poll see what you guys think
Kaladin- Stormblessed
- Club Supported :
Posts : 24585
Join date : 2012-06-28
Age : 30
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
No I don't think so. It would encourage even crazier January spending, in my opinion.
Plus the competition is rather short; I don't think it would be fair if a player could play for two clubs and end up winning the cup.
I mean this is all based on the tournament format.
Maybe, since there is 6 group games, if you didn't participate in more than half of the games then you could be eligible for another team after transfer. So you can play in up to 3 games with one club and still transfer and play
Plus the competition is rather short; I don't think it would be fair if a player could play for two clubs and end up winning the cup.
I mean this is all based on the tournament format.
Maybe, since there is 6 group games, if you didn't participate in more than half of the games then you could be eligible for another team after transfer. So you can play in up to 3 games with one club and still transfer and play
Luca- J Council Master
- Club Supported :
Posts : 14135
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 31
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
I think the rule is in place so that players don't move out of their team in order to still compete in the Champions league if their team is knocked out. I'm not sure.
BarrileteCosmico- Admin
- Club Supported :
Posts : 28277
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 33
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
wouldn't mind it for player's who got slim to no playing time tbh
la bestia negra- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 2548
Join date : 2011-12-14
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
no i don't think it should be removed because if a team gets kicked out their top players might get tempted to jump ship to the team that is still in the competition.
nichabr- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 1251
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
I think the rule shouldn't apply for those that only played one or two games in a squad rotating way. Some guys only play some minutes in a qualifier and bam, cup tied.
chinomaster182- Starlet
- Club Supported :
Posts : 990
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 36
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
I mean it's not like by the end of January it's the CL semis or something. It's still the last 16 and still a long way to go until a team can win it.
Onyx- Forum Legend
- Club Supported :
Posts : 40128
Join date : 2011-06-05
Does anyone hate the cup tied rule when a player moves club?
I know i f*cking do, don't see why a player should move club and not be allowed to play.
If a club signs a player he should be allowed to play....
Milan has Balotelli, we have Debuchy and Gouffran and Liverpool, ok they are KO'ed out now but they could have got through if the rule didn't exist had Coutinho and Sturridge etc etc.
You could argue i'm butthurt because two of our best players can't play and you would be right but i still think the rule is moronic.
Anyone agree?
If a club signs a player he should be allowed to play....
Milan has Balotelli, we have Debuchy and Gouffran and Liverpool, ok they are KO'ed out now but they could have got through if the rule didn't exist had Coutinho and Sturridge etc etc.
You could argue i'm butthurt because two of our best players can't play and you would be right but i still think the rule is moronic.
Anyone agree?
Great Leader Sprucenuce- Forum Legend
- Club Supported :
Posts : 68988
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 34
Kaladin- Stormblessed
- Club Supported :
Posts : 24585
Join date : 2012-06-28
Age : 30
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
I just bumped my old topic
Kaladin- Stormblessed
- Club Supported :
Posts : 24585
Join date : 2012-06-28
Age : 30
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
i think the rule changing should apply to EL as well btw but i agree.
Plus i think my thread should be merged into this one
Plus i think my thread should be merged into this one
Great Leader Sprucenuce- Forum Legend
- Club Supported :
Posts : 68988
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 34
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
At least one addition should be allowed to play in CL.
Highburied- Banned (Permanent)
- Club Supported :
Posts : 2630
Join date : 2011-06-06
Age : 41
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
El Shaarawy wrote:I just bumped my old topic
Why?
Highburied- Banned (Permanent)
- Club Supported :
Posts : 2630
Join date : 2011-06-06
Age : 41
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
highburied wrote:El Shaarawy wrote:I just bumped my old topic
Why?
Because canoes can't make donuts fly to the moon
Kaladin- Stormblessed
- Club Supported :
Posts : 24585
Join date : 2012-06-28
Age : 30
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
It would make things much more interesting for sure. ( Balo vs Barca )
But I think there should be conditions. Like you can't play if you already played a set number of minutes with a team that has been knocked out of the CL already or something like that.
But I think there should be conditions. Like you can't play if you already played a set number of minutes with a team that has been knocked out of the CL already or something like that.
Zealous- World Class Contributor
- Club Supported :
Posts : 16098
Join date : 2011-08-01
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
FFS YES. If we had Sturridge and Coutinho playing that Zenit match we would be through right now
McAgger- Ballon d'Or Contender
- Club Supported :
Posts : 28318
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 107
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Messiah "Aggerswagger" wrote:FFS YES. If we had Sturridge and Coutinho playing that Zenit match we would be through right now
I agree with this, but honestly I'm not sure if I would have said it should be eliminated before our January window. I think that specifically the CL-to-EL bit should be removed, but EL-to-EL or CL-to-CL could perhaps stay.
RedOranje- Admin
- Club Supported :
Posts : 11099
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Are players really going to want to jump ship just because they got knocked out of the CL?
I mean, maybe if that club wasn't making CL next season and they got knocked out, but otherwise I don't see that happening.
I mean, maybe if that club wasn't making CL next season and they got knocked out, but otherwise I don't see that happening.
CBarca- NEVER a Mod
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20394
Join date : 2011-06-17
Age : 27
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
We signed two players from clubs who got knocked out of CL in January.
Great Leader Sprucenuce- Forum Legend
- Club Supported :
Posts : 68988
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 34
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:We signed two players from clubs who got knocked out of CL in January.
Is that why they moved?
Debuchy already wanted to move to you guys in the summer. I don't know anything about Gouffran.
CBarca- NEVER a Mod
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20394
Join date : 2011-06-17
Age : 27
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Mbiwa was the other one.... Gouffran was from Bordeaux.
Also i don't know, i'm just saying that because they get knocked out of CL don't mean they don't want to move.
Also i don't know, i'm just saying that because they get knocked out of CL don't mean they don't want to move.
Great Leader Sprucenuce- Forum Legend
- Club Supported :
Posts : 68988
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 34
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
Oops.
My point is that I don't exactly get the rule, because I don't see players abandoning their club just because they got knocked out. They'd need more reasons than that or wanted to move in the first place (like Debuchy).
EL to EL is even less likely, and then moving between the competitions and being cup tied is just stupid IMO.
I guess I don't really see the point in the rule.
My point is that I don't exactly get the rule, because I don't see players abandoning their club just because they got knocked out. They'd need more reasons than that or wanted to move in the first place (like Debuchy).
EL to EL is even less likely, and then moving between the competitions and being cup tied is just stupid IMO.
I guess I don't really see the point in the rule.
CBarca- NEVER a Mod
- Club Supported :
Posts : 20394
Join date : 2011-06-17
Age : 27
Re: Should the rule regarding Cup-tied players not being able to play in CL/EL after a transfer be removed?
I agree with this.Zealous wrote:It would make things much more interesting for sure. ( Balo vs Barca )
But I think there should be conditions. Like you can't play if you already played a set number of minutes with a team that has been knocked out of the CL already or something like that.
Milan31- First Team
- Club Supported :
Posts : 1366
Join date : 2012-02-05
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» If your team's players would play a role in a movie, who would they be?
» Why English players don't play for leagues outside the EPL???
» How can some players smoke and still be able to play professional football
» Short players who play the lone striker role
» Players who went unoticed this transfer window.
» Why English players don't play for leagues outside the EPL???
» How can some players smoke and still be able to play professional football
» Short players who play the lone striker role
» Players who went unoticed this transfer window.
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Today at 12:34 pm by Myesyats
» Kobbie Mainoo Watch
Today at 12:07 pm by Glory
» GL NBA fantasy 23-24
Today at 7:02 am by El Gunner
» Transfer Rumours V6
Today at 3:59 am by Myesyats
» The Official Final Fantasy thread
Yesterday at 8:41 pm by BarrileteCosmico
» The Official PlayStation 1 Gaming Threads
Yesterday at 7:34 pm by Vibe
» La Liga 2023/24
Yesterday at 6:34 pm by Nivash
» Lamine Yamal Hype thread
Yesterday at 12:02 pm by El Gunner
» General Games Discussion
Tue Mar 26, 2024 12:36 pm by Myesyats
» De Rossi
Tue Mar 26, 2024 12:02 pm by rincon
» The Official Dwayne Wade <<<<<< you thread
Mon Mar 25, 2024 9:40 am by Vibe
» France NT News, Formations & Results
Mon Mar 25, 2024 3:16 am by BarcaLearning
» The Official Real Madrid 23 - 24 Matchday Thread
Sun Mar 24, 2024 9:42 pm by The Madrid One