Boateng> Robinho? Bonera>Mexes?

Giovanni10 wrote:thanks for the neg rep in me sharing an opinion..

Anyways, I'm not a noob.. as far as I'm concerned, attack is attack and I meant attack on the whole so that can encompass: AM, SS, WF, ST, CF

Where KP is concerned, his technique should limit him CM or CM box to box at the most. He should not be up in a attack, he wastes possession.

As far as Robinho goes, since you're looking for clarification, he is not good enough for Milan at all. He is does not have the acquired awareness form an adequate attacking partnership with any of the players I previously mentioned. He most assuredly always picks the wrong option in possession and needs about 10 opportunities to score 1 goal.

I have to disagree with your opinion of Robinho. He's actually the unsung hero of our attack and adds a whole new dimension to the way we play. He's really our only player who consistently runs at defenders and his movement causes opposing defenders all sorts of problems. I'm really not sure if you've watched enough Milan games to make a judgment on this as most ppl would agree that Binho has been immense for us.

You're spot on with Boateng though, he's pretty average as an attacking midfielder. Hopefully in a deeper role he can be more effective. Tbh my best formation wouldn't include him in the starting 11.

Cookie Monster wrote:

Giovanni10 wrote:thanks for the neg rep in me sharing an opinion..

Anyways, I'm not a noob.. as far as I'm concerned, attack is attack and I meant attack on the whole so that can encompass: AM, SS, WF, ST, CF

Where KP is concerned, his technique should limit him CM or CM box to box at the most. He should not be up in a attack, he wastes possession.

As far as Robinho goes, since you're looking for clarification, he is not good enough for Milan at all. He is does not have the acquired awareness form an adequate attacking partnership with any of the players I previously mentioned. He most assuredly always picks the wrong option in possession and needs about 10 opportunities to score 1 goal.

I have to disagree with your opinion of Robinho. He's actually the unsung hero of our attack and adds a whole new dimension to the way we play. He's really our only player who consistently runs at defenders and his movement causes opposing defenders all sorts of problems. I'm really not sure if you've watched enough Milan games to make a judgment on this as most ppl would agree that Binho has been immense for us.

You're spot on with Boateng though, he's pretty average as an attacking midfielder. Hopefully in a deeper role he can be more effective. Tbh my best formation wouldn't include him in the starting 11.

I agree with you on Robinho, because, for whatever reason he seems work well with Ibra, and is much more consistent with Cassano who has one great game and then 2 anonymous ones. So far, the bad finishing that haunted Robinho last season hasn't been evident this season.

As for Boateng, I have never seen so much criticism of a player who just scored in the previous game. I don't want him in AM either, but give credit where credit is due people.

Yeah Boateng has certainly been getting a lot of heat lately. Perhaps the group of us that have been critical of him have been a little too harsh.

He did score a spectacular goal against BATE though and he deserves applause for that effort. However, the goal masks the fact that he was anonymous for the majority of the game and provided very little both offensively and defensively.

Unfortunately, until we get some new midfielders (hopefully in January), Boateng will have to do. Who knows, maybe he'll excel in a box to box midfielder role.

I think Allegri will slowley drop Prince into the midfield three and have Robinho fill the role of AM. Nocerino should move to CDM, he is best in that position

Cookie Monster wrote:

Giovanni10 wrote:thanks for the neg rep in me sharing an opinion..

Anyways, I'm not a noob.. as far as I'm concerned, attack is attack and I meant attack on the whole so that can encompass: AM, SS, WF, ST, CF

Where KP is concerned, his technique should limit him CM or CM box to box at the most. He should not be up in a attack, he wastes possession.

As far as Robinho goes, since you're looking for clarification, he is not good enough for Milan at all. He is does not have the acquired awareness form an adequate attacking partnership with any of the players I previously mentioned. He most assuredly always picks the wrong option in possession and needs about 10 opportunities to score 1 goal.

I have to disagree with your opinion of Robinho. He's actually the unsung hero of our attack and adds a whole new dimension to the way we play. He's really our only player who consistently runs at defenders and his movement causes opposing defenders all sorts of problems. I'm really not sure if you've watched enough Milan games to make a judgment on this as most ppl would agree that Binho has been immense for us.

You're spot on with Boateng though, he's pretty average as an attacking midfielder. Hopefully in a deeper role he can be more effective. Tbh my best formation wouldn't include him in the starting 11.

Yeah, I watch most Milan SerieA games and Champions League games, one of my favourite outfits. In fact, unless they are playing at exactly the same time as Real Madrid, I will watch them.

Maybe my evaluation of Robinho is over-critical because I know he has still not reached the same heights as his season under Schuster at Real Madrid. I'm sure that is the Robinho that Milanisti are waiting patiently to see, maybe this season who knows? Based on his performances last year, that is still far from the Robinho that developed into a player Man City decided to pay almost 40mil euros for. He needs to shape up or ship out.

Giovanni10 wrote:

Cookie Monster wrote:

Giovanni10 wrote:thanks for the neg rep in me sharing an opinion..

Anyways, I'm not a noob.. as far as I'm concerned, attack is attack and I meant attack on the whole so that can encompass: AM, SS, WF, ST, CF

Where KP is concerned, his technique should limit him CM or CM box to box at the most. He should not be up in a attack, he wastes possession.

As far as Robinho goes, since you're looking for clarification, he is not good enough for Milan at all. He is does not have the acquired awareness form an adequate attacking partnership with any of the players I previously mentioned. He most assuredly always picks the wrong option in possession and needs about 10 opportunities to score 1 goal.

I have to disagree with your opinion of Robinho. He's actually the unsung hero of our attack and adds a whole new dimension to the way we play. He's really our only player who consistently runs at defenders and his movement causes opposing defenders all sorts of problems. I'm really not sure if you've watched enough Milan games to make a judgment on this as most ppl would agree that Binho has been immense for us.

You're spot on with Boateng though, he's pretty average as an attacking midfielder. Hopefully in a deeper role he can be more effective. Tbh my best formation wouldn't include him in the starting 11.

Yeah, I watch most Milan SerieA games and Champions League games, one of my favourite outfits. In fact, unless they are playing at exactly the same time as Real Madrid, I will watch them.

Maybe my evaluation of Robinho is over-critical because I know he has still not reached the same heights as his season under Schuster at Real Madrid. I'm sure that is the Robinho that Milanisti are waiting patiently to see, maybe this season who knows? Based on his performances last year, that is still far from the Robinho that developed into a player Man City decided to pay almost 40mil euros for. He needs to shape up or ship out.

IMHO that is too harsh. I admit, I was a HUGE critic of Robinho last season, and you can even dig up a thread of me in early last season calling for his head. But to say that this season he has been disappointing is far too harsh IMO. He has outperformed both Cassano and Pato and has been a critical part of our attack.

As for Prince, for those of you who criticize him, well... How can you really?

He has been a great addition to our midfield this season, not to mention the fact that he scored one hell of a goal just a couple days ago.

I'll put this in bold:

I firmly believe Robinho is our best choice for the AM position.

That being said, Prince is a more than capable back up. With being absolutely no reason to rush Robinho game back in a game that would've been a sure win, Prince is more than capable of fulfilling the role. Why some people criticized Allegri is beyond me.