Oscar vs Wilshere

gunnerlistick wrote:

The Ostracised One wrote:

REWB wrote:

wilshere goes missing when up against manutd?? ummm i only remember one game where he went missing and that was this season, when he just came back from injury. soo..fail comment

TBF Arsenal generally go missing agaisnt us.Either way comparing Carrick to Wilshere is like comparing Isco to Xabi Alonso. Come back to me when Wilshere has achieved anything in his career

Still better than Cleverley and Carrick

better than Clev, yea, Carrick? Please gtfo. Again come to me when Wilshere has achieved something in his career.

The Ostracised One wrote:

gunnerlistick wrote:

The Ostracised One wrote:

TBF Arsenal generally go missing agaisnt us.Either way comparing Carrick to Wilshere is like comparing Isco to Xabi Alonso. Come back to me when Wilshere has achieved anything in his career

Still better than Cleverley and Carrick

better than Clev, yea, Carrick? Please gtfo. Again come to me when Wilshere has achieved something in his career.

Jack got into the England side with ease, Carrick can't even get a sniff

gunnerlistick wrote:

The Ostracised One wrote:

gunnerlistick wrote:

Still better than Cleverley and Carrick

better than Clev, yea, Carrick? Please gtfo. Again come to me when Wilshere has achieved something in his career.

Jack got into the England side with ease, Carrick can't even get a sniff

Scholes was played on the wings to accomaodate Gerard and lampard. LOL...

The Ostracised One wrote:

gunnerlistick wrote:

The Ostracised One wrote:

TBF Arsenal generally go missing agaisnt us.Either way comparing Carrick to Wilshere is like comparing Isco to Xabi Alonso. Come back to me when Wilshere has achieved anything in his career

Still better than Cleverley and Carrick

better than Clev, yea, Carrick? Please gtfo. Again come to me when Wilshere has achieved something in his career.

He has won the U18 FA CUP

highburied wrote:

The Ostracised One wrote:

gunnerlistick wrote:

Still better than Cleverley and Carrick

better than Clev, yea, Carrick? Please gtfo. Again come to me when Wilshere has achieved something in his career.

He has won the U18 FA CUP

Jives insinuating that Carrick is better than Wilshere

Jives, pls

lol carrick cant even get into the england side, please.

Why do you compare CAM/AMs with CMs in rightback threads?
If you want a proper comparison go with Wilshere vs. Gündogan, around same position, age and impact

I really don't get why two players in different positions can't be compared. It's like comparing Messi vs Bramble as footballers. Messi's embarrassingly the better footballer, without a doubt

Wilshere has to leave the second tier to show he's as good as Carrick.
Right now he's a skinny le tissier

Im sorry cyberman, i like carrick, but he is just a poor mans busquests

wilshere better in center midfield, oscar better in attacking midfield.

and yea i agree that it should be ramires vs wilshere, they are more similar, oscar's a different kind of player.

More people are joining the Oscar bandwagon, his performances have improved slowly but truly. Technically speaking he is steps above Wilshere and his reading of the game is unrivaled for a player of his age. He is bound to be a better player than Wilshere in my opinion, if he isn't already.

Oscar is a very ordinary player. The most interesting thing about him is his name. Got some good qualities but is not remarkable in any way.

Diego Armando Maradona wrote:Oscar is a very ordinary player. The most interesting thing about him is his name. Got some good qualities but is not remarkable in any way.

Joker

the only remarkable thing about Wilshere is his injury rate.

Carrick is better than Wilshere... and it's not even up for debate.

Wilshere vs Oscar is a different story. They're very close. It's more personal preference rather than "who's better" as they both have the same type of quality. They're two different type of players with that said, but play in the same role. Arsenal fans will obviously say Wilshere and Chelsea fans will obviously say Oscar. But at the end of the day, it really depends on what type of system you want to play and then you picking the player to play your preferred system.

With all that said, I'd have to say Oscar seem's better in the final third and Wilshere is better playing from deeper in midfield.

Diego Armando Maradona wrote:Oscar is a very ordinary player. The most interesting thing about him is his name. Got some good qualities but is not remarkable in any way.

Wat.

His decision making and intelligence is off the charts.

Wilshere is superior to that South American deceiver. It appears having Brazil as your nationality seem sto impair peoples judgements and perceptions of your latent ability.

Is it just me or did you just call everyone who supports Brazil a retard?

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:

Diego Armando Maradona wrote:Oscar is a very ordinary player. The most interesting thing about him is his name. Got some good qualities but is not remarkable in any way.

Wat.

His decision making and intelligence is off the charts.

Based on?

But ok, I don't know why I was that harsh on him, i must have been tired. But seriously I don't think oscar is quite up there with the more talented young players

Diego Armando Maradona wrote:

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:

Diego Armando Maradona wrote:Oscar is a very ordinary player. The most interesting thing about him is his name. Got some good qualities but is not remarkable in any way.

Wat.

His decision making and intelligence is off the charts.

Based on?

But ok, I don't know why I was that harsh on him, i must have been tired. But seriously I don't think oscar is quite up there with the more talented young players

I love Arsenal's fans

moutinho wrote:More people are joining the Oscar bandwagon, his performances have improved slowly but truly. Technically speaking he is steps above Wilshere and his reading of the game is unrivaled for a player of his age. He is bound to be a better player than Wilshere in my opinion, if he isn't already.

Thats because Wilshere hasn't played much in the last 2 years. From being in the same group as Thiago/Kroos/Gundogan he doesn't get mentioned because of his lack of playing time.

Wait till next season.

moutinho wrote:More people are joining the Oscar bandwagon, his performances have improved slowly but truly. Technically speaking he is steps above Wilshere and his reading of the game is unrivaled for a player of his age. He is bound to be a better player than Wilshere in my opinion, if he isn't already.

Thats because Wilshere hasn't played much in the last 2 years. From being in the same group as Thiago/Kroos/Gundogan he doesn't get mentioned because of his lack of playing.

Wait till next season.