Should the two goals really be called off??

i think the one is a sure goal.

Fellaine was onside for his goal....that should've counted

This game was absolutely incredible. One of the most entertaining game of this season already. Everton are playing some beautiful football.

Both of them were goals imo.

Honestly we got lucky, the ref and the 2 linesmen were terrible all game. Really hope we start playing better as the season goes on.

1. Its the linesman fault not the refs
2. The free kick that led to the anichebe disallowed goal should never have been given in the first place
3. We had 3 players running at howard with no defenders in sight and it was called back for no reason
4. Fellaini stamped on Williamson yet no red card

The officiating was awful for both sides

It was en even match, beautiful to watch for neutrals.

I didnt know who to cheer for but then Mole came to my mind



..... And I cheered for Everton.

They say these things even themselves out like for us somewhat, offside goal vs Reading & then next game 2 clear pennos not given.

It was a fantastic game, I nearly went to bed at half-time coz was quite tired and had an early morning coming up, but luckily this girl kept me up by chatting me on facebook and I ended up watching the second-half, too. Terrific stuff.

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:
3. We had 3 players running at howard with no defenders in sight and it was called back for no reason

This call was what annoyed me the most. Offsides and centimetres-over-the-line calls are very difficult, I mean, put yourself in the linesman's shoes and ask yourself would you have been able to say with a hundred percent certainty that it was a goal?

But not playing the advantage on the foul on Ben Arfa was piss poor refereeing, it was such a basic decision to make and not being able to see the situation was not an issue. I doubt I'll see a worse refereeing decision made this season.

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:1. Its the linesman fault not the refs
2. The free kick that led to the anichebe disallowed goal should never have been given in the first place
3. We had 3 players running at howard with no defenders in sight and it was called back for no reason
4. Fellaini stamped on Williamson yet no red card

The officiating was awful for both sides

Oh come on That 3 on 1 chance couldve been a goal.....Ours were goals that were incorrectly not given.That 2nd goal was a mile in ffs.Wrong free kicks happen plenty every game,get over it.

RefCastle United

Just watched the highlights.

Everton could possibly be the toughest away game for any team in the EPL.
With depth now both upfront and on the wings this team can achieve something this year.

Mirallas

Shrekkisfat wrote:

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:1. Its the linesman fault not the refs
2. The free kick that led to the anichebe disallowed goal should never have been given in the first place
3. We had 3 players running at howard with no defenders in sight and it was called back for no reason
4. Fellaini stamped on Williamson yet no red card

The officiating was awful for both sides

Oh come on That 3 on 1 chance couldve been a goal.....Ours were goals that were incorrectly not given.That 2nd goal was a mile in ffs.Wrong free kicks happen plenty every game,get over it.

Point is if the ref was doing his job your disallowed goal doesn't even happen and again if the ref was doing his job and sent Fellaini off then he's not there to score the offside goal.

Your complaining about the ref ( even though it's the linesman fault not his) but if the ref made the correct calls then your disallowed goals don't happen anyway.

Also it wasn't even 3 on 1 Ben Arfa was past the last defender with Ba and Cisse either side of him and it was pulled back for no reason.

Let's not act like it all went our way, there's 3 key decisions there that went your way.

Fellaini being sent off like he should have done would have swung the match heavily in our favour, the free kick that we have already discussed and not playing the advantage when we only have the GK to beat with 3 forwards bearing down on goal.

There was also another occasion when Ben Arfa had 1 defender to beat and the ref didn't play advantage.

I don't deny they were both poor decisions but there was poor decisions that heavily effected the game for both sides.

The ref and the linesman was poor for both sides.

Hahaha...& then they say Serie A is corrupted...

Cotes wrote:Hahaha...& then they say Serie A is corrupted...

go back to ur dugout son, you looking for the wrong battle

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:1. Its the linesman fault not the refs
2. The free kick that led to the anichebe disallowed goal should never have been given in the first place
3. We had 3 players running at howard with no defenders in sight and it was called back for no reason
4. Fellaini stamped on Williamson yet no red card

The officiating was awful for both sides

ok my bad. it was the linesman fault... though they are both part of the officials... LOL i just think the one goal should be awarded... i've been watching the replays for several times already and i still have the same call.

Everton were robbed...

Cotes wrote:Hahaha...& then they say Serie A is corrupted...

The winner of the BPL isn't determined in court.

Am I doing it right?